Author Topic: Gonçalo Amaral speaks to Portugal's Nova Gente Magazine.  (Read 35018 times)

0 Members and 3 Guests are viewing this topic.

Cariad

  • Guest
Re: Gonçalo Amaral speaks to Portugal's Nova Gente Magazine.
« Reply #120 on: October 30, 2013, 05:31:53 PM »
If that's all you're saying, fair enough.

It is ruled out that Madeleine was driven anywhere dead in the car.



I believe that the bodily fluids could not be ruled out as belonging to Madeleine.

The material in the boot of the car can not be ruled out as belonging to Madeleine McCann.

The material in the booy of the hire car can not be ruled out as belonging to Madeleine McCann.


No it isn't. Madeleine could not be ruled out.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JOHN_LOWE.htm

What edit? I said that Madeleine could not be excluded! I had a response on 'nonsense' from someone, then someone else asked for a cite.

I supplied a cite and a quote to back up my claim that Madeleine could not be excluded. Which bit am I meant to edit?

I'm not being confrontational, I don't understand what it is you think I've done wrong.


Offline imustpointout

Re: Gonçalo Amaral speaks to Portugal's Nova Gente Magazine.
« Reply #121 on: October 30, 2013, 05:33:04 PM »
"A liquid post-script by Dr Martin Roberts."

that explains it then.

Cariad

  • Guest
Re: Gonçalo Amaral speaks to Portugal's Nova Gente Magazine.
« Reply #122 on: October 30, 2013, 05:47:26 PM »
So you accept that Madeleine was never driven anywhere dead in the car?

When did I say that?

Aiofe

  • Guest
Re: Gonçalo Amaral speaks to Portugal's Nova Gente Magazine.
« Reply #123 on: October 30, 2013, 06:15:13 PM »
I believe that the bodily fluids could not be ruled out as belonging to Madeleine.

There were no bodily fluids found. Only dry residue. The DNA analysis could not exclude about 50% of the European population. As an aid to identification it was as useful as flipping a coin.

Cariad

  • Guest
Re: Gonçalo Amaral speaks to Portugal's Nova Gente Magazine.
« Reply #124 on: October 30, 2013, 06:28:08 PM »
The questionmark at the end turns a statement into a question ...

That the McCanns never drove Madeleine anywhere dead in the car is a fact.

Do you accept that fact or don't you?

Adding 'so you accept that' to the beginning of a sentence presumes agreement. since I have not made any comment on the topic you presumption was unwarranted.

I am aware that adding a question mark to the end of a statement turns it in to a question. Why did you feel the need to explain that?

Do I usually display a lack of understanding of grammar?

AnneGuedes

  • Guest
Re: Gonçalo Amaral speaks to Portugal's Nova Gente Magazine.
« Reply #125 on: October 30, 2013, 06:32:40 PM »
An incomplete DNA result was obtained from cellular material on the swab 3a. The swab contained very little information and showed low level indications of DNA from more than one person. However, all of the confirmed DNA components within this result match the corresponding components in the DNA profile of Madeline McCann. LCN DNA profiling is highly sensitive it is not possible to attribute this DNA profile to a particular body fluid.

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JOHN_LOWE.htm
Exactly, they couldn't determine which kind of body fluid the DNA originated from.

Cariad

  • Guest
Re: Gonçalo Amaral speaks to Portugal's Nova Gente Magazine.
« Reply #126 on: October 30, 2013, 06:37:40 PM »
Exactly, they couldn't determine which kind of body fluid the DNA originated from.

No, nor could they rule out that it came from Madeleine Mccann, despite the repeated posts from member claiming differently.

Offline imustpointout

Re: Gonçalo Amaral speaks to Portugal's Nova Gente Magazine.
« Reply #127 on: October 30, 2013, 06:42:05 PM »
It seems that not only was Madeleine carried in a hire car sometime after going missing, but that she was carried in the boot of the car, and not only that - she dripped bodily fluid into the boot of the car during the journey.

Is that an accurate summary?

Offline imustpointout

Re: Gonçalo Amaral speaks to Portugal's Nova Gente Magazine.
« Reply #128 on: October 30, 2013, 06:53:16 PM »
And just to further clarify - this was a hire car that never carried anything at all from the Mccann family or even Madeleine in the boot before it was sniffed and licked by a dog?

