Author Topic: A general look at mental health issues and child rearing.  (Read 45615 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline Sherlock Holmes

A general look at mental health issues and child rearing.
« on: November 28, 2013, 06:12:53 PM »
There is no evidence here of post natal depression, mental illness of either parent, prior abuse against or maltreatment of any of their children, stress resulting from poverty...none of the common motives or reasons for harm.
« Last Edit: November 29, 2013, 07:18:28 PM by John »

AnneGuedes

  • Guest
Re: A general look at mental health issues and child rearing.
« Reply #1 on: November 28, 2013, 06:26:34 PM »
So what reason was there for the McCanns killing or mistreating their own child?  What evidence exists to show that they had reason to harm their child, or that they actually did?
Who suspects them of killing ? Nobody. Who is protected of killing by accident ? Nobody. It's a terrible reality, I can understand denying it.
I do hope they will be fully investigated and exonerated, for the sake of their family.

Offline Sherlock Holmes

Re: A general look at mental health issues and child rearing.
« Reply #2 on: November 28, 2013, 07:39:26 PM »
There is an absence of evidence for the McCanns having harmed or disposed of their child.

« Last Edit: November 29, 2013, 07:20:09 PM by John »

AnneGuedes

  • Guest
Re: A general look at mental health issues and child rearing.
« Reply #3 on: November 29, 2013, 12:56:16 AM »
There is an absence of evidence for the McCanns having harmed or disposed of their child.


There's as well no evidence that Madeleine wasn't harmed and disposed of by her parents in a swift and definitive way.
No evidence at all ?
« Last Edit: November 29, 2013, 07:21:29 PM by John »

Offline colombosstogey

Re: A general look at mental health issues and child rearing.
« Reply #4 on: November 29, 2013, 06:02:30 AM »

There is no evidence here of post natal depression,mental illness of either parent, prior abuse against or maltreatment of any of their children, stress resulting from poverty...none of the common motives or reasons for harm.

Is there not?

Sadly quite a few mums who suffer this never let anyone know about it. They go on to kill themselves, or even their children in suicide/homicide events and the family left behind are truly shocked they had no idea there was a problem.

You cant see PPD its invisible outwardly.

Having 3 children so young can put ANYONE at risk of PPD.

Not saying this is the case, but you cant say for definite there were no signs of PPD.

« Last Edit: November 29, 2013, 07:23:20 PM by John »

Offline Sherlock Holmes

Re: A general look at mental health issues and child rearing.
« Reply #5 on: November 29, 2013, 03:02:43 PM »
Is there not?

Sadly quite a few mums who suffer this never let anyone know about it. They go on to kill themselves, or even their children in suicide/homicide events and the family left behind are truly shocked they had no idea there was a problem.

You cant see PPD its invisible outwardly.

Having 3 children so young can put ANYONE at risk of PPD.

Not saying this is the case, but you cant say for definite there were no signs of PPD.

If Kate McCann was suffering from PPD, that information would probably be available in her medical records.

I was not aware that young maternal age was a factor in the condition, but in any case, Kate was 35 years old when she had Madeleine, and two years older when she had the twins, which would place her towards the end of her healthy reproductive years.

I was 38 when I had my first child -  three years ago - and the pregnancy and birth were managed medically as a high risk case because of my 'advanced' age. I had far more frequent than usual sonograms and other tests, developed gestational diabetes (a common risk for pregnant women over 35) and went through the pregnancy on a diabetic diet, and the birth was monitored more closely for certain things.

Woops, let the cat out of the bag there...

Cariad

  • Guest
Re: A general look at mental health issues and child rearing.
« Reply #6 on: November 29, 2013, 04:47:48 PM »
If Kate McCann was suffering from PPD, that information would probably be available in her medical records.

I was not aware that young maternal age was a factor in the condition, but in any case, Kate was 35 years old when she had Madeleine, and two years older when she had the twins, which would place her towards the end of her healthy reproductive years.

I was 38 when I had my first child -  three years ago - and the pregnancy and birth were managed medically as a high risk case because of my 'advanced' age. I had far more frequent than usual sonograms and other tests, developed gestational diabetes (a common risk for pregnant women over 35) and went through the pregnancy on a diabetic diet, and the birth was monitored more closely for certain things.

Woops, let the cat out of the bag there...

I read clombosstogeys post as meaning the age of the children. 3 under 4 must be incredibly hard work. there's only 22 months between my two and it was difficult when hey were young.

You have let the cat out of the bag though, I wasn't sure if you were male or female before! Not that it makes the blindest bit of difference to anything really, It's just nice to have a picture of who you're talking to  ?{)(**

AnneGuedes

  • Guest
Re: A general look at mental health issues and child rearing.
« Reply #7 on: November 29, 2013, 04:51:06 PM »
It's just nice to have a picture of who you're talking to  ?{)(**
It never passed my mind SH wasn't She Holmes. I wonder why.

Cariad

  • Guest
Re: A general look at mental health issues and child rearing.
« Reply #8 on: November 29, 2013, 04:55:33 PM »
It never passed my mind SH wasn't She Holmes. I wonder why.

Yes, I always suspected that she was a she. Polite, Respectful, intelligent... I should never have doubted  ?{)(**

Offline Sherlock Holmes

Re: A general look at mental health issues and child rearing.
« Reply #9 on: November 29, 2013, 05:13:21 PM »
I read clombosstogeys post as meaning the age of the children. 3 under 4 must be incredibly hard work. there's only 22 months between my two and it was difficult when hey were young.

