Author Topic: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...  (Read 44773 times)

0 Members and 3 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline John

Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
« Reply #105 on: May 23, 2014, 08:56:53 PM »
Any investigator worth their salt would have established if Tannerman was indeed an innocent tourist before going on National TV.  The fact that Redwood couldn't state categorically that this was the case leaves a hole big enough to drive a coach and horses through imo.
A malicious prosecution for a crime which never existed. An exposé of egregious malfeasance by public officials.
Indeed, the truth never changes with the passage of time.

Offline Carana

Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
« Reply #106 on: May 23, 2014, 08:59:23 PM »
"Almost certainly" and "a revelation moment" which has changed the focus of the investigation.  And SY made a big thing about it on TV - they wouldn't do that if they weren't as sure as they could be.  And they wouldn't have been almost certain if the account of the innocent holidaymaker who they identified differed substantially in time or location or other detail from JT's statement.

Would the Met have felt confident in relaying this to the press if this person's account, and possibly that of a partner, had been contradictory to the view of other members of a large family group (even excluding younger children)?

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
« Reply #107 on: May 23, 2014, 09:00:47 PM »
Any investigator worth their salt would have established if Tannerman was indeed an innocent tourist before going on National TV.  The fact that Redwood couldn't state categorically that this was the case leaves a hole big enough to drive a coach and horses through imo.
where you see a huge hole, I see a tiny chink.  It would have been impossible for him to say 100% certain without 3rd party corroborating evidence like cctv.  'Almost certain' is as close as he could feasibly get to describing his certainty imo.

Offline John

Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
« Reply #108 on: May 23, 2014, 09:38:06 PM »
Why wasn't he taken back to the street and a reconstruction carried out?  Too many loose ends for my liking.  As I stated I think there is more wishful thinking than good old fashioned police work going on here.
« Last Edit: May 23, 2014, 09:39:57 PM by John »
A malicious prosecution for a crime which never existed. An exposé of egregious malfeasance by public officials.
Indeed, the truth never changes with the passage of time.

Offline Benice

Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
« Reply #109 on: May 24, 2014, 01:53:03 AM »
What exactly would be the point of taking a statement from an eye witness who claimed to have identified a suspect by his 'walk'?

Why did Tanner go on the surveillance if she couldn't identify the carrier?

IIRC Jane Tanner didn't know she was going to attend an ID parade until she got there.

In view of your comments above  -  can I take it that you don't think she gave a statement?     So do you concede that Amaral lied when he said  she ''formally identified Robert Murat' in his book? 

The truth IMO is that she did not ID Robert Murat or make a statement, but Amaral wanted his readers to think she had- just as he wanted viewers to think she had when he told the same lies during TV  interviews.    He lied, and then escalated his lies about JT when he falsely claimed she was present at the 'confrontation' meeting.  She was not.

If Jane Tanner had identified Robert Murat as the man she saw on the 3rd and made a signed statement confirming that (which would have involved PJ officers and an interpreter ) - then she would have to be insane to deny that happened knowing it could so easily be proved  to be untrue via her own witness statement and the witnesses who were present at the time.   There is not a scrap of evidence that JT is off her head.

Anyone who thinks that if she had identified Murat, Amaral would have sent her home without making a statement about the most important evidence which he had received to date  - to justify making  Murat an Arguido - is seriously in denial IMO.

The notion that innocence prevails over guilt – when there is no evidence to the contrary – is what separates civilization from barbarism.    Unfortunately, there are remains of barbarism among us.    Until very recently, it headed the PJ in Portimão. I hope he was the last one.
                                               Henrique Monteiro, chief editor, Expresso, Portugal

Offline Eleanor

Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
« Reply #110 on: May 24, 2014, 07:28:04 AM »

To whom did Jane Tanner "Formally Identify" Robert Murat?  It certainly wasn't Amaral.

Offline Victoria

Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
« Reply #111 on: May 24, 2014, 08:47:39 PM »
Why wasn't he taken back to the street and a reconstruction carried out?  Too many loose ends for my liking.  As I stated I think there is more wishful thinking than good old fashioned police work going on here.

Taken back to the street by who? At whose expense? Under which jurisdiction?

Offline Victoria

Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
« Reply #112 on: May 24, 2014, 08:49:39 PM »
To whom did Jane Tanner "Formally Identify" Robert Murat?  It certainly wasn't Amaral.

She didn't formally identify him, and even Amaral doesn't claim that Murat was made arguido as a result of the tapas group. The Portuguese police had their own reasons for being interested in Murat - it says as much in Amaral's book. There is a hell of a lot of nonsense being talked on this thread, so much so that it takes me back to the days of the mirror forums.

