Author Topic: A general look at mental health issues and child rearing.  (Read 45616 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline Carana

Re: A general look at mental health issues and child rearing.
« Reply #15 on: November 29, 2013, 05:52:03 PM »
I'm just not too confident about the likelihood of finding Smithman after all these years.

If he was a PdL resident, either he would have come forward of his own volition or been interviewed by local police as part of a neighbourhood inquiry, as you say.

If he was a tourist taking his child back from the night creche (same as bundleman) then presumably he would have been identified by SY and eliminated.

It is possible though highly unlikely that he is an innocent member of the public oblivious to the media interest in him. But that doesn't explain why the mother of the child did not prompt him or come forward herself. Where is she?

Until recently, bundleman hadn't been identified either (at least as the most likely person), for some reason. There could still be a breaththrough concerning Smithman...

AnneGuedes

  • Guest
Re: A general look at mental health issues and child rearing.
« Reply #16 on: November 29, 2013, 05:55:27 PM »
Yes but there are many, many demanding babies and children. Madeleine wasn't the only one.

Must be a great strain I agree, especially with IVF thrown in. But I know many people who manage several young children at once and all the ups and downs that entails.

KM also elected to go through this process. Presumably she felt that she was able to cope with it. After all, she had already gone through IVF with Madeleine and knew what she was taking on. I personally don't feel I would be able to cope with the rigours of IVF, but obviously there are many people with the strength to do it and KM was one of them.
The minimum implanted is 2, because the process is not easy. You don't know whether both eggs will develop.
Not all babies cry like Madeleine did. I had one like that, I never met another one. It's not crying for an hour or two, it's crying all the time, except when fed !

Cariad

  • Guest
Re: A general look at mental health issues and child rearing.
« Reply #17 on: November 29, 2013, 06:18:29 PM »
The minimum implanted is 2, because the process is not easy. You don't know whether both eggs will develop.
Not all babies cry like Madeleine did. I had one like that, I never met another one. It's not crying for an hour or two, it's crying all the time, except when fed !

My elder son had colic. It's not an exaggeration to say that he cried for six months. It was incredibly difficult and without the help of my family, I don't know how I'd have coped.

I was really very worried when I was expecting my second child. Luckily he was a text book baby. Slept all the time, hardly cried at all. If they could all be like him I'd probably have had a dozen  8)-)))

« Last Edit: November 29, 2013, 07:25:07 PM by John »

Offline John

Re: A general look at mental health issues and child rearing.
« Reply #18 on: November 29, 2013, 07:27:18 PM »
I have split these posts off from the open window thread as best as possible.  Please try to not answer several issues including off topic issues in the one post.

I would like to keep my remaining hair if at all possible this fine evening! 
« Last Edit: November 29, 2013, 07:31:43 PM by John »
A malicious prosecution for a crime which never existed. An exposé of egregious malfeasance by public officials.
Indeed, the truth never changes with the passage of time.

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: A general look at mental health issues and child rearing.
« Reply #19 on: November 29, 2013, 07:31:21 PM »
There is no evidence here of post natal depression, mental illness of either parent, prior abuse against or maltreatment of any of their children, stress resulting from poverty...none of the common motives or reasons for harm.

Neither is there evidence of harm (by either parent)

Offline Sherlock Holmes

Re: A general look at mental health issues and child rearing.
« Reply #20 on: November 29, 2013, 07:35:23 PM »
I have split these posts off from the open window thread as best as possible.  Please try to not answer several issues including off topic issues in the one post.

I would like to keep my remaining hair if at all possible this fine evening! 

Thanks for your help with this, John


ferryman

  • Guest
Re: A general look at mental health issues and child rearing.
« Reply #21 on: November 29, 2013, 07:41:42 PM »
I'm unclear why you have corrupted Sherlock's post.

I'm sure you have your reasons.

Offline John

Re: A general look at mental health issues and child rearing.
« Reply #22 on: November 29, 2013, 07:45:46 PM »
Thanks for your help with this, John

It is extremely difficult and time consuming to create a new thread from an existing one where two issues are being responded to simultaneously.

You might want to edit your op since much of it was irrelrvant to this topic and thus removed.
A malicious prosecution for a crime which never existed. An exposé of egregious malfeasance by public officials.
Indeed, the truth never changes with the passage of time.

