Author Topic: Another look at Tannerman and those pyjamas.  (Read 51712 times)

0 Members and 3 Guests are viewing this topic.

icabodcrane

  • Guest
Re: Another look at Tannerman and those pyjamas.
« Reply #45 on: December 12, 2013, 04:15:00 PM »
I think at all times he uses the words lawyers have advised him to use, Icabod.

As we know it's a very complicated case, and it still carries the potential for further serious legal action.

So we are left guessing at what to read between the lines  ?

My guess would be that Scotland Yard  do  ...  must ...  have a substantive reason for eliminating the Jane Tanner sighting from the investigation  ...   but it is  not that they have definatively identified the person that she  saw  (  because they have not done so by their own admission ) 

What other  reason there may be for them to have  informed  the public that the man Jane saw is of no interest to them   is beyond my guessing range 

Offline Sherlock Holmes

Re: Another look at Tannerman and those pyjamas.
« Reply #46 on: December 12, 2013, 04:15:11 PM »
I think at all times he uses the words lawyers have advised him to use, Icabod.

As we know it's a very complicated case, and it still carries the potential for further serious legal action.

I think that this is the approach.

He has to be very careful to cover himself.

It is a balance, like anything else. He must be pretty convinced that he is correct in eliminating Tannerman. At the same time, he has made mistakes in the past, and knows that he has to be very careful before claiming that he is 100% sure of something.

The elimination of Tannerman is not a minor detail. The entire premise of Crimewatch was that Smithman was now the focus. A big song and dance with trumpets was made about the shifting timeline. (When in reality there's no reason to assume suspects were not in the picture shortly after 9pm just because Tannerman appears to have been innocent). This development (ruling out Tannerman) seems to have shifted their entire focus, and therefore must be based on something solid.

That's why I don't believe, as Anne does, that DCI procured a pair of 'rotten' pjamas  from a  jumble sale simply to placate an impatient public and give the producers of crimewatch something to do of an evening.
« Last Edit: December 12, 2013, 04:18:17 PM by Sherlock Holmes »

Lyall

  • Guest
Re: Another look at Tannerman and those pyjamas.
« Reply #47 on: December 12, 2013, 04:27:13 PM »
I think that this is the approach.

He has to be very careful to cover himself.

It is a balance, like anything else. He must be pretty convinced that he is correct in eliminating Tannerman. At the same time, he has made mistakes in the past, and knows that he has to be very careful before claiming that he is 100% sure of something.

The elimination of Tannerman is not a minor detail. The entire premise of Crimewatch was that Smithman was now the focus. A big song and dance with trumpets was made about the shifting timeline. (When in reality there's no reason to assume suspects were not in the picture shortly after 9pm just because Tannerman appears to have been innocent). This development (ruling out Tannerman) seems to have shifted their entire focus, and therefore must be based on something solid.

That's why I don't believe, as Anne does, that DCI procured a pair of 'rotten' pjamas  from a  jumble sale simply to placate an impatient public and give the producers of crimewatch something to do of an evening.

Maybe they had no choice but to blow those trumpets about 10pm because without the 9.15 'sighting' they were faced with a Crimewatch and had very little else to show?

Cancelling the show would not have gone down well I imagine. Anywhere.

Offline Wonderfulspam

Re: Another look at Tannerman and those pyjamas.
« Reply #48 on: December 12, 2013, 04:34:26 PM »
So we are left guessing at what to read between the lines  ?

My guess would be that Scotland Yard  do  ...  must ...  have a substantive reason for eliminating the Jane Tanner sighting from the investigation  ...   but it is  not that they have definatively identified the person that she  saw  (  because they have not done so by their own admission ) 

What other  reason there may be for them to have  informed  the public that the man Jane saw is of no interest to them   is beyond my guessing range

Throw the wrong pyjamas into the mix & the plot becomes more obscure.

How can Smithman's child be Madeleine if she was not wearing the short sleeved 'eeyore' jammies that Kate & Gerry claimed she was wearing?

