Author Topic: Lisbon...beautiful architecture or dark secrets?  (Read 20366 times)

0 Members and 3 Guests are viewing this topic.

Cariad

  • Guest
Re: Lisbon...beautiful architecture or dark secrets?
« Reply #60 on: October 01, 2013, 12:04:44 PM »
What has Cariad done to you, Icabod?

That is not a suitable way to speak to another poster.



If you took the time to look, the answer you need is in front of you. In the website address Cariad posted

http://www.worldpath.net/~minstrel/hobosign.htm

Minstrel/hobo







OMO, but I think you owe Cariad an apology for your rude way of treating her.

No apology necessary. Looking at my first post again, I think I explained myself very poorly. It was a case of me knowing exactly what I meant and assuming everybody else would.

I'm the most left wing person you could ever meet, so I would never make a racist slur against any minority, however, Icabod doesn't know that about me, so might have assumed I was being derogatory about Romany's.
In which case the reaction was justified.

I hope I've cleared it up now though and thank you Sadie for looking out for me.

Anyway, the point I was (not very successfully) trying to make was that there's a long history of people using marking to alert like minded people to something in the area.

I'm still curious if it could simply be a graffiti tag though?

AnneGuedes

  • Guest
Re: Lisbon...beautiful architecture or dark secrets?
« Reply #61 on: October 01, 2013, 12:21:43 PM »
The Hieronymites Monastery was donated by the king of Portugal, who built it, to the monks of a contemplative order who had to celebrate Mass daily for the souls of D. Henrique the Navigator, D. Manuel I and his successors. The monks were expected to glorify the vast deeds of the Portuguese and bring spiritual assistance to sailors in their discovery of other worlds. Vasco da Gama is buried in this monastery.

With the advent of liberalism, in 1833, was decreed the dissolution of the religious orders in Portugal. The community of monks was dissolved, the monastery became State property and the accommodations a school up to 1940.
http://www.mosteirojeronimos.pt/en/index.php?s=atalho&id=37
http://www.casapia.pt/Default.aspx?tabid=67http://

Note: the number of legends and Da Vinci Code style books about the monastery is endless.
So why not insert another myth ?
« Last Edit: October 01, 2013, 12:32:43 PM by AnneGuedes »

Offline faithlilly

Re: Lisbon...beautiful architecture or dark secrets?
« Reply #62 on: October 01, 2013, 12:37:02 PM »
This is the puzzle, John.

I know you are very busy and cant read everything.  This thread is about an Orphanage called Casa Pia where wholesale sexual abuse of children happened a good while ago.  This Orphanage is under the care of the Church, in this case Jeronimos Monastry.  Jeronimos Monastry is one of the most glorious and at a guess expensive buildings in the World.

It has a whiter than white image, purer than pure, yet at the back in nice looking buildings, all this appalling abuse went on - mainly to the deaf mute child.  A couple of years ago, it was still going on according to reports on the internet.

Whilst using my broken GE, I noticed all these hearts painted on various public utility street furniture.  From Mysters images I see they are painted on other places too .... but they are all in the street where the abuse happens, which is a long but quiet street that grubs along the back of Jeronimos Monastry.

Both ends of this street are marked with these hand painted hearts, as seemingly are pertinent points like the Deaf and Dunb school within the Monastries grounds.

Myster and I, maybe others also, are wondering whether they are pointers for evil paedos.   Where to go for their "pleasure".

We are looking for other ideas as to what they could be about.  They are only in this street, it seems ... with both ends of that street marked <<< that alone seems sinister to me, but would be happy if others could think of a sound reason for them other than as markers.


Hope this brief resume helps.  More in the previous posts.

Perhaps they are a permanent mark of sympathy and support for the children who suffered abuse ?

It's actually rather telling sadie that you interpret what would be, to most, a rather benign symbol into something sinister and tawdry.
Brietta posted on 10/04/2022 “But whether or not that is the reason behind the delay I am certain that Brueckner's trial is going to take place.”

Let’s count the months, shall we?

