I realise we are going off topic and I apologise to Admin who have recently asked us to avoid doing so ( but this question has bothered me a bit since the '48 questions Kate refused to answer' were made public )
One of the questions related to Kate having once considered handing Madeleine's care over to a relative
It appeared so out of left field that it was a bit shocking ... where did that come from ? would the police have inexplicably plucked that specific question from mid air, based on no knowledge or evidence at all ?
When the same question was put to Gerry ( who had not chosen to stay silent ) he responded to the question of whether or not Kate had considered handing Madeleine over to a relative ... "Not to my knowledge"
Not to his KNOWLEDGE !
I expected his answer to be a dismissive and contemptuous, "No, of course not. My wife never considered any such thing"
He didn't though. He made no denial of a subject the police appeared to have some knowledge of
It was an altogether odd exchange, I though
Yes, very strange. I wonder why they asked it in the first place? Did they have information that K Mccann had requested help for a family member?
Considering the age of K & G Mccann and the method of conceiving, I would be very surprised if they had requested a family member adopt Madeleine. They were both older parents, well educated and obviously desperately wanted children.
I suppose it's possible that because they wanted kids so much they idealised parenthood and couldn't cope with the reality, which tends to involve much more bodily fluids and much less sleep than people generally imagine, but again, their professions would have prepared them very well for the less pleasant side of parenting.
I have heard whispers that Madeline had some form of learning disorder. I've never seen anything that makes me believe that this is true, but to play devils advocate for a moment and assume that it is, I think that most parents would feel
especially protective of a special child and if they were having difficulties caused by it, wouldn't it be the twins that they would ask for help with, keeping the child that needed them more close to home?
I agree Icabod, Gerry's response is totally bizarre. 'Not to my knowledge' is such a blasé answer to a question that should have been shocking. It also distances himself from the question, as though it
could have happened, but he would not have been involved in such a thing.....
It implies a lack of communication which beggars belief.
Then again, I could be reading way too much in to a through away line.
I'm quite uncomfortable with the idea that a mother suffering from PND would be capable of harming her child. It does of course happen but it is very, very rare.
http://www.rcpsych.ac.uk/healthadvice/problemsdisorders/postnataldepression.aspxAlmost all cases of infanticide caused by mental health problems are the result of Postpartum psychosis which is a much rarer condition and would be very difficult to hide for any length of time. I really think both things can be ruled out as causes of Madeleine's disappearance.
http://www.rcpsych.ac.uk/healthadvice/problemsdisorders/postpartumpsychosis.aspxPeople suffering from mental health issues are a danger to themselves at times, but very rarely are they a danger to others.
I'd just like to add my thanks to John!