Author Topic: Where did those e-fits really come from?  (Read 16513 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Cariad

  • Guest
Re: Where did those e-fits really come from?
« Reply #45 on: October 29, 2013, 08:30:17 AM »
A woman feels danger on the streets at night.

No-one feels danger in a lighted apartment

I'm quoting you Sadie, cause you mentioned it first, though a few other people have commented that Jane Tanner may have felt scared and Red pointed out that Fiona Payne didn't want to check because it was too dark.

How does that tally with Kate Mccann says that it felt so safe? How does it tally with the patio doors being left open so Madeleine could get out and find them?

Does anyone categorically know if the apartment was lit?

Addressing the OP, did the Smiths give the detalis and if so how valid are they as e-fits?
« Last Edit: October 29, 2013, 09:21:20 AM by Cariad »

Offline pathfinder73

Re: Where did those e-fits really come from?
« Reply #46 on: October 29, 2013, 09:44:15 AM »
"Kate had been moaning you had been gone a long time watching the football." Jane Tanner (10:17)

Smithman carrying a child in his arms checked his watch after passing the Smith family and the time was 10:03. Both are still unidentified 10 years later.

Benita

  • Guest
Re: Where did those e-fits really come from?
« Reply #47 on: October 29, 2013, 09:50:13 AM »
"Kate had been moaning you had been gone a long time watching the football." Jane Tanner (10:17)



he hadn't been watching the football though ...he was chatting to jez on the road ...so why post this about football it was only a comment made by jane to Gerry at the reconstruction ...

Cariad

  • Guest
Re: Where did those e-fits really come from?
« Reply #48 on: October 29, 2013, 10:05:13 AM »

If you'r referring to the diarrhoea post, it was only what one of the tapas 9 said!

I think we're allowed to post extracts from rogatory statements.

 
« Last Edit: October 29, 2013, 10:19:23 AM by Joanne »

Offline pathfinder73

Re: Where did those e-fits really come from?
« Reply #49 on: October 29, 2013, 10:05:55 AM »

he hadn't been watching the football though ...he was chatting to jez on the road ...so why post this about football it was only a comment made by jane to Gerry at the reconstruction ...

A discrepancy Benita. They all need to be looked at. They usually kick off at 7.45 or 8pm UK/Portugal time.

2007 (May 3) Sevilla (Spain) 2-Osasuna (Spain) 0 (UEFA Cup) Semi-Final Match
« Last Edit: October 29, 2013, 10:14:39 AM by pathfinder73 »
Smithman carrying a child in his arms checked his watch after passing the Smith family and the time was 10:03. Both are still unidentified 10 years later.

Offline Sherlock Holmes

Re: Where did those e-fits really come from?
« Reply #50 on: October 29, 2013, 01:37:24 PM »
I'm quoting you Sadie, cause you mentioned it first, though a few other people have commented that Jane Tanner may have felt scared and Red pointed out that Fiona Payne didn't want to check because it was too dark.

How does that tally with Kate Mccann says that it felt so safe? How does it tally with the patio doors being left open so Madeleine could get out and find them?

Does anyone categorically know if the apartment was lit?

Addressing the OP, did the Smiths give the detalis and if so how valid are they as e-fits?

Regarding checking in the dark, Cariad, I don't think there's a contradiction, even though it appears that way on the face of it.

One could have the general impression, based on knowledge and experience, that a given place was safe. That does not mean that every woman in that place would feel comfortable walking down dark streets at night. The latter is a matter of human instinct. Instinct tells a woman to fear for her safety at night, and consequently she feels more nervous - whether danger really exists or not.

That is something completely separate from the question of how children feel at night, or whether it is safe to leave them.

As to the light in the apartment, I think that this is mentioned in the files, though I'm not sure where.

Offline Wonderfulspam

Re: Where did those e-fits really come from?
« Reply #51 on: October 29, 2013, 02:21:20 PM »

http://www.mccannfiles.com/id222.html

4078    “Go on to tell me about that then as slowly as you can?”