Cariad

  • Guest
Re: A general look at mental health issues and child rearing.
« Reply #23 on: November 29, 2013, 08:05:28 PM »
I realise we are going off topic and I apologise to Admin who have recently asked us to avoid doing so   (  but this question has bothered me a bit since the  '48 questions Kate refused to answer'  were made public  ) 

One of the questions related to Kate having once considered handing Madeleine's care over to a relative

It appeared so out of left field that it was a bit shocking  ...  where did that come  from ?  would the police have inexplicably plucked that specific question from mid air,  based on no knowledge or evidence at all  ?

When the same question was put to Gerry  (  who had  not  chosen to stay silent  )  he responded to the question of whether or not   Kate had  considered   handing Madeleine over to a relative  ...  "Not to  my knowledge" 

Not to his  KNOWLEDGE ! 

I  expected his answer to be a dismissive and contemptuous,  "No, of course not. My wife never considered any such thing"

He didn't though.  He made no denial of a subject the police appeared to have some knowledge of

It was an altogether odd exchange, I though

Yes, very strange.  I wonder why they asked it in the first place? Did they have information that K Mccann had requested help for a family member?

Considering the age of K & G Mccann and the method of conceiving, I would be very surprised if they had requested a family member adopt Madeleine. They were both older parents, well educated and obviously desperately wanted children.

I suppose it's possible that because they wanted kids so much they idealised parenthood and couldn't cope with the reality, which tends to involve much more bodily fluids and much less sleep than people generally imagine, but again, their professions would have prepared them very well for the less pleasant side of parenting.

I have heard whispers that Madeline had some form of learning disorder. I've never seen anything that makes me believe that this is true, but to play devils advocate for a moment and assume that it is, I think that most parents would feel  especially protective of a special child and if they were having difficulties caused by it, wouldn't it be the twins that they would ask for help with, keeping the child that needed them more close to home?

I agree Icabod, Gerry's response is totally bizarre. 'Not to my knowledge' is such a blasé answer to a question that should have been shocking. It also distances himself from the question, as though it could  have happened, but he would not have been involved in such a thing.....
It implies a lack of communication which beggars belief.

Then again, I could be reading way too much in to a through away line.

I'm quite uncomfortable with the idea that a mother suffering from PND would be capable of harming her child. It does of course happen but it is very, very rare.

http://www.rcpsych.ac.uk/healthadvice/problemsdisorders/postnataldepression.aspx

Almost all cases of infanticide caused by mental health problems are the result of Postpartum psychosis which is a much rarer condition and would be very difficult to hide for any length of time. I really think both things can be ruled out as causes of Madeleine's disappearance.

http://www.rcpsych.ac.uk/healthadvice/problemsdisorders/postpartumpsychosis.aspx

People suffering from mental health issues are a danger to themselves at times, but very rarely are they a danger to others.

I'd just like to add my thanks to John!  8((()*/
 

Offline Sherlock Holmes

Re: A general look at mental health issues and child rearing.
« Reply #24 on: November 29, 2013, 08:11:03 PM »
Neither is there evidence of harm (by either parent)

No evidence whatsoever, either in forensic terms or psychological.

It is generally accepted in psychology that only in extremely rare occasions does a mature adult commit a serious crime. When such crime is committed by a person well into their adult years, there is almost always relatively long history of criminal activity; a 'criminal career'. This career normally begins in youth or early adulthood, with petty or occasionally more serious crime, and escalates in type and scale over the years. Recidivism is very common.

It is exceptionally unusual for a mature person with no criminal past to commit major crime of any description, be it violent, financial, anything. The pattern is that a line is crossed, the criminal gets away with it , and then crosses the next line and then the next. The more he gets away with things, the more his confidence and bravado increase, and it snowballs from there.

The exception to the rule is the so-called 'crime of passion', where an otherwise mentally healthy person with no criminal past suddenly commits a major crime in response to a dramatic, out of the blue event. The classic example is a person murdering their spouse upon discovery of unfaithfulness.

The term 'crime of passion', however ,can hardly be ascribed to harming one's own child, or to anything the McCanns have been accused of.