If Smithman is the number one suspect then either police believe the kidnapping pervert changed Maddies jammies during the abduction or they accept Kate & Gerry have not told the truth about what night wear she was dressed in.
Christian Brueckner Fan Club

AnneGuedes

  • Guest
Re: Another look at Tannerman and those pyjamas.
« Reply #49 on: December 12, 2013, 04:54:43 PM »

That's why I don't believe, as Anne does, that DCI procured a pair of 'rotten' pjamas  from a  jumble sale simply to placate an impatient public and give the producers of crimewatch something to do of an evening.
But I didn't suggest, SH, that DCI RW "procured a pair or rotten pyjamas from a jumble sale" nor that the exhibited ones weren't Innocentman's child's pyjamas !
What I reckon is : those pyjamas are too much or not enough and betray a flimsy and amazing medialike attitude towards the public.
DCI RW seems to be desperate for hints, clues, sightings, anything that will help concluding the abductor vanished without saying what he did with the abducted. Didn't he appear the other day only to thank watchers for their calls, e-mails, etc. ?

DCI RW indeed has no authority to affirm recklessly that Tannerman=Innocentman. Tannerman plausibility was the reason number one why the MP requested the reconstitution that was rejected by the group.
In Portugal not even the PJ could bypass the MP and the (still but not for long) AG Report on such a topic.

AnneGuedes

  • Guest
Re: Another look at Tannerman and those pyjamas.
« Reply #50 on: December 12, 2013, 05:04:12 PM »

How can Smithman's child be Madeleine if she was not wearing the short sleeved 'eeyore' jammies that Kate & Gerry claimed she was wearing?

Yes. The same witness who said the little girl was barefoot said she had long sleeves. The others didn't notice.
Btw Mr McCann, on the 10th of May, didn't remember to have described the pyjama Madeleine had on when they spent some time together between tennis and bedtime :
 Asked, he relates that he does not recall to have described exactly the type of pyjamas (colour, designs, etc.) that MADELEINE had worn at the time she disappeared
« Last Edit: December 12, 2013, 05:09:52 PM by AnneGuedes »

Offline pathfinder73

Re: Another look at Tannerman and those pyjamas.
« Reply #51 on: December 12, 2013, 05:08:05 PM »
The pyjamas are another discrepancy (surprise, surprise). I think they will be more concerned in identifying Smithman first.
Smithman carrying a child in his arms checked his watch after passing the Smith family and the time was 10:03. Both are still unidentified 10 years later.

Offline Wonderfulspam

Re: Another look at Tannerman and those pyjamas.
« Reply #52 on: December 12, 2013, 05:17:13 PM »
Yes. The same witness who said the little girl was barefoot said she had long sleeves. The others didn't notice.
Btw Mr McCann, on the 10th of May, didn't remember which pyjama Madeleine had on when they spent some time together between tennis and bedtime :
 Asked, he relates that he does not recall to have described exactly the type of pyjamas (colour, designs, etc.) that MADELEINE had worn at the time she disappeared

He certainly appears to suffer rather badly with selective amnesia doesn't he.
Confused over which door he used with or without key, can't remember whether Maddie was in bed or on the thing & doesn't even recall what clothes she was wearing.
Makes one wonder if he was actually there at all & quite surprised at how he even remembers to inhale & exhale.
Christian Brueckner Fan Club

Offline Sherlock Holmes

Re: Another look at Tannerman and those pyjamas.
« Reply #53 on: December 13, 2013, 03:04:47 AM »
Maybe they had no choice but to blow those trumpets about 10pm because without the 9.15 'sighting' they were faced with a Crimewatch and had very little else to show?

Cancelling the show would not have gone down well I imagine. Anywhere.

Presumably SY were the ones who approached the BBC about doing Crimewatch, rather than the other way around. So it wouldn't be a case of cancelling if they didn't manage to come up with something interesting. They wouldn't have arranged to do the piece in the first place had they not had much material.

And they probably had a great deal of editorial sway. It isn't up to the producers of Crimewatch to decide what SY want to emphasise to the public. They might do a bit of tweaking in helping SY get their message across, but the message is Scotland Yard's. 

I find it significant that so many potential suspects/persons of interest/people SY want to interview  (men on balconies, someone watching over the wall to the apartment, someone lurking in the stairwell, the people arguing in the street, charity collectors, and so on) were mentioned on the programme in such a short space of time. It all went in a flash.

I tried to put myself in the position of someone who hadn't done much reading on the case while I was watching the programme, and I felt that the physical descriptions of these men, and the significance of the explanations of what they were doing and where they were were presented so quickly and fleetingly that someone unfamiliar with the case would be hard pressed to take much of it in.