Reply    “Yes, erm, I was, I think I was nearing the top of the road, it’s a bit of a, I’m trying to think how, but I can’t really remember how much of a hill it is, but it is definitely a hill going up there, and just as I got to the top somebody did walk across.  And the thing that really struck me was the, erm, the bare feet.  And the thought that came into my head was, I’ll say when we’re in Leicester, our children were quite adaptable, and what we used to do is, we used to walk round to Dave and Fi’s house for, erm, the kids, for tea with the kids, the kids would play, we’d put them in a travel cot there and we’d sometimes stay a bit later and then carry the kids home, because it’s
only, it’s like the next road.  And we’d wrap them in a blanket or whatever, but you could always, their feet would fall, their feet would fall out the bottom and you’d think ‘Oh they’re going to get cold feet’ because they’d always wriggle.  So one thing I thought was ‘Oh a bit of a bad parent like us, you know, that kid’s obviously being taken home’ or whatever.  And I think that’s all, you know, that’s sort of, erm, I think that’s where the sort of I thought ‘Oh’, and that was the only reason I really clocked it I think.  Because at that point I thought it’s a person taking their child either back from the crèche or, you know, just some father carrying their own child, so it didn’t really, you know, and that didn’t.  I’m making it sound like it really registered at the time, but it didn’t, that is literally, I thought ‘Oh’”.


"And the thing that really struck me was the, erm, the bare feet."

‘Oh they’re going to get cold feet’

"So one thing I thought was ‘Oh a bit of a bad parent like us, you know, that kid’s obviously being taken home’ or whatever."



Far from fearing a nocturnal attack, Tanners mind appeared to be preoccupied by bare cold feet & standards of parenting.
« Last Edit: October 29, 2013, 02:34:03 PM by Wonderfulspam »
Christian Brueckner Fan Club

icabodcrane

  • Guest
Re: Where did those e-fits really come from?
« Reply #52 on: October 29, 2013, 02:48:19 PM »
Regarding checking in the dark, Cariad, I don't think there's a contradiction, even though it appears that way on the face of it.

One could have the general impression, based on knowledge and experience, that a given place was safe. That does not mean that every woman in that place would feel comfortable walking down dark streets at night. The latter is a matter of human instinct. Instinct tells a woman to fear for her safety at night, and consequently she feels more nervous - whether danger really exists or not.

That is something completely separate from the question of how children feel at night, or whether it is safe to leave them.

As to the light in the apartment, I think that this is mentioned in the files, though I'm not sure where.

Well this argument is purely academic in any event

Sadie claimed that Jane Tanner was  'nervous'  and somehow  'on alert' at having seen  a man  in the street at 9.15pm   ...  so nervous and  'alerted'   that she took very particular note of his appearance

This is just another of  sadie's theories,  based on no known facts  ...   Jane Tanner,  herself,  has never  ( as far as I am aware  )  said that seeing this man with a child made her feel   'scared'  or in any way  'on alert'

This idea of  Jane having the  vapours is all rather  Victorian if you ask me

Offline Sherlock Holmes

Re: Where did those e-fits really come from?
« Reply #53 on: October 30, 2013, 03:22:05 AM »
Well this argument is purely academic in any event

Sadie claimed that Jane Tanner was  'nervous'  and somehow  'on alert' at having seen  a man  in the street at 9.15pm   ...  so nervous and  'alerted'   that she took very particular note of his appearance

This is just another of  sadie's theories,  based on no known facts  ...   Jane Tanner,  herself,  has never  ( as far as I am aware  )  said that seeing this man with a child made her feel   'scared'  or in any way  'on alert'

This idea of  Jane having the  vapours is all rather  Victorian if you ask me

Don't know if she had the 'vapours', just that she was on a perfectly normal state of slighly higher alert than usual, given the fact that she was a lone woman walking in the dark.

I appreciate that this is only one interpretation of the situation, but one could explain the fact that she saw Gerry and Jez and they did not see her in terms of her level of alertness as a woman. Gerry and Jez were not concerned about the appearance of another person in the street and were not attuned to her presence.

