Author Topic: The manner in which they “worked” for the Smith was brilliant?  (Read 9980 times)

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline Luz

Re: The manner in which they “worked” for the Smith was brilliant?
« Reply #45 on: September 19, 2013, 12:07:05 PM »
Carana posted an article yesterday who h relates a conversation Mr Amaral had with a former colleague.

www.joana-morais.blogspot.com/2008/10/mccanns-knew-that-i-was-going-to-catch.html



What does this comment mean??


GA – Among other things. It was one of the best games that I ever saw played out, to divert attention from what really happened in the apartment. The manner in which they “worked” for the Smith was brilliant.


I've read some of the posts made about this OP. With some I agree with others not so much.

My interpretation about what Amaral said about the way the Smith's testimony was used is that, once the testimony was produced and divulged there was no way to avoid it, so there was an attempt to integrate it with the former testimony given by Ms. Tanner.

But as long as I can recall by memory, the sight Jane acknowledged pointed to a time between 9:15 and 9:20, where she saw a person carrying a bundle/child going to the right (northwards), which is outwards from the village center. However 30 or 35 minutes later, that same "abductor" was seen by the Smiths in the south center of the village. So an abductor was carrying an abducted child in its arms around the village for more than half an hour? Odd at the least.

Offline sadie

Re: The manner in which they “worked” for the Smith was brilliant?
« Reply #46 on: September 19, 2013, 12:17:32 PM »
It is absolutely incredible that an abduction took place at this time - if you believe it did. And right under the noses of Gerry and Jeremy as well.

Personally I do believe there was an abduction, but I think the fact that there were so many people hovering around at this time casts doubt on their being a team of abductors. The more people around, the greater chance of detection. Hard to believe none of the checkers had the slightest inkling of two or three other men creeping around at the same time. Only benefit to having a team is having look-outs  - who obviously weren't doing their job properly given that Gerry and Jez were so close by. Astonishing luck.
Sherlock, i have faith in you as having more logic than most ... yet you seem to have missed the point in sadies theory.

The watcher was waiting for when the Mccanns, especially, had done their check .
.. and no doubt trying to work out when other members of the group would be doing theirs. 
Matt had done his check at 9pm. 
Gerry had done his between 9 .05 and 9.15 ish. 
The watcher was not to know that Jane and Russells duaghter was sick, so unusual journeys were taking place
========================

RUSSELLS STATEMENT
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/RUSSELL-OBRIEN.htm

WITNESS STATEMENT

Name: Russell James O'Brien
Date: 2007/05/11

Extract:

- Regarding the night period, affirms that, on this day, around 19H15/19H30 he went to his apartment. Told his daughters some stories, having stayed with Evie O'Brien, who was a little better but had a hard time sleeping. Meanwhile, his companion Jane went to dinner in the restaurant the Tapas around 20H35/20H40 with the deponent going around 20H45. As the menu was always the same, the group already knew what plates made up the menu, for this reason the deponent told his wife what he wanted, and that she place the order, while he tried to put Evie down.
- When he arrived at the restaurant, all the adults were there, without the children. David and Fiona were missing and Dianne Webster. They arrived more or less 10 minutes after.
- Around 2100 they ordered dinner.
- As was normal, in more or less every 15/30 minutes, one person from each apartment would go to the apartments/rooms to check on the children and if they were well. On that day, as Evie O'Brien was ill, this time was reduced.
- He remembers that Matthew Oldfield left the restaurant, around 21H00, having gone to the apartments to ensure that no noise was coming from within.
- He is not sure who left first. But has the notion that, about five minutes after, Gerry McCann went to check on his children. Around 5 or 10 minutes after Gerry McCann had left, the deponent's companion, Jane Tanner, also left, to check personally on how her two children were doing. He does remember is Jane or Gerry arrived first but remembers that Jane commented on having passed Gerry on the road, and that he was talking to another guest in the same locale, named Jez.
- Around 21h25, taking advantage of a pause in the service of the first plate, the deponent left the restaurant with Matthew Oldfield to check on the children. He arrived at his apartment and immediately heard his daughter Evie crying and stayed in the apartment. He believes that Matthew Oldfield went to his apartment, and is not aware if he was going to also check on the McCann children and went to the deponent's apartment and asked him if he needed help.
- Matthew Oldfield returned to the restaurant, having told Jane Tanner that the deponent stayed behind with Evie O'Brien because she was crying.
- The truth is that after the crying, the deponent had to change all the sheets and his daughter's clothing as she had vomited.
- His companion came to change places with him 15 minutes after and told him to go finish dinner.
- Around 21H55, he returned to the restaurant, having stayed there for 5/10 minutes waiting to be served his plate. At this point, all the others had already finished eating

[Finish extract]

===================================



Because the watcher:
- had no knowledge that Russell and Janes daughter was poorly and restless,
- he had seen Matt check the window, Gerry go in and check then leave down the steps .... and turn down the road. 
- From his place tuckeed back in the shadows on that nalcony he couldn't see Gerry had stopped and was quietly talking with Jez. 
- He was not expecting Jane to appear so soon after Matts check

...... So he gave the go ahead 



Have no doubt about it, the actual abduction, if via the front door using a key, could have taken less than a minute.  I have a blue disability badge as I walk badly and I did it easily in less than a minute.