Offline Luz

Re: Lisbon...beautiful architecture or dark secrets?
« Reply #63 on: October 01, 2013, 01:09:33 PM »
I have read the comments from Portugal with great interest.   Could Anne be hinting at the great political divide that still exists in parts of Iberia going back to the more recent civil wars?  I know from my own travels that the resentments in many villages still linger as strong today as it did during the time of the Spanish Civil War when the Portuguese Government came down on the side of the Nationalists against Republicans.  The role of the then Government of Antonio Salazar in providing aid and succor to Nazi Germany must never be underestimated.

I agree with you that Lisbon is a town of many secrets, as all cities in Europe are. But its secretes are far more remote than the twentieth century history.

The relation between what happened in Portugal and what occurred in Spain during the late thirties Spanish Civil War, with Franco, is not as simple as that, nor both countries relations with the Nazis. The Spanish Civil War was absolutely destructive, maybe as much or more than what Germany did, on a smaller scale.

When I was very little (5/6 y. o.) I had a very old friend in my native village, an old man from Barcelona that was a refugee from the Civil War. All his family had been killed in front of his eyes (execution style) and he escaped by foot, eating whatever he could get from the soil, until he arrived in the south of Portugal. In my small village he survived because he was hidden by the inhabitants.  His house, in the middle of the Algarvian mountains, now in ruins, is still looked at as a place of "mystery".

Franco was an open supporter of Germany during the War, although never directly/openly involved in it, as for Salazar, he acted as a surreptitious neutral president that accepted that Portugal acted as a platform for the refugees, but at the same time had covert businesses with Germany and the Allies.

Iberia was not clear  or clean during the WW II, but then, no country was, not even those that were directly involved in it.

Lisbon maintains in fact some places where the mystery of those years (WW II) is still present. It takes a while and some dedication to find them. But it's fascinating. I call Lisbon my home after having lived there for more than 30 years and I still don't know all there is to find about it.

For me, what makes Lisbon a fascinating place, it is not so much the architecture, but the multicultural history. From the more ancient legends, to the more recen templar, the masons, the illuminatti,....you can fin everything and anything.

Even today, if you walk through the oldest parts of it, you find the world condensed in small slices of the city - a bit like London but more plural and in much smaller scale. Last year, a small study with a dozen Lisbon elementary schools, revealed the presence of 291 nationalities among the students.

Dark secrets? Yes, undoubtedly...Which city doesn't have them?

Just a little note: When I applied to College I mistakenly put Lisbon in the first place and I ended being accepted there, but my choice of heart was Porto, because it has the same grey light as London, which I love dearly. In the end, I'm happy I went to Lisbon, and I learned to love the yellow light that makes Lisbon a city for the arts.
« Last Edit: October 01, 2013, 01:17:22 PM by Luz »

stephen25000

  • Guest
Re: Lisbon...beautiful architecture or dark secrets?
« Reply #64 on: October 01, 2013, 01:11:44 PM »
No not to denigrate Portugal but to point on what went on behind the guise of a holier than holier, whiter than white, very rich religious establishment.

... and seemingly might/is still going on.

Are you happy that this might still be going on Stephen?

Are you trying to hide it, by trying to get this thread pulled?  ... Why?  There has to be a reason.




If you cared to read my posts Stephen, you would find that I have visited PT a good number of times and travelled its very beautiful land from North to South, East to West.  You will find that I have praised its people (with a few Fascist type exceptions), its Architecture and its whole ethos (except for certain Judicial departments with Fascist leanings).

This is not about PT per se, but about a certain specific place in Lisboa; an Orphanage attached to a Monastry, which is a magnificent religious place that looks, LOOKS as though it is the most upright place in the World.  Butter wouldn't melt in its mouth sort of place !

And also mention of another two places in PT, both Orphanages



So I repeat,

Are you happy that this might still be going on Stephen?

Are you trying to hide it, by trying to get this thread pulled?  ... Why?  There has to be a reason.


OK.


Let's look at the abuse which takes place in 'establishments' all over the world including the UK.

Or are you trying to attack Portugal because of your obvious bias ?


Offline John

Re: Lisbon...beautiful architecture or dark secrets?
« Reply #65 on: October 01, 2013, 02:20:54 PM »
I agree with you that Lisbon is a town of many secrets, as all cities in Europe are. But its secretes are far more remote than the twentieth century history.

The relation between what happened in Portugal and what occurred in Spain during the late thirties Spanish Civil War, with Franco, is not as simple as that, nor both countries relations with the Nazis. The Spanish Civil War was absolutely destructive, maybe as much or more than what Germany did, on a smaller scale.

