Author Topic: Timeline. Lead up to Kates alert indicating that Madeleine had disappeared.  (Read 22973 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
The children were "at the bottom of the garden".

Kate is a fit individual.

How long should it take her to cross the metaphorical garden, climb half a dozen stairs, go in through an unlocked door and "check"?

About 3 minutes maximum.  6 round trip at most, presuming no one had vanished or woken or died.

So what was she doing for the other 4 (at least) minutes?  She does not account for this time.  It was long enough for Gerry to get concerned, that means she took longer than normal, agreed?

Long enough for a partying relaxed Gerry to worry, apparently - even though Kate may have gone to the toilet too on her check.

Turn your computer off and sit in silence for 4 minutes.  It's actually quite a long time. 

In four minutes, a fast runner can be a mile away.
Right.  So maybe she went on a run, is that what you're suggesting?

Offline pegasus

... During this time ... had plenty of time to sneak out with ...
Yes agreed there was time, but just because there was time, does not mean it happened during that time.
IMO there was no removal of any kind by anyone during that 1 left at table period.
« Last Edit: June 02, 2014, 11:18:36 PM by pegasus »

Offline pegasus

A straightforward explanation, comparing various statements, might be that about 10 minutes is an overestimate?

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
Don't be so obstreperous.

You know full well what it indicates

That there is periods of time of that night that are NOT EXPLAINED.

And/or lied about.

Take your pick.

Obstreperous?  That means noisy and difficult to control.  Are you sure that was the word you wanted?

I have really no idea what you are driving at viz-a-viz Kate's missing 4 minutes.  The woman took longer than expected because she had just discovered her child missing and was presumably searching the apartment looking for her. Gerry would not have factored this into his thought processes regarding the length of time she was gone as he wouldn't have known at this point that Madeleine was missing.  What is so hard to grasp about this?

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
A straightforward explanation, comparing various statements, might be that about 10 minutes is an overestimate?
Hang on - that's way too plausible an answer, disallowed on the grounds that the McCanns are not allowed to make any mistakes or miscalculation of the time in their statements, according to some posters on here anyway.

Martina

  • Guest
Okay, so I did another exersize checking and comparing the Tapas Crowd statements about the time of the alarm. I excluded Jane, as she was not at the table during this event and Dianne Webster who does not give any time assesments, even very vague.

David Payne - in the first statement he says it was towards 10 p. m, in the rogatory he states that Kate came back just after ten.

Fiona Payne - only in her rogatory she talked about the time of the alarm and she stated it was between quartet to ten and ten.

Matthew Oldfield - in the first statement we find the vague "around ten", in the second he states Kate went to check at 21:50, then in the rogatory one he says

and I asked the reception to phone the Police, and that must have been about five past, it's difficult to know what time it was at that time, but maybe about ten past ten, five past ten, ten past ten'.

So at ten past ten they already managed to run from the Tapas to apartment, search it, check on their own children, and Matthew after that managed to get to the reception desk. All of it in ten minutes? I don't think so.

Rachael Oldfield - in the first statement we find a good ole' "around ten". The second one informs us that Kate got up from the table at five to ten/ten o'clock and the same timing is repeated in the rogatory.

Russel O'Brien - in the first statement he states Kate went to check on children at ten o'clock. In the second statement he is more vague stating it was around ten. In the rogatory he says it was approximately just before ten.

Sssoooo... what do you think, fellow posters?

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
Okay, so I did another exersize checking and comparing the Tapas Crowd statements about the time of the alarm. I excluded Jane, as she was not at the table during this event and Dianne Webster who does not give any time assesments, even very vague.

David Payne - in the first statement he says it was towards 10 p. m, in the rogatory he states that Kate came back just after ten.

Fiona Payne - only in her rogatory she talked about the time of the alarm and she stated it was between quartet to ten and ten.

Matthew Oldfield - in the first statement we find the vague "around ten", in the second he states Kate went to check at 21:50, then in the rogatory one he says

and I asked the reception to phone the Police, and that must have been about five past, it's difficult to know what time it was at that time, but maybe about ten past ten, five past ten, ten past ten'.