Try it yourself, Sherlock

1) open a door using the key
2) Walk to the bedroom
3) open the blinds and window
4) walk over to Madeleines bed.  Administer something
5) Lift Madeleine ans walk out of the flat
6) Pass Madeleine over to bundleman

Try it yourself ... I think you will Sherlock




btw, thankyou for reading sadies theory ... and considering it more than once.  It is only a theory, but a lot of thought has gone into it ... and it seems to fit in every way

Some seem to have nade a point of not reading it, but if they are determined NOT to open up their minds, then that is up to them !  ?>)()<

Lyall

  • Guest
Re: The manner in which they “worked” for the Smith was brilliant?
« Reply #47 on: September 19, 2013, 12:22:22 PM »
So there were three of them? Watcher, Bundleman & Tom Cruise? >@@(*&)

Offline sadie

Re: The manner in which they “worked” for the Smith was brilliant?
« Reply #48 on: September 19, 2013, 12:28:53 PM »
So there were three of them? Watcher, Bundleman & Tom Cruise? >@@(*&)
Yep, probably.  Could have done it with two, but more difficult

You seem to take the loss of a child very flippantly  (Tom Cruise) !  Not funny really making silly remarks about the loss of a child

People are reading.  You are letting yourself down again.

Lyall

  • Guest
Re: The manner in which they “worked” for the Smith was brilliant?
« Reply #49 on: September 19, 2013, 12:33:45 PM »
Just banter Sadie. If we took this disappearance flippantly none of us would be here.

So the watcher saw GM come down the steps from the patio doors but couldn't see him talking to JW just a few feet away? How did that happen?

Offline sadie

Re: The manner in which they “worked” for the Smith was brilliant?
« Reply #50 on: September 19, 2013, 04:03:10 PM »
Just banter Sadie. If we took this disappearance flippantly none of us would be here.

So the watcher saw GM come down the steps from the patio doors but couldn't see him talking to JW just a few feet away? How did that happen?
Read sadies theory, then you will know

Offline Sherlock Holmes

Re: The manner in which they “worked” for the Smith was brilliant?
« Reply #51 on: September 19, 2013, 09:59:13 PM »
Sherlock, i have faith in you as having more logic than most ... yet you seem to have missed the point in sadies theory.

The watcher was waiting for when the Mccanns, especially, had done their check .
.. and no doubt trying to work out when other members of the group would be doing theirs. 
Matt had done his check at 9pm. 
Gerry had done his between 9 .05 and 9.15 ish. 
The watcher was not to know that Jane and Russells duaghter was sick, so unusual journeys were taking place
========================

RUSSELLS STATEMENT
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/RUSSELL-OBRIEN.htm

WITNESS STATEMENT

Name: Russell James O'Brien
Date: 2007/05/11

Extract:

- Regarding the night period, affirms that, on this day, around 19H15/19H30 he went to his apartment. Told his daughters some stories, having stayed with Evie O'Brien, who was a little better but had a hard time sleeping. Meanwhile, his companion Jane went to dinner in the restaurant the Tapas around 20H35/20H40 with the deponent going around 20H45. As the menu was always the same, the group already knew what plates made up the menu, for this reason the deponent told his wife what he wanted, and that she place the order, while he tried to put Evie down.
- When he arrived at the restaurant, all the adults were there, without the children. David and Fiona were missing and Dianne Webster. They arrived more or less 10 minutes after.
- Around 2100 they ordered dinner.
- As was normal, in more or less every 15/30 minutes, one person from each apartment would go to the apartments/rooms to check on the children and if they were well. On that day, as Evie O'Brien was ill, this time was reduced.
- He remembers that Matthew Oldfield left the restaurant, around 21H00, having gone to the apartments to ensure that no noise was coming from within.
- He is not sure who left first. But has the notion that, about five minutes after, Gerry McCann went to check on his children. Around 5 or 10 minutes after Gerry McCann had left, the deponent's companion, Jane Tanner, also left, to check personally on how her two children were doing. He does remember is Jane or Gerry arrived first but remembers that Jane commented on having passed Gerry on the road, and that he was talking to another guest in the same locale, named Jez.
- Around 21h25, taking advantage of a pause in the service of the first plate, the deponent left the restaurant with Matthew Oldfield to check on the children. He arrived at his apartment and immediately heard his daughter Evie crying and stayed in the apartment. He believes that Matthew Oldfield went to his apartment, and is not aware if he was going to also check on the McCann children and went to the deponent's apartment and asked him if he needed help.
- Matthew Oldfield returned to the restaurant, having told Jane Tanner that the deponent stayed behind with Evie O'Brien because she was crying.
- The truth is that after the crying, the deponent had to change all the sheets and his daughter's clothing as she had vomited.
- His companion came to change places with him 15 minutes after and told him to go finish dinner.
- Around 21H55, he returned to the restaurant, having stayed there for 5/10 minutes waiting to be served his plate. At this point, all the others had already finished eating

