So what is the evidence for abduction?

[Benice]

& @ Benice

Exactly Alice.
This is the short and tall of it.
Of course, preconceptions and assumptions colour understanding, sometimes...

Your claim:
''How that squares with DI Redwoods alledged claim that Madeleine was abducted by a stranger I have no idea (but he never actually said that exactly)''
----------------------------------------------------------------

Quote from Andy Redwood

We have conducted a forensic analysis of the timelines and there is clearly opportunity there for Madeleine McCann to have been removed from that apartment alive.    And it is our belief as experienced investigators - on the evidence - that that is a criminal act that has been undertaken by a stranger.
Unquote

There are no 'ifs' or 'buts' to be seen in the above.      It's a clear statement by Andy Redwood which shows that your claim that he never actually said that - is incorrect.

[ferryman]

Your claim:
''How that squares with DI Redwoods alledged claim that Madeleine was abducted by a stranger I have no idea (but he never actually said that exactly)''
----------------------------------------------------------------

Quote from Andy Redwood

We have conducted a forensic analysis of the timelines and there is clearly opportunity there for Madeleine McCann to have been removed from that apartment alive.    And it is our belief as experienced investigators - on the evidence - that that is a criminal act that has been undertaken by a stranger.
Unquote

There are no 'ifs' or 'buts' to be seen in the above.      It's a clear statement by Andy Redwood which shows that your claim that he never actually said that - is incorrect.

Ah!  But Andy Redwood was (and probably still is!) "in it" ....

[stephen25000]

Ah!  But Andy Redwood was (and probably still is!) "in it" ....

She could have walked out of the apartment as well.

Redwood also stated she might not have left the apartment alive.

Redwood said she could be alive or dead.

Did Redwood read about Schrodinger's cat ?

[ferryman]

She could have walked out of the apartment as well.

Redwood also stated she might not have left the apartment alive.

Redwood said she could be alive or dead.

Did Redwood read about Schrodinger's cat ?

Keep dreaming ....

[stephen25000]

Keep dreaming ....

I don't have dreams about Madeleine returning ferryman.

What about you ?

[Mr Gray]

She could have walked out of the apartment as well.

Redwood also stated she might not have left the apartment alive.

Redwood said she could be alive or dead.

Did Redwood read about Schrodinger's cat ?

perhaps you should read about Shrodinger's cat...the cat existed as both alive and dead at the same time...not alive or dead

[ferryman]

I don't have dreams about Madeleine returning ferryman.

What about you ?

I don't have dreams about Kate and Gerry languishing in a Portuguese jail for the crimes of others against their daughter.

What about you?

[stephen25000]

perhaps you should read about Shrodinger's cat...the cat existed as both alive and dead at the same time...not alive or dead

I have read it dave.

In connection with multiverse theory.

So if you believe she is alive, where exactly would that be  ?

With a paedo or with a really nice family ?

Have you seen the advice given to 'Madeleine' on the facebook page ?

[stephen25000]

I don't have dreams about Kate and Gerry languishing in a Portuguese jail for the crimes of others against their daughter.

What about you?

Neither do I ferryman.

It seems you do though.

[Mr Gray]

I have read it dave.

In connection with multiverse theory.

So if you believe she is alive, where exactly would that be  ?

With a paedo or with a really nice family ?

Have you seen the advice given to 'Madeleine' on the facebook page ?

seems like you didn't understand it....alive and dead...not alive or dead

[stephen25000]

From facebook


'" C'mon Maddie, Look around you, look for signs, look for anything, we are all waiting for you to come home to your Mummy and Daddy!!!" '

[stephen25000]

seems like you didn't understand it....alive and dead...not alive or dead

I understand it perfectly well dave.

I was paying tribute to Redwood. %£&)**# &%&£(+ %£&)**# &%&£(+

[stephen25000]

seems like you didn't understand it....alive and dead...not alive or dead

You never know dave. in some parallel realities, the mccanns didn't leave their children to go drinking.

[Alice Purjorick]

perhaps you should read about Shrodinger's cat...the cat existed as both alive and dead at the same time...not alive or dead

Simon's cat is much better and about as relevant to this thread.

[Angelo222]

You never know dave. in some parallel realities, the mccanns didn't leave their children to go drinking.

According to their statements the drinking started before they left the apartment.  So by 10pm they must have been well oiled.