So at ten past ten they already managed to run from the Tapas to apartment, search it, check on their own children, and Matthew after that managed to get to the reception desk. All of it in ten minutes? I don't think so.

Rachael Oldfield - in the first statement we find a good ole' "around ten". The second one informs us that Kate got up from the table at five to ten/ten o'clock and the same timing is repeated in the rogatory.

Russel O'Brien - in the first statement he states Kate went to check on children at ten o'clock. In the second statement he is more vague stating it was around ten. In the rogatory he says it was approximately just before ten.

Sssoooo... what do you think, fellow posters?
I would say that Kate raised the alarm at around 10pm, give or take a few minutes either side.

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
Do you actually expect all 9 witnesses to give matching, precise times?  Really?

Offline pegasus

Hang on - that's way too plausible an answer, disallowed on the grounds that the McCanns are not allowed to make any mistakes or miscalculation of the time in their statements, according to some posters on here anyway.
Well I don't see any way you would get more than one peep fibbing at most, so JIMO any theory which has more is straight out the door.

Martina

  • Guest
I would say that Kate raised the alarm at around 10pm, give or take a few minutes either side.

"Around" is a very vague description that might even reach a timespan of a half of the hour (from 9:45 to 10:15). So it clears absolutely nothing.

Martina

  • Guest
Do you actually expect all 9 witnesses to give matching, precise times?  Really?

These witnesses were allegedly doing regular check-ups on their children. How can you do regular check-ups without knowing what time it is?

Silkywhiskers

  • Guest
These witnesses were allegedly doing regular check-ups on their children. How can you do regular check-ups without knowing what time it is?

Indeed, Gerry said he had to remind her it was her "turn".
« Last Edit: June 04, 2014, 04:26:25 AM by John »

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
All the statements roughly concur that 10pm was the time that the alarm was raised, give or take a few minutes.  Why you're having to make such a song and a dance about it is a mystery to me.  As has oft been said (and it usually gets ignored by the doubters) if each and every statement mirrored the other in all the specific details then that would be way more fishy IMO.  Like, you know when children copy the bright kid's homework and then they all have the same mistake in their work.  Whereas, different points of view, different knowledge, different errors makes a far more believable overall picture.  I don't expect you to agree Silky and I'm off to bed now [... moderated ...]
« Last Edit: June 04, 2014, 04:28:19 AM by John »

Silkywhiskers

  • Guest
All the statements roughly concur that 10pm was the time that the alarm was raised, give or take a few minutes.  Why you're having to make such a song and a dance about it is a mystery to me.  As has oft been said (and it usually gets ignored by the doubters) if each and every statement mirrored the other in all the specific details then that would be way more fishy IMO.  Like, you know when children copy the bright kid's homework and then they all have the same mistake in their work.  Whereas, different points of view, different knowledge, different errors makes a far more believable overall picture.  I don't expect you to agree Silky and I'm off to bed now [... moderated ...]

It is not ME using the timeline as "proof of innocence", it is YOU.

I have insisted all the way along no one is sure.  That's because no one was sure, and the refusal to participate in a reconstruction DIRECTLY resulted in the case being archived.

So let's agree that no one really knows who was where when that night.  It'll save another 500 pages.
« Last Edit: June 04, 2014, 04:29:18 AM by John »

Offline Brietta

It is not ME using the timeline as "proof of innocence", it is YOU.

I have insisted all the way along no one is sure.  That's because no one was sure, and the refusal to participate in a reconstruction DIRECTLY resulted in the case being archived.

So let's agree that no one really knows who was where when that night.  It'll save another 500 pages.

For the record ...

Dr Amaral decided against holding a reconstruction for his own reasons ~ the Drs McCann have never refused to take part in a reconstruction.
"All I'm going to say is that we've conducted a very serious investigation and there's no indication that Madeleine McCann's parents are connected to her disappearance. On the other hand, we have a lot of evidence pointing out that Christian killed her," Wolter told the "Friday at 9"....