[Finish extract]

===================================



Because the watcher:
- had no knowledge that Russell and Janes daughter was poorly and restless,
- he had seen Matt check the window, Gerry go in and check then leave down the steps .... and turn down the road. 
- From his place tuckeed back in the shadows on that nalcony he couldn't see Gerry had stopped and was quietly talking with Jez. 
- He was not expecting Jane to appear so soon after Matts check

...... So he gave the go ahead 



Have no doubt about it, the actual abduction, if via the front door using a key, could have taken less than a minute.  I have a blue disability badge as I walk badly and I did it easily in less than a minute.

Try it yourself, Sherlock

1) open a door using the key
2) Walk to the bedroom
3) open the blinds and window
4) walk over to Madeleines bed.  Administer something
5) Lift Madeleine ans walk out of the flat
6) Pass Madeleine over to bundleman

Try it yourself ... I think you will Sherlock




btw, thankyou for reading sadies theory ... and considering it more than once.  It is only a theory, but a lot of thought has gone into it ... and it seems to fit in every way

Some seem to have nade a point of not reading it, but if they are determined NOT to open up their minds, then that is up to them !  ?>)()<

Sadie,

The principles of deduction, with regard to the question of how many abductors there were, tell us that until evidence presents itself showing that the abduction could not have been executed by one person single-handedly, there is no logic in introducing more people into the equation. If a second - or third - person is present by implication, or if physical evidence suggesting another person comes to light, that is significant. But if only one person's presence is necessary according to the facts that are currently available, then suggesting the involvement of others is just inventing fictional characters.

This is not to say that there wasn't, or could not have been, a team of abductors at 5A, or that there weren't people involved in the operation behind the scenes or further along the line, merely that we should remember that there is absolutely nothing whatsoever to imply the involvement of more than one person in Madeleine's physical removal from the apartment, according to the knowledge we have today.

If anything, there are elements in the timeline which would hint to - though not of course go as far as to prove, as we are not a hundred per cent sure of their veracity - the presence of a lone abductor: two sightings of a man on foot, each time operating alone; the taking of Madeleine within the close presence and earshot of Gerry McCann and Jez, suggesting there was no look-out; the possibility that the abductor was in the apartment at the same time as Gerry, again, a suggestion that there was no lookout.

I know your theory produces answers for all these things, but these answers involve the introduction of fresh abductors, for whom, so far, we have neither physical evidence nor logical necessity.

I agree with you that Bundleman could have entered the apartment, sedated Madeleine, opened the window, and left again, within a very short space of time. Whatever happened, we know from the timeline that it must have been fast. But crucially, all these things could easily have been performed with only one pair of hands.

Offline sadie

Re: The manner in which they “worked” for the Smith was brilliant?
« Reply #52 on: September 20, 2013, 12:37:29 AM »
Sadie,

The principles of deduction, with regard to the question of how many abductors there were, tell us that until evidence presents itself showing that the abduction could not have been executed by one person single-handedly, there is no logic in introducing more people into the equation. If a second - or third - person is present by implication, or if physical evidence suggesting another person comes to light, that is significant. But if only one person's presence is necessary according to the facts that are currently available, then suggesting the involvement of others is just inventing fictional characters.

This is not to say that there wasn't, or could not have been, a team of abductors at 5A, or that there weren't people involved in the operation behind the scenes or further along the line, merely that we should remember that there is absolutely nothing whatsoever to imply the involvement of more than one person in Madeleine's physical removal from the apartment, according to the knowledge we have today.

If anything, there are elements in the timeline which would hint to - though not of course go as far as to prove, as we are not a hundred per cent sure of their veracity - the presence of a lone abductor: two sightings of a man on foot, each time operating alone; the taking of Madeleine within the close presence and earshot of Gerry McCann and Jez, suggesting there was no look-out; the possibility that the abductor was in the apartment at the same time as Gerry, again, a suggestion that there was no lookout.

I know your theory produces answers for all these things, but these answers involve the introduction of fresh abductors, for whom, so far, we have neither physical evidence nor logical necessity.

I agree with you that Bundleman could have entered the apartment, sedated Madeleine, opened the window, and left again, within a very short space of time. Whatever happened, we know from the timeline that it must have been fast. But crucially, all these things could easily have been performed with only one pair of hands.
I hear what you are saying Sherlock ... and respect your view.

However my theory is the only one so far that explains certain factors.  Sorry, I am too tired tonight to explore them with you.  However I did run over them when you presented your theory.

Heris theory is a very good one but no marks, or fibres,  on the window frame and sill seem to exclude it to me.  There were other factors too that worried me, including the virtual certainty that the front door was used, cos it would be so obvious to any thief.