Given the complete absence of any forensic evidence of harm caused to Madeleine by her parents, I feel that people accusing the McCanns of anything sinister, such as concealing her body, should at least provide some suggestion of mental instability or prior criminal history.

Concealing a body, and perverting the course of justice to the degree that the McCanns would be doing if that is what had happened (leading SY a merry dance; manipulating governments; embezzling millions) are all major crimes in themselves, for which there would need to be psychological or criminal prerequisites.

Evidence, please!

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: A general look at mental health issues and child rearing.
« Reply #25 on: November 29, 2013, 08:13:05 PM »
Was that post in response to my previous post ? If so I have neither corrupted nor edited the post, I copied it word for word as it appears on my screen and highlighted the relevant section of the post !

I guess you must have comprehension issues ...

Offline Wonderfulspam

Re: A general look at mental health issues and child rearing.
« Reply #26 on: November 29, 2013, 08:17:21 PM »
No evidence whatsoever, either in forensic terms or psychological.

It is generally accepted in psychology that only in extremely rare occasions does a mature adult commit a serious crime. When such crime is committed by a person well into their adult years, there is almost always relatively long history of criminal activity; a 'criminal career'. This career normally begins in youth or early adulthood, with petty or occasionally more serious crime, and escalates in type and scale over the years. Recidivism is very common.

It is exceptionally unusual for a mature person with no criminal past to commit major crime of any description, be it violent, financial, anything. The pattern is that a line is crossed, the criminal gets away with it , and then crosses the next line and then the next. The more he gets away with things, the more his confidence and bravado increase, and it snowballs from there.

The exception to the rule is the so-called 'crime of passion', where an otherwise mentally healthy person with no criminal past suddenly commits a major crime in response to a dramatic, out of the blue event. The classic example is a person murdering their spouse upon discovery of unfaithfulness.

The term 'crime of passion', however ,can hardly be ascribed to harming one's own child, or to anything the McCanns have been accused of.

Given the complete absence of any forensic evidence of harm caused to Madeleine by her parents, I feel that people accusing the McCanns of anything sinister, such as concealing her body, should at least provide some suggestion of mental instability or prior criminal history.

Concealing a body, and perverting the course of justice to the degree that the McCanns would be doing if that is what had happened (leading SY a merry dance; manipulating governments; embezzling millions) are all major crimes in themselves, for which there would need to be psychological or criminal prerequisites.

Evidence, please!

Concealing a body, and perverting the course of justice to the degree that the McCanns would be doing if that is what had happened (leading SY a merry dance; manipulating governments; embezzling millions) are all major crimes in themselves, for which there would need to be psychological or criminal prerequisites.



Why would there 'need' to be psychological or criminal prerequisites ?

Let Gerry explain....

"Sometimes people do things for reasons that even they cannot understand."

"An act of madness, an accident or sudden impulse can lead to consequences that people may never have imagined or intended."

Christian Brueckner Fan Club

AnneGuedes

  • Guest
Re: A general look at mental health issues and child rearing.
« Reply #27 on: November 29, 2013, 08:18:28 PM »

Concealing a body, and perverting the course of justice to the degree that the McCanns would be doing if that is what had happened (leading SY a merry dance; manipulating governments; embezzling millions) are all major crimes in themselves, for which there would need to be psychological or criminal prerequisites.

Evidence, please!
What can you do once you're caught in a whirlpool or a tsunami ?

Offline Mr Gray

Re: A general look at mental health issues and child rearing.
« Reply #28 on: November 29, 2013, 08:20:12 PM »
Who suspects them of killing ? Nobody. Who is protected of killing by accident ? Nobody. It's a terrible reality, I can understand denying it.
I do hope they will be fully investigated and exonerated, for the sake of their family.

 in my opinion,,, and it would seem SY... they have been fully investigated and exonerated . Do you have any evidence that this is not the case

Offline Wonderfulspam

Re: A general look at mental health issues and child rearing.
« Reply #29 on: November 29, 2013, 08:20:43 PM »
Exactly.

Also, I have never read one disparaging remark about the McCanns (pre [ censored word ]s that is) or any parenthood problems. And as we know someone usual crawls out of the woodwork with "Oh I can tell you this....."

And no one has.

Maybe they only beat her behind closed doors.  Or a sofa.
Christian Brueckner Fan Club