And whatever you want to say about the bundleman situation, in the end Jane described him with a sufficient enough degree of accuracy as to enable Scotland Yard to match him to closely enough to a person that he could be ruled out of the investigation. If Jane had not been so perceptive, SY would not have had enough to go on in ruling bundleman out.

Aegean

  • Guest
Re: Where did those e-fits really come from?
« Reply #54 on: October 30, 2013, 12:55:20 PM »
Don't know if she had the 'vapours', just that she was on a perfectly normal state of slighly higher alert than usual, given the fact that she was a lone woman walking in the dark.

I appreciate that this is only one interpretation of the situation, but one could explain the fact that she saw Gerry and Jez and they did not see her in terms of her level of alertness as a woman. Gerry and Jez were not concerned about the appearance of another person in the street and were not attuned to her presence.

And whatever you want to say about the bundleman situation, in the end Jane described him with a sufficient enough degree of accuracy as to enable Scotland Yard to match him to closely enough to a person that he could be ruled out of the investigation. If Jane had not been so perceptive, SY would not have had enough to go on in ruling bundleman out.

SY would not have been forced to have to rule "bundleman" out if Jane had not perceptively insisted that he was Madeleine's abductor.

Strange, however, that she wasn't able to perceive that the child "bundleman" was carrying wasn't Madeleine. Mind you, if she and the Tapas Nine had bothered to take their own kids to the night creche they might actually have met "bundleman" and his child in there - seeing as he was a responsible parent and took his kid to the creche whenever he and his party wanted to go out in the evening.

I can't see why Jane would be nervous walking alone in the Mark Warner complex - the Tapas group apparently found it so safe they were happy to keep their kids all alone at night in their rooms while they want out for dinner and other entertainments. And, if they had put the kids in the night creche she wouldn't have had to be walking about in the dark on her own to go and check up on her kids, as per this bizarre "checking in" system they had.

But, thanks for highlighting the fact that, despite what the McCanns claim, the apartments weren't just "50 yards" away with an unimpeded view - Jane had to take a circuitous route, turning corners and without a direct line of vision, in the dark.

Offline Luz

Re: Where did those e-fits really come from?
« Reply #55 on: October 31, 2013, 08:23:03 AM »
Forget the e fits, Anjos has spoken  @)(++(*

the PJ don't use efits, so what are you all shouting about?

Carlos Anjos: Release of e-fits "is very unprofessional"

News anchor Andreia Vale [AV]: In the studio with us is Carlos Anjos, CMTV commentator. Hello Carlos, good afternoon. Thank you for being here. This e-fit of an individual, this new "breath" of the [English police] investigation, does it have any credibility in your opinion?

Carlos Anjos [CA], President of the Committee for the Protection of Crime Victims/ former president of the Criminal Investigation Officers' Union of the PJ (ASFIC/PJ) - Good afternoon. Unfortunately, no. Unfortunately, no. It seems to me, from the way that this is being carried out, from the standpoint of the criminal investigation to be very unprofessional. We do have in fact two schools of thought. We have the school of thought of criminal investigation in Continental Europe that has a particular way of working, where the media is only used to divulge any information when it reaches a dead end and is unable to go further; and the Anglo-Saxon school that uses the media in every way possible...

AV - Often from the outset.

CA - From the outset, precisely, playing on emotions. In this case, what we see here, is that all the information are contradictory - and it would be good if we could set down a record of everything that we have learned in the past few days in order to understand some errors and some disinformation. First, no one was detained in the scope of this case. The man that was arrested, was detained for collateral crimes, connected to crimes against children. The police detected child pornography in his computer, he sold child pornography, and he was arrested a month ago. He wasn't arrested now, he was detained by the Manchester police. England has a total different system from ours, each city has its own police force, each force has its own autonomy. They don't have a single body working at national level like we do with the Judiciary Police, the PSP, the GNR, police authorities that work in the whole country. They have police forces in each county and city, which remain autonomous. Therefore it wasn't the London Metropolitan police, or the Scotland Yard - who are investigating with a special team the Madeleine case - that have arrested that man, but the Manchester police. It's in the course of that arrest, and like criminals usually do, that the man uses as his self-defence: "I saw Madeleine in a Mediterranean island, I know where she is". All this suggests that he wished to gain a prominent position and receive a special treatment, from then on he began to receive attention that he would not have received if he was for example, a common criminal.
Now that this arrest of a suspect has been explained, an arrest that took place a month ago and thus an old issue; it should be explained, the newspaper [Daily Mirror] which has published the story did so since they had nothing relevant to publish. BBC had the exclusive; they had nothing and decided to publish that incident ahead of the BBC broadcast. Regarding the e-fit, the only person that saw something gave a description to the Judiciary Police and provided a facial picture of a suspect that doesn't exist, that is, it was a featureless face. The witness was too far away...