Why go to the the trouble of making a programme that millions are going to watch, and gloss over the part where the audience is being asked to think most? I sometimes wonder if they really are interested in any of these people at all, or if that part was just thrown in for some other reason.

All in all it appears that SY consider Smithman to be their major focus - or rather, they have decided to convey this impression to the public. They could have presented things very differently to us, but they haven't. So we presume they have a good reason for this - whatever it may be.
« Last Edit: December 13, 2013, 03:06:57 AM by Sherlock Holmes »

Offline Sherlock Holmes

Re: Another look at Tannerman and those pyjamas.
« Reply #54 on: December 13, 2013, 03:10:57 AM »
But I didn't suggest, SH, that DCI RW "procured a pair or rotten pyjamas from a jumble sale" nor that the exhibited ones weren't Innocentman's child's pyjamas !
What I reckon is : those pyjamas are too much or not enough and betray a flimsy and amazing medialike attitude towards the public.
DCI RW seems to be desperate for hints, clues, sightings, anything that will help concluding the abductor vanished without saying what he did with the abducted. Didn't he appear the other day only to thank watchers for their calls, e-mails, etc. ?

DCI RW indeed has no authority to affirm recklessly that Tannerman=Innocentman. Tannerman plausibility was the reason number one why the MP requested the reconstitution that was rejected by the group.
In Portugal not even the PJ could bypass the MP and the (still but not for long) AG Report on such a topic.

Where's the evidence that he is only interested in hints, clues, sightings?  We've had all these for years, from all over the world, and they have come to naught. He is looking to take the investigation as far as he possibly can.

And why doesn't he want to investigate what was done with Madeleine? Where do we see this?

Offline Sherlock Holmes

Re: Another look at Tannerman and those pyjamas.
« Reply #55 on: December 13, 2013, 03:27:30 AM »
It's not His case, SH, it's a Portuguese investigation, DCI RW just did a review and now asked the Portuguese to make some interviews for SY.
Besides DCI RW carefully says JT likely saw Innocentman. It's not sold 100%
The UK public has been maintained ignorant by the media who never dared to do the slightest investigative journalism. So Cwatchers can swallow anything.
But you'll admit that somebody who has read the PJ files can't. If DCI RW respected that public (why should he ? His objective is getting sightings, calls etc.), he would have at least indicated on the famous map (of no use) the route taken by Innocentman, don't you think ?

Don't really see it like this, my Dear Anne.

The case does not 'belong' to DCI Redwood, but he is still leading the British part of the investigation and as such is answerable to the government which has granted him significant funds to carry out his work, the taxpayers who are proving those funds, his higher-ups in Scotland Yard, the McCanns, and also in certain a sense the media who will pull him to pieces if he makes a mistake. That's quite a responsibility.

Of course he has to 'work' with the media, including the makers of crimewatch, but in the circumstances - one of the biggest cases in the world - I cannot believe that style comes before substance. There must be a reason why those pyjamas were shown, and a good one. He's going to get into far too much trouble if there isn't.

Call me naive.

Regarding the brianwashing of the British public by the media, it is true that the standard of British journalism isn't at an all-time high - the British public themselves are normally the first to decry that fact - but that doesn't mean that DCI Redwood doesn't have to do his work.

And as far as the investigation being a Portuguese one goes, there was no Portuguese investigation (not an open one at least) until very recently. What an astonishing co-incidence that the case was re-opened in Portugal around the time that Crimewatch and its sister programmes in other European countries, containing the 'new'timeline and slant, was broadcast - even though we are told that under Portuguese law a case can only be re-opened with new evidence. Flimsy the programme may have been in essence, but on the general situation it seems to have had a strong effect.

So technically we may be able to say that this case is Portuguese, but the reality is that without British money (excuse the lack of diplomacy), SY's formal requests for Portuguese co-operation, the back-up of the British Government, and the constant pushing by the McCanns, there would be little doing.
« Last Edit: December 13, 2013, 03:45:03 AM by Sherlock Holmes »

AnneGuedes

  • Guest
Re: Another look at Tannerman and those pyjamas.
« Reply #56 on: December 13, 2013, 03:56:01 PM »
Don't really see it like this, my Dear Anne.