You have let the cat out of the bag though, I wasn't sure if you were male or female before! Not that it makes the blindest bit of difference to anything really, It's just nice to have a picture of who you're talking to  ?{)(**

I just re-read columbostogey's post and your reading of it definitely makes sense. Having twins shortly after having Madeleine would indeed be challenging.

Most mentally healthy mothers do ultimately manage to cope with this situation, however, even though it is very demanding. If KM was alleged to be depressed or having difficulty coping to the point that it would raise our suspicions, we would need evidence.

Nice to meet you too!


Offline Sherlock Holmes

Re: A general look at mental health issues and child rearing.
« Reply #10 on: November 29, 2013, 05:15:11 PM »
It never passed my mind SH wasn't She Holmes. I wonder why.

SHErlock Holmes. Well deduced, Anne.

AnneGuedes

  • Guest
Re: A general look at mental health issues and child rearing.
« Reply #11 on: November 29, 2013, 05:34:23 PM »
I just re-read columbostogey's post and your reading of it definitely makes sense. Having twins shortly after having Madeleine would indeed be challenging.

Most mentally healthy mothers do ultimately manage to cope with this situation, however, even though it is very demanding. If KM was alleged to be depressed or having difficulty coping to the point that it would raise our suspicions, we would need evidence.

Nice to meet you too!
Jeanne darc's theory is somehow supported by this : an exhausted mother and a husband who always thinks it will be fine. Madeleine as a baby was always crying and demanding attention (very rarely someone who knows how it is will take your baby and tell you to have a quiet time by yourself). Then being pregnant of 2 without having had time to recover wasn't a good idea (speaking of idea since those twins are FIV as well).

icabodcrane

  • Guest
Re: A general look at mental health issues and child rearing.
« Reply #12 on: November 29, 2013, 05:37:24 PM »
I just re-read columbostogey's post and your reading of it definitely makes sense. Having twins shortly after having Madeleine would indeed be challenging.

Most mentally healthy mothers do ultimately manage to cope with this situation, however, even though it is very demanding. If KM was alleged to be depressed or having difficulty coping to the point that it would raise our suspicions, we would need evidence.

Nice to meet you too!

I realise we are going off topic and I apologise to Admin who have recently asked us to avoid doing so   (  but this question has bothered me a bit since the  '48 questions Kate refused to answer'  were made public  ) 

One of the questions related to Kate having once considered handing Madeleine's care over to a relative

It appeared so out of left field that it was a bit shocking  ...  where did that come  from ?  would the police have inexplicably plucked that specific question from mid air,  based on no knowledge or evidence at all  ?

When the same question was put to Gerry  (  who had  not  chosen to stay silent  )  he responded to the question of whether or not   Kate had  considered   handing Madeleine over to a relative  ...  "Not to  my knowledge" 

Not to his  KNOWLEDGE ! 

I  expected his answer to be a dismissive and contemptuous,  "No, of course not. My wife never considered any such thing"

He didn't though.  He made no denial of a subject the police appeared to have some knowledge of

It was an altogether odd exchange, I though

Offline Sherlock Holmes

Re: A general look at mental health issues and child rearing.
« Reply #13 on: November 29, 2013, 05:47:49 PM »
Jeanne darc's theory is somehow supported by this : an exhausted mother and a husband who always thinks it will be fine. Madeleine as a baby was always crying and demanding attention (very rarely someone who knows how it is will take your baby and tell you to have a quiet time by yourself). Then being pregnant of 2 without having had time to recover wasn't a good idea (speaking of idea since those twins are FIV as well).

Yes but there are many, many demanding babies and children. Madeleine wasn't the only one.

Must be a great strain I agree, especially with IVF thrown in. But I know many people who manage several young children at once and all the ups and downs that entails.

KM also elected to go through this process. Presumably she felt that she was able to cope with it. After all, she had already gone through IVF with Madeleine and knew what she was taking on. I personally don't feel I would be able to cope with the rigours of IVF, but obviously there are many people with the strength to do it and KM was one of them.

AnneGuedes

  • Guest
Re: A general look at mental health issues and child rearing.
« Reply #14 on: November 29, 2013, 05:48:41 PM »
I realise we are going off topic and I apologise to Admin who have recently asked us to avoid doing so   (  but this question has bothered me a bit since the  '48 questions Kate refused to answer'  were made public  ) 

One of the questions related to Kate having once considered handing Madeleine's care over to a relative

It appeared so out of left field that it was a bit shocking  ...  where did that come  from ?  would the police have inexplicably plucked that specific question from mid air,  based on no knowledge or evidence at all  ?

When the same question was put to Gerry  (  who had  not  chosen to stay silent  )  he responded to the question of whether or not   Kate had  considered   handing Madeleine over to a relative  ...  "Not to  my knowledge" 

Not to his  KNOWLEDGE ! 

I  expected his answer to be a dismissive and contemptuous,  "No, of course not. My wife never considered any such thing"

He didn't though.  He made no denial of a subject the police appeared to have some knowledge of

It was an altogether odd exchange, I though
This was a strange question, yes, very unexpected from the police of a country where everything is sacrificed to "cocoon" your children. Except for cases of very precarious single family, adoption is pretty rare. People will help each other but children stay in their mother home.