AV - It's the picture of a man seen carrying a child?

CA - Precisely, the person gives a description, 30 meters away, at night, and just gives a physical account given that she could not see the facial features. That picture which appears now, is based on that slightly oval shaped face, from that statement that was given initially to the Judiciary Police, composed with further descriptions given by other people, thus we have a face that... a picture of a face that is a composite... - it should be said that these are portraits of the same man, one is of the man 6 years ago that was then aged with a software program, the other is a portrait that was done based on the accounts given by several people. This is very problematic.
The creation of identikit pictures is a complex process, imagine if someone would ask you, Andreia, to give an account of the facial features of someone that you saw just for a few seconds, that would be already difficult, and even more so if a picture is created based on 5 or 6 witnesses accounts, where the reliability of those accounts is close to nil. So, what we have here is the face of a man, and a description given by several people, and this is where I believe a huge mistake is being made since the e-fit could be matched to almost all the men in the world, between the ages of 20 to 40.

AV - The physiognomy is too broad?

CA - Exactly, and another serious mistake, they give all the characteristics of a man from southern Europe, brown hair, brown eyes and then they state that it is supposed to be an English man, it's the complete antithesis of the description that they have given. Worse still, they have stated that they want to locate a man with ages ranging from 20 to 40 years old - the first reaction to this is that it seems to be a wide gap. People with 20 years old and with 40 years old are unmistakable, at 20 you say that is a young man, at 40 a mature man - and what is worse, if they wish to locate a man who is now 20 years old then the man was 14 years old at the time of Madeleine's disappearance! Thus, whoever saw him, could not mistake a man, even if it was a young man, with a teenager. So, we see a series of errors in the formulation of this hypothesis, which means that they have nothing.
We know the English police did an extensive work, according to what we know and was published in the media, it was even divulged by the English authorities in the media, and that was the investigation to identify all the cell phones that were in use in that night in the Algarve. Except the prepaid cell phones, those are impossible to be identified. After the investigation to all the cell phones, that had a contract, they had to identify all those who had a criminal record, or a record of crimes against children, for paedophilia or abduction, etc. After establishing the identity and record of the cell phone owners, they arrived to 41 people of interest. This brings up the first problem, the first problem is that most paedophiles who move between countries, criminals that travel regularly, the first thing they do upon arrival is to buy a prepaid cell phone, so they can't be identified. Those are all outside this list, they were not included. Yesterday, it was published in the media that there is a possibility that some of those who were identified are under surveillance, being tapped. That makes more sense, it sheds some light as to the reasons behind, and forgive my expression, this circus. It's an attempt to shake things up bit, so that there are lots of people talking about the case, to see if any of the suspects talks about this issue...

AV - To see if the suspect gives himself away.

CA - ...if the suspect gives himself away, and from the "nothing", they are able to get something.

AV - Carlos, thank you so much for being here with us.

http://joana-morais.blogspot.com/2013/10/carlos-anjos-release-of-e-fits-is-very.html

Its becoming very clear, who is trying to derail PJ/SY review, with misinformation. I wonder why?


Where does Carlos Anjos say that PJ doesn't use e-fits?

This is your usual distortion of information...keep on, we are used to that.

lizzibif.

  • Guest
Re: Where did those e-fits really come from?
« Reply #56 on: October 31, 2013, 11:47:48 AM »
Where does Carlos Anjos say that PJ doesn't use e-fits?

This is your usual distortion of information...keep on, we are used to that.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Who are "we" luz ?