If you are saying that it was wrong of the Portuguese police not to make public the descriptions the Smith family gave of the man they had seen, then I agree with you ... that information should have been put into the public domain
By the same reasoning, though, you must accept that the McCanns should have released the e fits the Smith gave to their private detectives into the public domain too
The Portugeuse police work under the restraint of 'secrecy laws' I believe ... what reason did the McCannns have, though, for keeping those e fit images away from the public ?
Yes that is exactly what I'm saying. amaral had the Smith description from May 2007. Doesn't release it, but has the cheek to use the photofit details, the McCann's had done of Jane's sighting, in his book. Which was actually sent to Paiva in October 2007, by Bob Small courtesy of Gerry. So how did amaral get his mitts on it?
It wasn't the McCann's place to release the Smith sighting, they didn't have it till 2008. According to amaral,
"Their coming to Portugal as well as their statements are kept secret". Why isn't the Estrela CCTV mentioned in the files, or his book? He's now saying this could have shown the abductor carrying Madeleine.
Hello! He thought Madeleine had been harmed and her parents, disposed of her, he wants to make his mind up.
Concidering its got FA do to with him now, he can't keep his neb out, can he?
If I remember correctly, the PJ didn't want anything from the PI's, and ignored it all.
Its no good Amaral prattling on about SY, not finding anything till now, when they have had to sort his mess out, to find crucial evidence that he should have done 6 years ago.