Did the Joana Cipriano murder inquiry unduly influence the Madeleine one?

[John]

Something which has been mentioned in passing but which I feel should have its own thread.

Did what happened in the Joana Cipriano murder case influence Dr Amaral and his colleagues somewhat in the way they pursued the Madeleine investigation less than three years later?

Leandro Silva, the common-law husband of Leonor Cipriano, commented that "the only difference between the McCanns and us is that we don't have money"

What do you think?

[Benice]

Something which has been mentioned in passing but which I feel should have its own thread.

Did what happened in the Joana Cipriano murder case influence Dr Amaral and his colleagues somewhat in the way they pursued the Madeleine investigation less than three years later?

Leandro Silva, the common-law husband of Leonor Cipriano, commented that "the only difference between the McCanns and us is that we don't have money"

What do you think?

I would agree  that his statement is a fair one.    But would add a further 'difference' in that they were Portuguese and the McCanns were not.

[Lyall]

Something which has been mentioned in passing but which I feel should have its own thread.

Did what happened in the Joana Cipriano murder case influence Dr Amaral and his colleagues somewhat in the way they pursued the Madeleine investigation less than three years later?

Leandro Silva, the common-law husband of Leonor Cipriano, commented that "the only difference between the McCanns and us is that we don't have money"

What do you think?

Influenced in what way John?

[DCI]

Something which has been mentioned in passing but which I feel should have its own thread.

Did what happened in the Joana Cipriano murder case influence Dr Amaral and his colleagues somewhat in the way they pursued the Madeleine investigation less than three years later?

Leandro Silva, the common-law husband of Leonor Cipriano, commented that "the only difference between the McCanns and us is that we don't have money"

What do you think?

But, nobody knows what happened to Joana, only what Amaral, thinks happened.
Just the same as with Madeleine!

Big difference though, Kate couldn't be got at, like Leonor was.
Is that why Amaral took such a dislike to Kate?

[faithlilly]

But, nobody knows what happened to Joana, only what Amaral, thinks happened.
Just the same as with Madeleine!

Big difference though, Kate couldn't be got at, like Leonor was.
Is that why Amaral took such a dislike to Kate?

I always got the feeling Amaral felt pity rather than dislike for Kate.

[Lyall]

But, nobody knows what happened to Joana, only what Amaral, thinks happened.
Just the same as with Madeleine!

Big difference though, Kate couldn't be got at, like Leonor was.
Is that why Amaral took such a dislike to Kate?

Is this a leak of Monday's script?

[jassi]

Is this a leak of Monday's script?

Even if it is, I can't see the relevance to the ongoing SY attempt to discover what happened to Madeleine and it will have no influence on the trial proceedings in Portugal

[Lyall]

Even if it is, I can't see the relevance to the ongoing SY attempt to discover what happened to Madeleine and it will have no influence on the trial proceedings in Portugal

I was just joking Jassi

Sorry

[Lyall]

DCI's analysis is pure wummery, Jassi.

[jassi]

I was just joking Jassi

Sorry

I know, but sadly, you are probably right about it being the script

[sadie]

But, nobody knows what happened to Joana, only what Amaral, thinks happened.
Just the same as with Madeleine!

Big difference though, Kate couldn't be got at, like Leonor was.
Is that why Amaral took such a dislike to Kate?

Exactly, is that why?  Or was she just another woman to bully and denigrate?

[jassi]

Exactly, is that why? Or was she just another woman to bully and denigrate?

Remind me, is this the woman who was convicted of murder?

[Rachel Granada]

Remind me, is this the woman who was convicted of murder?

Yes, that's correct Jassi.

After a "confession" was beaten out of her by the PJ.

[jassi]

Yes, that's correct Jassi.

After a "confession" was beaten out of her by the PJ.

Presumably that counted for nothing at the trial, hence the conviction.

[Redblossom]

Yes, that's correct Jassi.

After a "confession" was beaten out of her by the PJ.

This is not a fact...unless you can provide proof of it, bet you cant though....thats why its another groundhog day discussion.....

I dont understand the question in Johns OP