When I was very little (5/6 y. o.) I had a very old friend in my native village, an old man from Barcelona that was a refugee from the Civil War. All his family had been killed in front of his eyes (execution style) and he escaped by foot, eating whatever he could get from the soil, until he arrived in the south of Portugal. In my small village he survived because he was hidden by the inhabitants.  His house, in the middle of the Algarvian mountains, now in ruins, is still looked at as a place of "mystery".

Franco was an open supporter of Germany during the War, although never directly/openly involved in it, as for Salazar, he acted as a surreptitious neutral president that accepted that Portugal acted as a platform for the refugees, but at the same time had covert businesses with Germany and the Allies.

Iberia was not clear  or clean during the WW II, but then, no country was, not even those that were directly involved in it.

Lisbon maintains in fact some places where the mystery of those years (WW II) is still present. It takes a while and some dedication to find them. But it's fascinating. I call Lisbon my home after having lived there for more than 30 years and I still don't know all there is to find about it.

For me, what makes Lisbon a fascinating place, it is not so much the architecture, but the multicultural history. From the more ancient legends, to the more recen templar, the masons, the illuminatti,....you can fin everything and anything.

Even today, if you walk through the oldest parts of it, you find the world condensed in small slices of the city - a bit like London but more plural and in much smaller scale. Last year, a small study with a dozen Lisbon elementary schools, revealed the presence of 291 nationalities among the students.

Dark secrets? Yes, undoubtedly...Which city doesn't have them?

Just a little note: When I applied to College I mistakenly put Lisbon in the first place and I ended being accepted there, but my choice of heart was Porto, because it has the same grey light as London, which I love dearly. In the end, I'm happy I went to Lisbon, and I learned to love the yellow light that makes Lisbon a city for the arts.

An extremely interesting post Luz. 

As a Spanish part-time resident I have spent many hours in the company of people who experienced the Franco tyranny towards the small towns and villages of the south at first hand.  I have found that even now in 2013, the hatred of all things Madrid is quite pronounced among the older generation.

I have never been to Portugal as such, just to Madeira, where I found the people so very friendly.  Maybe I will find a reason to visit the motherland in the near future.
« Last Edit: October 01, 2013, 02:27:14 PM by John »
A malicious prosecution for a crime which never existed. An exposé of egregious malfeasance by public officials.
Indeed, the truth never changes with the passage of time.

Offline Luz

Re: Lisbon...beautiful architecture or dark secrets?
« Reply #66 on: October 01, 2013, 02:29:39 PM »
Stephen, don't worry.

Every country has it's dark places.

What I find fascinating is that the same persons that take António Marinho Pinto as an opinion leader, do not take his opinion that Casa Pia is a lie designed to harm the Socialist Government, and the victims are liars (yes, the exact same Socrates Government that sold the Lisbon Treaty to Gordon Brown).

For me Casa Pia's pedophile history is a tragedy for dozens of young man and women. However, I've known and worked with Casa Pia for more than 25 years, and I congratulate the many wonderful professionals that work there, and the many wonderful students that came out of there to become honorable citizens.

stephen25000

  • Guest
Re: Lisbon...beautiful architecture or dark secrets?
« Reply #67 on: October 01, 2013, 02:35:25 PM »
Stephen, don't worry.

Every country has it's dark places.

What I find fascinating is that the same persons that take António Marinho Pinto as an opinion leader, do not take his opinion that Casa Pia is a lie designed to harm the Socialist Government, and the victims are liars (yes, the exact same Socrates Government that sold the Lisbon Treaty to Gordon Brown).

For me Casa Pia's pedophile history is a tragedy for dozens of young man and women. However, I've known and worked with Casa Pia for more than 25 years, and I congratulate the many wonderful professionals that work there, and the many wonderful students that came out of there to become honorable citizens.

Thanks Luz for the information and reply.

Offline Luz

Re: Lisbon...beautiful architecture or dark secrets?
« Reply #68 on: October 01, 2013, 02:40:07 PM »
An extremely interesting post Luz. 

As a Spanish part-time resident I have spent many hours in the company of people who experienced the Franco tyranny towards the small towns and villages of the south at first hand.  I have found that even now in 2013, the hatred of all things Madrid is quite pronounced among the older generation.