Offline Mr Moderator

Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
« Reply #113 on: May 25, 2014, 04:18:49 AM »
Gonçalo Amaral had an interest in Murat for several reasons.  What is crystal clear however is that had Tanner totally and absolutely failed to identify him then he would not have been investigated any further.  Tanner didn't know what Murat looked like until that fateful encounter with him just before the surveillance was to take place. In her rogatory interview she even admits that she didn't recognise the man in the surveillance as Murat, the man she had met just an hour previously even though this exercise was undertaken in broad daylight.  When she saw the carrier it was in darkness with poor street lighting.  Tanner adds that when she first met Murat outside his house he looked quite little but appeared quite big when she saw him on the telly. Confusion seems to have been the order of the day.

« Last Edit: May 25, 2014, 05:06:24 AM by Mr Moderator »

Offline Mr Gray

Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
« Reply #114 on: May 25, 2014, 10:29:46 AM »
By 11 May, eight days after Madeleine had been reported missing, one of the Portuguese Police team, Inspector Pedro Varanda, had become suspicious enough about Murat to file an urgent memo to his manager. His report, filed that day, included the following observations:

“Sir,

This relates to an informal conversation I’ve had with Robert Murat. As you will know, today at 11.30am, Inspector Patricia Duarte and I interviewed a British citizen called Dianne Webster. We realised she could not speak Portuguese, so we sought an English-speaking interpreter.

We decided to use a fellow British citizen, Robert J.Q.E. Murat, of whom we were aware from his previous translation work. His address is Casa Liliana, Rua Ramalhete, Praia da Luz, Lagos.

 After we’d finished interviewing Dianne Webster, I had an informal conversation in Portuguese with Murat. During this conversation, he displayed an unusual level of curiosity about the investigation that was developing around the disappearance of Madeleine McCann on 3 May.

To give an example, he insistently and repeatedly questioned me about the identity of possible suspects. He also questioned me about the investigation strategy of the head of our investigation. He even asked about what work the investigation team might be considering in the coming days.

 I became highly suspicious. His behavior was absolutely inappropriate for a translator. In response to such an unusual attitude, I played along, ducking the questions. I also reminded him to stick to his contractual role of translating. I pointed out that the whole investigation was still in the initial enquiry phase, and that therefore judicial secrecy rules still applied.

I also need to emphasise that the suspicions I had were reinforced when I became aware that Robert Murat would covertly attempt to catch glimpses of various documents, for example, items being prepared for the case files that make up the present inquiry. 

I noticed that Murat also displayed an enormous knowledge of all kinds of matters relating to the ‘Ocean Club Complex’, where the events under investigation had taken place, and of the routines followed by the McCann family and their companions during their respective stays in Praia da Luz. I would add that he has persistently tried to influence the conduct of the present investigation.
« Last Edit: May 26, 2014, 06:54:51 PM by John »

Offline jassi

Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
« Reply #115 on: May 25, 2014, 10:39:35 AM »
Just goes to show how suspicion might ultimately amount to nothing.
I believe everything. And l believe nothing.
I suspect everyone. And l suspect no one.
I gather the facts, examine the clues... and before   you know it, the case is solved!"

Or maybe not -

OG have been pushed out by the Germans who have reserved all the deck chairs for the foreseeable future

Offline Mr Gray

Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
« Reply #116 on: May 25, 2014, 10:48:56 AM »
Gonçalo Amaral had an interest in Murat for several reasons.  What is crystal clear however is that had Tanner totally and absolutely failed to identify him then he would not have been investigated any further.  Tanner didn't know what Murat looked like until that fateful encounter with him just before the surveillance was to take place. In her rogatory interview she even admits that she didn't recognise the man in the surveillance as Murat, the man she had met just an hour previously even though this exercise was undertaken in broad daylight.  When she saw the carrier it was in darkness with poor street lighting.  Tanner adds that when she first met Murat outside his house he looked quite little but appeared quite big when she saw him on the telly. Confusion seems to have been the order of the day.

This is the article from the guardian reporting on murats's specch to the Cambridge union....He sys it was a british journalist who caused his problems...


In Murat's case, a British journalist covering the disappearance had been "so anxious to break the story" that she created it. "She tried to convince the Portuguese police that I was acting suspiciously."

He had never been arrested but had been interviewed and made an "arguido", or official suspect. His arguido status unleashed a "torrent of outlandish, untrue and deeply hurtful allegations".


