Author Topic: Mr Smith didn't contact the police for two weeks. Did this harm the search?  (Read 97148 times)

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline Joanne

I have to agree with Xtina.

Offline imustpointout

Topic: How crucial was the Smith delay?

Offline Joanne

As a potenetial witness, very important. As is that of everyone else who was a potential witness.

Offline xtina

Topic: How crucial was the Smith delay?






fgs......I'm not sure when Mr smith reported  to the police.....weather it  was when he  got home or  whatever.....what  i do know is he was ignored [for six years]..

but imustpointout.......their is a hell of a lot more  important issues with this  case ....where people have  let maddie down  ....and IMO one of  them is not  Mr  smith
Always listen to both sides of the story before you judge.

The first storyteller you will always find has modified the story, for there benefit BE WISE.

Cariad

  • Guest
"Their description of the barefoot child and the man, who wore beige trousers, echoes that of Miss Tanner, who said she saw a man carrying a sleeping child away from the McCanns apartment about 9.15pm.
 
Though the Smith family believe they met an almost identical man closer to 10pm, the coincidence prompted them to contact police after they returned to Ireland. Mr Smith said: "Luz is such a small place and so quiet, we felt a duty to tell police and let them decide if it was important."

http://www.mccannfiles.com/id162.html

I'm guessing that they didn't realise the importance of the sighting until they realised how similar it was to JT's. How crucial was the missed opportunity? I guess it could've solved the case 6 years ago. Equally it would've made no difference then.

If this is the lead that breaks open the case, it will be easier to judge what impact that 5 days would've had. I don't think it's fair to knock them for it though. They seem to have thought that it was just some bloke carrying his kid home. As soon as they realised how similar the description was to JT's, they contacted the police.

Offline imustpointout






fgs......I'm not sure when Mr smith reported  to the police.....weather it  was when he  got home or  whatever.....what  i do know is he was ignored [for six years]..

but imustpointout.......their is a hell of a lot more  important issues with this  case ....where people have  let maddie down  ....and IMO one of  them is not  Mr  smith

so you are unable to add to the topic - but you choose to complain about something else.

Offline imustpointout

"Their description of the barefoot child and the man, who wore beige trousers, echoes that of Miss Tanner, who said she saw a man carrying a sleeping child away from the McCanns apartment about 9.15pm.
 
Though the Smith family believe they met an almost identical man closer to 10pm, the coincidence prompted them to contact police after they returned to Ireland. Mr Smith said: "Luz is such a small place and so quiet, we felt a duty to tell police and let them decide if it was important."

http://www.mccannfiles.com/id162.html

I'm guessing that they didn't realise the importance of the sighting until they realised how similar it was to JT's. How crucial was the missed opportunity? I guess it could've solved the case 6 years ago. Equally it would've made no difference then.

If this is the lead that breaks open the case, it will be easier to judge what impact that 5 days would've had. I don't think it's fair to knock them for it though. They seem to have thought that it was just some bloke carrying his kid home. As soon as they realised how similar the description was to JT's, they contacted the police.

of course don't knock them - "they seem to think it was just some bloke carrying his kid home."

Smith said

"He only became aware of the disappearance of the child the next morning, through his daughter, L*****, in Ireland who had sent him a message or called him regarding what had happened. At this point he thought that MADELEINE could have been the child he saw with the individual."
« Last Edit: October 14, 2013, 04:51:06 PM by imustpointout »

Offline imustpointout

"At this point he thought that MADELEINE could have been the child he saw with the individual"

this was on 4/05/07 - before he had left PDL or Portugal

Cariad

  • Guest
of course don't knock them - "they seem to think it was just some bloke carrying his kid home."

Smith said

"He only became aware of the disappearance of the child the next morning, through his daughter, L*****, in Ireland who had sent him a message or called him regarding what had happened. At this point he thought that MADELEINE could have been the child he saw with the individual."

How can we possibly know how crucial the delay was if we don't know what this information will bring in?

It might be crucial, yes, but it might equally be of no importance.

You're demanding that everyone stay on topic, but the topic is "let's speculate about this thing that might be something or nothing".

If this is the information that solves the case then the delay of 5 days for the report then 6 1/2 years for the e-fit was probably crucial.

If it doesn't solve the case, then no it wasn't crucial.

Offline imustpointout

" the delay of 5 days"

what do the Police all over the World say about the initial period and how crucial it is?

Cariad

  • Guest
oh dear was it a difficult question?

Pontification about morals and standards - guesses about how a child could have died - denial of abduction - question every single thing the Mccanns and others say.

But a crucial piece of evidence where somebody states he may have seen Madeleine is just brushed aside - how should we know.

And as admin said in the PM today - there will be a lot of people looking at this forum tonight.

Well done you all - better to get on with arguing with each other isn't it.

Is that directed at me? Or are you just being rude in general?

Offline imustpointout

it was directed at you and was factual not rude.

Offline Kazcutt

It's a shame mr smiths statement on the web don't echo what's coming out now
Ie in the files it says he thinks it's Gerry but in the papers he said the police wasn't interested .so now the smiths are working with sy and the police are supporting the mccanns did mr smith really say it wasn't Murat ?

Offline xtina

so you are unable to add to the topic - but you choose to complain about something else.



he hasn't just  come forward now has he....... he came forward over six year ago

how can you tell with this case ...how crucial it  would have been......when the J/T and  various others took over every thing else...

of topic may by ...bit IMO ...at  least he  had  the guts to say who he   thought it was carrying a  child ....now  that  was  crucial that  he was ignored
Always listen to both sides of the story before you judge.

The first storyteller you will always find has modified the story, for there benefit BE WISE.

Offline imustpointout

It's a shame mr smiths statement on the web don't echo what's coming out now
Ie in the files it says he thinks it's Gerry but in the papers he said the police wasn't interested .so now the smiths are working with sy and the police are supporting the mccanns did mr smith really say it wasn't Murat ?

the only reason he went to the police in the first place was to say it wasn't Murat.