I have never been to Portugal as such, just to Madeira, where I found the people so very friendly.  Maybe I will find a reason to visit the motherland in the near future.

You got to, John.

But don't go to the touristic places. If you are in Spain, try travelling by car and stop at the little villages along the frontier. The stories about those Civil War times are overwhelming. There are places on each side of the border where you can still find people that survived the war - when we can get them to talk it's both mind-blowing and emotionally very trying.
I love Madeira, for it's natural beauty, for it's amazing people, but the true miscellaneous Portugal is in the continent. Like Britan, Portugal's history goes back in time, but here there are places where our foundations are still very raw. You'll love it if you don't follow those agency touristic maps.

AnneGuedes

  • Guest
Re: Lisbon...beautiful architecture or dark secrets?
« Reply #69 on: October 01, 2013, 02:54:21 PM »
my choice of heart was Porto, because it has the same grey light as London, which I love dearly. In the end, I'm happy I went to Lisbon, and I learned to love the yellow light that makes Lisbon a city for the arts.
That "grey light" makes natives of Lisbon miss terribly "the" light when they go up north.
Today Lx looks like London btw. Are you coming to-morrow ?

Offline Sherlock Holmes

Re: Lisbon...beautiful architecture or dark secrets?
« Reply #70 on: October 02, 2013, 03:22:58 AM »
Am I talking nonsense again? I'm Pretty sure they were called tramp signs. In the 'olden days' when there was no support system for unemployed people, men would wander from place to place looking for work or beginning at doors if no jobs could be found. They would leave a chalk mark on a the gate of houses they had visited to tell other tramps what treatment to expect at the place. The page of meaningless symbols is a kind of dictionary. Underneath the symbols (in very small lettering) is an explanation of what each sign mean.

I don't mean gypsies or travellers in that sense. These men didn't share an ethnicity or religion, they were just down on their luck.

Yes, Cariad, there is a Sherlock Holmes story involving such sings (one of the original Victorian Conan Doyle stories- I'll have to look it up.)

Sherlock infers from a sign that he sees outside a house that a certain band of tramps are in the vicinity (the sign is a code between tramps, signalling that the house in question is one where charity is often given.) Sherlock dresses up as a tramp and talks to some of them to get inside information about what is going on in the house.

Offline sadie

Re: Lisbon...beautiful architecture or dark secrets?
« Reply #71 on: October 02, 2013, 11:07:43 AM »
So we accept that in certain circumstances "secret" signs are used?

Anyone any idea what these hearts are about?

Someone has gone to some trouble walking thta long street and painting them.


Interestingly, to me anyhow cos I look for anomolies, is the fact that GE "street Scene " facility does NOT go the length of that street.  It misses a chunk out and takes a detour around a very minor insignificant U shaped street.



The piece it misses out?  = the length of road which has the deaf and dumb school on it.  Hmmm?


I wonder why?  >@@(*&).  I have never before seen GE street scene suddenly veer off its main route, make a detour along a road of absolutely no importance ... and return to its main route, further on,  missing a chunk. >@@(*&)

Just have a look and see.  Nothing of any importance alomg that detour route, yet it veers off ... and ruins its main route.

Strange, but does it mean anything?


Do the hearts signify anything?  They are only in that particular street as far as I can see, and both ends of the street are marked

Offline Myster

Re: Lisbon...beautiful architecture or dark secrets?
« Reply #72 on: October 03, 2013, 05:52:43 AM »
I don't think the diversion along the U-shaped road (Praça Malaca) has any significance. The streetview camera-van sometimes makes detours around one-way streets, private and unmetalled roads which the drivers can't or choose not to access. That short straight section containing the green bottle-bank (with the heart) is one-way, as is the whole length of Rua Dom Francisco de Almeida. Perhaps they chose not to, just forgot, or simply couldn't be bothered to drive back along it a second time.

There are four more hearts I've found too - one on the bark of a young tree on the opposite corner of the road to the northern metal utilities box (with two hearts), and on three other trees along the curved part of main Av.Restelo road to the east. If you can be bothered to look they're on either side of a white & grey coach and towards the rear of an artic. lorry parked in a long layby. To see them put the yellow pegman on the first Av.Restelo word on the bend.