You seem to have several facts wrong...if your basic facts are wrong all your conclusions will be wrong

Offline Carana

Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
« Reply #117 on: May 25, 2014, 11:49:22 AM »
 307 Letter from Leicestershire Police constabulary regarding Lori Campbell's suspicions re: Murat (in English) 2007.05.07
308-Portuguese translation of above letter

THANKS TO KIZZY
02-Processo, Volume 2, Page 307-308
02_VOLUMEIIa_Page_307
02_VOLUMEIIa_Page_308
Letter from Leicester Constabulary
to Portugal Incident Room/Madeleine McCann
 

6th May 2007

Sir,

Lori CAMPBELL a reporter from the Sunday Mirror has contacted Leicestershire Police to report the following.
Lori has been speaking to an interpreter who has been helping authorities with the investigation into Madeleine's disappearance. He has only given his name as 'ROR' (sic) and has not given any background information about himself.
Lori has become suspicious of Rob as he has given conflicting accounts to various people and became very concerned when he noticed his photo being taken by the Mirror's photographer. 'ROB' stated to Lori that he is going through a messy divorce
In the UK at the moment and that he had a three year old daughter just like Madeleine, who he is separated from at the moment. He made a big show of telephoning his daughter in front of reporters, and Lori felt that he was being too loud and making a big thing of speaking to his daughter on the phone. The things that 'ROB' has said to Lori have raised her concerns about him.
Could you please call Lori who is still in Portugal to establish further details to identify 'ROB' in order to eliminate him from your enquiries on 07917 xxxxxx.
Submitted for information
 

308—Portuguese translation of above letter
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/LORRI-CAMPBELL.htm

Offline John

Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
« Reply #118 on: May 26, 2014, 07:12:49 PM »
Gonçalo Amaral had an interest in Murat for several reasons.  What is crystal clear however is that had Tanner totally and absolutely failed to identify him then he would not have been investigated any further.  Tanner didn't know what Murat looked like until that fateful encounter with him just before the surveillance was to take place. In her rogatory interview she even admits that she didn't recognise the man in the surveillance as Murat, the man she had met just an hour previously even though this exercise was undertaken in broad daylight.  When she saw the carrier it was in darkness with poor street lighting.  Tanner adds that when she first met Murat outside his house he looked quite little but appeared quite big when she saw him on the telly. Confusion seems to have been the order of the day.

It is evident that Robert Murat's curiosity and inquisitory approach to those he encountered in the case was perceived by the Portuguese detectives and reporters as something suspicious. It was indeed unfortunate that he just happened to live a short distance along the road where Tanner saw the carrier heading.  His formal questioning on the 14 May 2007 and the searches of his mothers villa and the other property he had access to which followed was not surprising given what had gone on.  It wasn't helped when three members of the tapas group, Russell, Rachael and Fiona also came forward a few days later to state they had seen him in the OC car park at about 1am on the morning after Madeleine disappeared, a claim which Murat has always hotly denied.

What relevance Jane's surveillance on the 13 May had may never fully be known but Amaral was certainly convinced.

« Last Edit: May 26, 2014, 07:14:37 PM by John »
A malicious prosecution for a crime which never existed. An exposé of egregious malfeasance by public officials.
Indeed, the truth never changes with the passage of time.

Offline Carana

Re: Jane Tanner claims she never identified Murat but...
« Reply #119 on: May 26, 2014, 08:08:51 PM »
It is evident that Robert Murat's curiosity and inquisitory approach to those he encountered in the case was perceived by the Portuguese detectives and reporters as something suspicious. It was indeed unfortunate that he just happened to live a short distance along the road where Tanner saw the carrier heading.  His formal questioning on the 14 May 2007 and the searches of his mothers villa and the other property he had access to which followed was not surprising given what had gone on.  It wasn't helped when three members of the tapas group, Russell, Rachael and Fiona also came forward a few days later to state they had seen him in the OC car park at about 1am on the morning after Madeleine disappeared, a claim which Murat has always hotly denied.

What relevance Jane's surveillance on the 13 May had may never fully be known but Amaral was certainly convinced.

Lori Campbell started it all off. I have no objection to her reporting her concern to the authorities (on the contrary), but I do have a problem with her reporting it to the world in general in the media. All because someone was trying to be helpful, and it reminded her of the Soham case? One creep (Ian Huntley) does not humanity make. What's the alternative? In a tsunami, you'd just walk away in case anyone thought that you were trying to drown someone as opposed to trying to help them get to safety?