The case does not 'belong' to DCI Redwood, but he is still leading the British part of the investigation and as such is answerable to the government which has granted him significant funds to carry out his work, the taxpayers who are proving those funds, his higher-ups in Scotland Yard, the McCanns, and also in certain a sense the media who will pull him to pieces if he makes a mistake. That's quite a responsibility.

Of course he has to 'work' with the media, including the makers of crimewatch, but in the circumstances - one of the biggest cases in the world - I cannot believe that style comes before substance. There must be a reason why those pyjamas were shown, and a good one. He's going to get into far too much trouble if there isn't.

Call me naive.

Regarding the brianwashing of the British public by the media, it is true that the standard of British journalism isn't at an all-time high - the British public themselves are normally the first to decry that fact - but that doesn't mean that DCI Redwood doesn't have to do his work.

And as far as the investigation being a Portuguese one goes, there was no Portuguese investigation (not an open one at least) until very recently. What an astonishing co-incidence that the case was re-opened in Portugal around the time that Crimewatch and its sister programmes in other European countries, containing the 'new'timeline and slant, was broadcast - even though we are told that under Portuguese law a case can only be re-opened with new evidence. Flimsy the programme may have been in essence, but on the general situation it seems to have had a strong effect.

So technically we may be able to say that this case is Portuguese, but the reality is that without British money (excuse the lack of diplomacy), SY's formal requests for Portuguese co-operation, the back-up of the British Government, and the constant pushing by the McCanns, there would be little doing.
It never passed my mind to think or to call you "naive". I'm certainly more than you and it's a bit like in the story of the scorpion and the frog that Orson Welles loved to tell : that's in my nature !
Imo the PM is the responsible one for this case, he was publicly intimidated by Rebekah Brooks (who knew his fragilities on that topic) and he gave away. The MET head could, it seems, have refused, but he didn't and DCI RW was left with no choice.
About the pyj, the fact DCI RW exhibited them (while he didn't have to), makes me think that he had no idea that a handful of watchers would notice a difference (apart from the group) and find counterproductive to exhibit them.
About the costs of a rogatory mission, the European convention states that they are in charge of the country where the diligences are made. In April 2008, Portugal paid the flight tickets and hotel fees for the PJ officers, but not the costs of the LC.
About why the MP reopened the case, mystery ! Tractorman's function seems to have been just a key, though, according to some infos I've had, the authorities sincerely believed he could be Mr Right. I wonder if the real motive isn't to write down another AG report.

Offline Sherlock Holmes

Re: Another look at Tannerman and those pyjamas.
« Reply #57 on: December 13, 2013, 09:43:05 PM »
It never passed my mind to think or to call you "naive". I'm certainly more than you and it's a bit like in the story of the scorpion and the frog that Orson Welles loved to tell : that's in my nature !
Imo the PM is the responsible one for this case, he was publicly intimidated by Rebekah Brooks (who knew his fragilities on that topic) and he gave away. The MET head could, it seems, have refused, but he didn't and DCI RW was left with no choice.
About the pyj, the fact DCI RW exhibited them (while he didn't have to), makes me think that he had no idea that a handful of watchers would notice a difference (apart from the group) and find counterproductive to exhibit them.
About the costs of a rogatory mission, the European convention states that they are in charge of the country where the diligences are made. In April 2008, Portugal paid the flight tickets and hotel fees for the PJ officers, but not the costs of the LC.
About why the MP reopened the case, mystery ! Tractorman's function seems to have been just a key, though, according to some infos I've had, the authorities sincerely believed he could be Mr Right. I wonder if the real motive isn't to write down another AG report.

Yes, this is surely an interesting and convoluted saga.

But back to the pyjamas again - are they really so different? On a dark night?

Redblossom

  • Guest
Re: Another look at Tannerman and those pyjamas.
« Reply #58 on: December 13, 2013, 10:23:28 PM »
Yes, this is surely an interesting and convoluted saga.

But back to the pyjamas again - are they really so different? On a dark night?

Can bright blue pyjamas seem white or pink? With or without a street light? I dont know..

AnneGuedes

  • Guest
Re: Another look at Tannerman and those pyjamas.
« Reply #59 on: December 13, 2013, 10:54:50 PM »
Yes, this is surely an interesting and convoluted saga.

But back to the pyjamas again - are they really so different? On a dark night?
As different as two pyjamas of about the same size can be... Not so dark, the night, think of the beige, golden, mustard and finally ugly (that colour always makes me laugh !) pants.