That makes a total of eleven, there may be even more going towards the entrance of the Casa Pia to the south.

BTW, you don't need "google earth", just go into google, then click maps, and copy and paste - Jerónimos Monastery, Lisbon, Portugal - in the box.

Just a thought - if coaches/buses park in that layby because they're too large to go down the one-way Rua Dom Francisco de Almeida, could the hearts not just be route indicators for groups of children walking to the school after a coach trip, or from the school before one ?

As someone noted earlier, they could be marks to recognise/acknowledge the victims of past Casa Pia abuse.

Next time you're in the area Sadie, why not call in at the school and ask if those hearts are a project that the kids carried out ?  They might just say yes... and put your mind at rest !



It's one of them cases, in'it... one of them f*ckin' cases.

Offline sadie

Re: Lisbon...beautiful architecture or dark secrets?
« Reply #73 on: October 03, 2013, 09:10:41 AM »
I don't think the diversion along the U-shaped road (Praça Malaca) has any significance. The streetview camera-van sometimes makes detours around one-way streets, private and unmetalled roads which the drivers can't or choose not to access. That short straight section containing the green bottle-bank (with the heart) is one-way, as is the whole length of Rua Dom Francisco de Almeida. Perhaps they chose not to, just forgot, or simply couldn't be bothered to drive back along it a second time.

There are four more hearts I've found too - one on the bark of a young tree on the opposite corner of the road to the northern metal utilities box (with two hearts), and on three other trees along the curved part of main Av.Restelo road to the east. If you can be bothered to look they're on either side of a white & grey coach and towards the rear of an artic. lorry parked in a long layby. To see them put the yellow pegman on the first Av.Restelo word on the bend.

That makes a total of eleven, there may be even more going towards the entrance of the Casa Pia to the south.

BTW, you don't need "google earth", just go into google, then click maps, and copy and paste - Jerónimos Monastery, Lisbon, Portugal - in the box.

Just a thought - if coaches/buses park in that layby because they're too large to go down the one-way Rua Dom Francisco de Almeida, could the hearts not just be route indicators for groups of children walking to the school after a coach trip, or from the school before one ?

As someone noted earlier, they could be marks to recognise/acknowledge the victims of past Casa Pia abuse.

Next time you're in the area Sadie, why not call in at the school and ask if those hearts are a project that the kids carried out ?  They might just say yes... and put your mind at rest !


Thanks myster, you have done a lot of work.  found another two further down in a shop window and door in Rua Jeronimo, behind the three big blue trash bins.  Haven't got time atm, but I am almost sure that this shop is part of Jeronimos Mon and within the area thta has loads of Casa Pia notices, I think indicating that Casa Pia departments lie in that area ..... so, I am guessing, the shop is part of Casa Pia itself.


I follow what you are saying about the children using the hearts as a guide, but somehow that doesn't seem right, cos I think those coach parking spaces are more likely to be for tourists visiting the Monastry.  The road that skirts around the back of Jeronimos is fairly narrow, but little traffic there and quite wide enough for coaches delivering children to the deaf and dumb school.  And leaving space for other vehicles to pass, I would have thought


Gotta get on now.  Will try and come back later

sadie

x

Offline Myster

Re: Lisbon...beautiful architecture or dark secrets?
« Reply #74 on: October 03, 2013, 07:24:32 PM »
Yes it is narrow, (if Rua Dom Francisco de Almeidais is the street you mean) but even narrower if cars are parked on one side, going by the number there in streetview. What coach driver would risk getting stuck in that one-way street, with only a cars width to get through.

I know peoples privacy has to be protected to an extent by blurring out car registrations... but street signs and house numbers ?
Google are rolling in dosh and they can't even afford some decent high-res cameras. I found the 3 blue trash bins, but the shop window was so blurred it was difficult to make out a heart.. then I lost it and couldn't find it again, but if as you say they appear in a shop window/door then they could be something official and inoccuous such as support for a heart charity, a Portuguese equivalent of the British Heart Foundation - for an organised run or a National Heart Week perhaps ? ... and they just haven't got round to removing them.

And that whole Casa Pia complex circling the Monastery is huge with many different departments.

It's one of them cases, in'it... one of them f*ckin' cases.