Author Topic: Timeline. Lead up to Kates alert indicating that Madeleine had disappeared.  (Read 22998 times)

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

Silkywhiskers

  • Guest
Gerry said Kate left at 10:03 and was worried 10 minutes later where she was then she came back just before 10:15. She wasn't gone long according to others. Matt said it was 9:50 when she left and he didn't do his 10pm check. Russ said he got back at 9:45 and only had a few bites of his steak when Kate came running. Now this means before 10pm not after. Hopefully SY will ask Matt how he knew the time because I predict he checked his watch to see if it was 10pm time for his check and then found that it wasn't. This is easy to find out. So they may have to check where somebody was from 10 to 10:15 after that other revelation.

It is NOT "easy" to find out.

The entire investigation was archived because the PJ could not obtain the cooperation of those involved for a reconstruction, which was ESSENTIAL to sort out the times and movements.

One might ponder why SY have skipped the reconstruction and the reinterviews (of even the staff!) and gone straight for the body.

Would phone pings have something to do with it?
« Last Edit: June 02, 2014, 09:45:23 PM by Silkywhiskers »

Offline pathfinder73

Smithman was seen after the alarm had been raised at 10:03. Aoife Smith said they left Kelly's bar at 10pm which connects with a 10:03 sighting time.  She was the only one right on the Dolphin restaurant time. Martin and Peter were wrong on the time. 9:50 is an incorrect sighting time and that time was used in the McCanns own reconstruction.
« Last Edit: June 02, 2014, 09:44:17 PM by pathfinder73 »
Smithman carrying a child in his arms checked his watch after passing the Smith family and the time was 10:03. Both are still unidentified 10 years later.

Silkywhiskers

  • Guest
Smithman was seen after the alarm had been raised at 10:03. Aoife Smith said they left Kelly's bar at 10pm which connects with a 10:03 sighting time.  She was the only one right on the Dolphin restaurant time. Martin and Peter were wrong on the time. 9:50 is an incorrect sighting time and that time was used in the McCanns own reconstruction.

None of them said 10.03, did they?

They all said "about" and "around".

No one was sure of the exact time - why would you be?  Oh look here's an abductor with a stolen child, I better check my watch?

Please.  They DID NOT KNOW WHAT THEY'D SEEN AT THE TIME.

Everyone was a few drinks in, having a great old time in a holiday resort. 

A lot of people wouldn't even be WEARING a watch on a holiday.

Offline pathfinder73

None of them said 10.03, did they?

They all said "about" and "around".

No one was sure of the exact time - why would you be?  Oh look here's an abductor with a stolen child, I better check my watch?

Please.  They DID NOT KNOW WHAT THEY'D SEEN AT THE TIME.

Everyone was a few drinks in, having a great old time in a holiday resort. 

A lot of people wouldn't even be WEARING a watch on a holiday.

Gerry said 10:03 which is the important point.
Smithman carrying a child in his arms checked his watch after passing the Smith family and the time was 10:03. Both are still unidentified 10 years later.

Martina

  • Guest
Gerry said 10:03 which is the important point.

Gerry said Kate left at 22:03, and came back screaming later.

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
WHERE did you get 10.03?

Pulled it out of your imagination?

The time the Smiths saw Smithman is UNCONFIRMED but assumed to be just before 10.

The only guide to the time they saw him was by counting back to the time they signed the restaurant tab.  The rest of it is conjecture.
Just before or just after 10pm, there's still no way Gerry could have been where you think he was, doing what you think he was doing as we know from Dianne Webster that he was sat at the Tapas table when the slarm was raised, which you have stated was just after 10pm.

Silkywhiskers

  • Guest
Just before or just after 10pm, there's still no way Gerry could have been where you think he was, doing what you think he was doing as we know from Dianne Webster that he was sat at the Tapas table when the slarm was raised, which you have stated was just after 10pm.

Keep going....all these holes you dig are just getting deeper....no pun intended...

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
Keep going....all these holes you dig are just getting deeper....no pun intended...
Oh?  Which part of what I have just written do you dispute?  It can't be the time the alarm was raised as you have told us when that was.  Was it the Time of the Smiths sighting?  Well another expert on here tells us it occurred at 10.03pm so it can't be that.  Which just leaves Dianne Webster's statement.  I guess that's what you have a problem  with then...?

Martina

  • Guest
Okay I made a small exercise and checked what did actually Gerry said about the time of Kate's check and return in each of his statements.

