In her book Kate says "Jane was concerned that he ( Murat ) might have been picked up purely as a result of the amateurish identity parade in which she had unwittingly participated"
Now why would she think that if she hadn't identified him ?
Kate continues ; "Jane phoned Bob Small to tell him she'd encountered Murat before her rendevous with the PJ and mentioned that Russell and Rachael had said they'd noticed him outside our flat on the night Madeleine vanished, in case either piece of information was important"
Kate doesn't actually state that Jane identified him as the man she saw with a child.
Nowhere in the PJ case against Murat is it written that anyone made any sort of ID of him. Jane Tanner's name is only mentioned in relation to the route from 5a to Murat's villa.
04_VOLUME_IVa_Page_958
04_VOLUME_IVa_Page_959
External Inquiry Report
Date. 2007-05-11
Place: Ocean Club, P da L.
Responsible Officers: Officers Joao Carlos and Luis Pereira
Description and Result:
Systematically analysed with the elements contained in the investigation that indicate how the action could eventually have occurred, the possibility of placing different valid hypotheses referring to the process of the action was concluded, it being the case that in all the equated scenarios, the direction of the escape route taken by the author (abductor) was questioned.
It should be remembered that Jane Tanner's witness statement confirms having seen and individual carrying a child, who would have left from Block 5 A and turned to the right, walking along Rua Agostinho da Silva and crossing the road at the junction with Rua Direita, where the entrance to the Tapas restaurant is situated, the route used by the parents when checking on the children, in this way placing himself at greater exposure.
In effect, if the action had been planned, the author should have - bearing in mind the physical space - chosen the contrary direction as his escape route, where there was a parking area at a distance of 20 metres, which would have been a discreet way to enable him to leave the scene unnoticed.
Given this reasoning, it was judged appropriate to visit the scene, in order to see the geographical viability of the correct perception of the events, or at least the closest possible approximation regarding their truth.
It was immediately possible to note that the Casa Liliana house, situated in Rua da Ramalhete, P da L, Lagos, owned by Robert Murat, could also de designated as Casa Liliana, situated on Rua Agostinho Silva, or in other words, situated in the same road as Block 5, precisely in the direction taken by the suspicious individual, described in Jane Tanner's witness account.
An image of the site is attached with indications relating to the above description.
Comment by the officer responsible for the inquiry:
Excepting superior opinion, the fact that had not been explained, concerning the abductor's escape route, would be clarified in the case that it were possible to report that the author (abductor) lives or has access to some space next to the site, namely in the direction in which an individual was seen to be leaving.
Signed
Attached map: 959