Offline Mr Gray

Re: Gonçalo Amaral speaks to Portugal's Nova Gente Magazine.
« Reply #129 on: October 30, 2013, 07:28:55 PM »
No, nor could they rule out that it came from Madeleine Mccann, despite the repeated posts from member claiming differently.

if they had found no DNA residue in the car ...there would have been nothing to send to the FSS
So  there would have been no evidence that maddie had been in the car...but that would not have ruled out maddie having been carried in the car...that is the ridiculous argument you are using

Aiofe

  • Guest
Re: Gonçalo Amaral speaks to Portugal's Nova Gente Magazine.
« Reply #130 on: October 30, 2013, 09:34:17 PM »
No, nor could they rule out that it came from Madeleine Mccann, despite the repeated posts from member claiming differently.

They could rule out half of the European population, but not the half that included Madeleine and the rest of the McCann. The results would also include half the people posting here!

Offline Gildas

Re: Gonçalo Amaral speaks to Portugal's Nova Gente Magazine.
« Reply #131 on: October 31, 2013, 11:03:50 AM »
There were no bodily fluids found. Only dry residue. The DNA analysis could not exclude about 50% of the European population. As an aid to identification it was as useful as flipping a coin.

"The DNA analysis could not exclude about 50% of the European population. As an aid to identification it was as useful as flipping a coin."

Aofe, do you have a link for this?  I am interested in knowing how this was calculated.
T

Aiofe

  • Guest
Re: Gonçalo Amaral speaks to Portugal's Nova Gente Magazine.
« Reply #132 on: October 31, 2013, 11:14:51 AM »
"The DNA analysis could not exclude about 50% of the European population. As an aid to identification it was as useful as flipping a coin."

Aofe, do you have a link for this?  I am interested in knowing how this was calculated.

It is the final conclusion of the FSS report, the Lowe report. It talks about the same markers being shared by a random selection of people's blood in the FSS offices.

"What we need to consider, as scientists, is whether the match is genuine and legitimate; because Madeline has deposited DNA as a result of being in the car or whether Madeline merely appears to match the result by chance. The individual components in Madeline's profile are not unique to her, it is the specific combination of 19 components that makes her profile unique above all others. Elements of Madeline's profile are also present within the the profiles of many of the scientists here in Bimiingham, myself included. lt's important to stress that 50% of Madeline's profile will be shared with each parent. It is not possible in a mixture of more than two people, to determine or evaluate which specific DNA components pair with each other. Namely, we cannot separate the components out into 3 individual DNA profiles."

I am relying on an analysis by a colleague for the suggestion that giving the number of possible donors and limited markers, about half of a 37 marker random soup from 3-5 people would identify abut half the European population

Offline Gildas

Re: Gonçalo Amaral speaks to Portugal's Nova Gente Magazine.
« Reply #133 on: October 31, 2013, 11:40:00 AM »
It is the final conclusion of the FSS report, the Lowe report. It talks about the same markers being shared by a random selection of people's blood in the FSS offices.

"What we need to consider, as scientists, is whether the match is genuine and legitimate; because Madeline has deposited DNA as a result of being in the car or whether Madeline merely appears to match the result by chance. The individual components in Madeline's profile are not unique to her, it is the specific combination of 19 components that makes her profile unique above all others. Elements of Madeline's profile are also present within the the profiles of many of the scientists here in Bimiingham, myself included. lt's important to stress that 50% of Madeline's profile will be shared with each parent. It is not possible in a mixture of more than two people, to determine or evaluate which specific DNA components pair with each other. Namely, we cannot separate the components out into 3 individual DNA profiles."

I am relying on an analysis by a colleague for the suggestion that giving the number of possible donors and limited markers, about half of a 37 marker random soup from 3-5 people would identify abut half the European population

Thank you for your reply, Aiofe. I still don't know I how it was calculated, but its not that important, so thanks anyway.
T

Aiofe

  • Guest
Re: Gonçalo Amaral speaks to Portugal's Nova Gente Magazine.
« Reply #134 on: October 31, 2013, 11:52:57 AM »
Thank you for your reply, Aiofe. I still don't know I how it was calculated, but its not that important, so thanks anyway.

As it was explained to be, they look at twenty sites for chains of molecules attached there. Each site has a limited number of possible chains of molecules- only digits or tens in number for each site and some of these chains of molecules are present in different people at several sites. When in normal DNA analysis is used, each chain of molecules is known to be related to a specific site. In LCNDNA, much information is lost as the relationship between chains of molecules and sites is unknown.

This means that LCNDNA has a much lower specificity.

It should also be noted that if DNA from the famil was part of the mix, such an identification would be almost certain.