4th May:

At about 22.00 it was his wife Kate who went to check on the children. She entered the apartment by the door using the key and saw immediately that the door to the children's bedroom was completely open, the window was also open, the blinds were raised and the curtains were drawn open.
The side door leading to the living room was closed, which as previously stated, was never left locked. Faced with this troubling situation, Kate checked that the twins were in their beds, unlike Madeleine, who had disappeared. After checking the apartment thoroughly, his wife, quite shocked and upset, went to the restaurant, alerting the witness and the others about the disappearance.


10thMay

Half and hour later without anything to signal, it being 22h03, he turned to alert KATE that it was time for her to go to see the children. She immediately made her way to the apartment by the usual path, she having entered by the rear door. About 10 minutes later, he started to worry about her lateness and, at the moment he prepared to stand and to go to see the reason for her lateness, KATE appeared running, completely distraught and crying, saying that MADELEINE had disappeared and that she was sure because she had looked throughout the house.

Interesting. In the first statement there is no mention about an exceptionally long check by Kate making Gerry worried and the time of the alarm is  quite vaguely described as "at about 22:00". Then in the second one we are given a very precise timing - 22:03. The human memory tends to work the other way, from the sharp and exact memories to the blurry and vague ones.

Then in Gerry's second statement appears this:

The deponent had had the wrong idea that MATHEW had seen the bedroom external blinds closed when he was there at 21H30, the reason for that was that he thought the disappearance would have been happened between 21h30 and 22h00, it being that, actually, he is [?] convinced that the abduction occurred in the period understood to be between his visit at 21h05 and MATHEW'S visit at 21H30.

In other words Gerald McCann was trying to convince the police that whoever was seen that night in the town, carrying a girl it couldn't be him, as the abduction absolutely had to occur during the time he had an alibi for. Yessir.


Aaaand 7th September:

The third check was made by Kate at around 22:00. He does not know how long it was before Kate returned, but he does remember that shortly before she returned he was thinking of going to see what was going on, as it seemed a long time and he thought that one of children might have woken up.

We are back to the vague "around 22:00". By the way, Kate as a perfect mother was certainly fully able to deal with such a minor problem as putting the child back to bed. So what was Gerry so worried about?

Martina

  • Guest
No he didn't, not if the alarm was raised just after 10pm (as we have been reliably informed  on here tonight was the case).

We were reliable informed by whom, because somehow I cannot recollect this event? Gerald himself stated TWICE that the alarm was raised at around 22:00., and Kate backed it up with her own statement from 4th May. Are you saying that the McCanns are lying???

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
Yeah well whatever.

What was Kate doing in those missing 10 minutes then?
What missing ten minutes?  Perhaps she donned a short dark wig, Gerry's trews and went for a walk, is that what you're thinking?  Oh hang on though!  Who was the woman who raised the alarm then?  A Kate looky-likey I bet! 
Case solved.

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
We were reliable informed by whom, because somehow I cannot recollect this event? Gerald himself stated TWICE that the alarm was raised at around 22:00., and Kate backed it up with her own statement from 4th May. Are you saying that the McCanns are lying???
Reliably informed by our resident case expert Silkywhiskets of course!

Silkywhiskers

  • Guest
What missing ten minutes?  Perhaps she donned a short dark wig, Gerry's trews and went for a walk, is that what you're thinking?  Oh hang on though!  Who was the woman who raised the alarm then?  A Kate looky-likey I bet! 
Case solved.


Well according to Team McCann, we have an "abductor" who looked just like Gerry, so why not fill PDL up with doppelgangers too?

Give the burglars/abductors/cleaners/apartment managers some company...

Busy night wasnt it?

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
About 10 minutes later, he started to worry about her lateness

From his rog statement.

So what was she doing?
Checking the apartment for Madeleine?  She had just discovered she'd gone missing hadn't she?

Silkywhiskers

  • Guest
Checking the apartment for Madeleine?  She had just discovered she'd gone missing hadn't she?

The children were "at the bottom of the garden".

Kate is a fit individual.

How long should it take her to cross the metaphorical garden, climb half a dozen stairs, go in through an unlocked door and "check"?

About 3 minutes maximum.  6 round trip at most, presuming no one had vanished or woken or died.

So what was she doing for the other 4 (at least) minutes?  She does not account for this time.  It was long enough for Gerry to get concerned, that means she took longer than normal, agreed?

Long enough for a partying relaxed Gerry to worry, apparently - even though Kate may have gone to the toilet too on her check.

Turn your computer off and sit in silence for 4 minutes.  It's actually quite a long time. 

In four minutes, a fast runner can be a mile away.