Author Topic: Empathy and Support  (Read 52773 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

icabodcrane

  • Guest
Re: Empathy and Support
« Reply #30 on: June 23, 2014, 02:41:43 PM »








I simply cannot understand how anyone can wish a little girl to be dead.


 I find it almost impossible to understand people who do not wish the same, who prefer to wish the child dead.



In propaganda terms this is what's known as  'exchanging a term'

You have redefined your opponents' argument to better suit your own prejudices by declaring that those who  'think'  the child is dead  actually  'wish'  she was

No-one here  'wishes'  Madeleine was dead. That is a ridiculous  ( and rather contemptuos thing to say ) ,   which leaves your opening post/argument  devoid of substance and utterly pointless
« Last Edit: June 23, 2014, 02:43:24 PM by icabodcrane »

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: Empathy and Support
« Reply #31 on: June 23, 2014, 02:55:17 PM »
In propaganda terms this is what's known as  'exchanging a term'

You have redefined your opponents' argument to better suit your own prejudices by declaring that those who  'think'  the child is dead  actually  'wish'  she was

No-one here  'wishes'  Madeleine was dead. That is a ridiculous  ( and rather contemptuos thing to say ) ,   which leaves your opening post/argument  devoid of substance and utterly pointless

Perhaps there is some alternative explanation for you obviously lip-smacking relish at the (as it turned out, false!)  report that the probe would be using jcbs in their searches.

As I recall you put it:

You don't use diggers to look for evidence, you use diggers to look for a BODY!

As it turns out, they haven't used diggers ...

Offline gilet

Re: Empathy and Support
« Reply #32 on: June 23, 2014, 04:22:32 PM »
Which poster actually made such claim? I haven't noticed that. Most people here, I think, wish Maddie to be alive and unharmed. Me included, as I stated it before. So who made this claim?

Or is it maybe another subtle attempt to paint the people who do not think it is very probable Maddie is alive and well (but do not wish her dead) as baaaad, bad, empathy lacking inhuman monsters?

I shall not repeat the name of the person who did claim that. It is a poster who has replied on this thread and states that she does not apologise for her views.


Offline gilet

Re: Empathy and Support
« Reply #33 on: June 23, 2014, 04:44:28 PM »
Personally I think anyone who won't even consider that someone living in permanent terrible pain, or mental impairment with no hope of reprieve may prefer an alternative is totally lacking in empathy.

Please re-read my post. At no point did I make any such claim so if your post is intended as a reply to mine then it is not exactly a very sensible reply.

I agree that the person has every right to make their own decision (when of an appropriate age and of sound mind) to make their own decision.

But that is not the point of my post, a fact I suspect you already know.

My point is that those who state that they would give that person no chance and who claim that the person would be better off dead are utterly heartless.

Offline gilet

Re: Empathy and Support
« Reply #34 on: June 23, 2014, 04:46:13 PM »
Just another post to support the McCanns.

You lost me Gilet at the word DISGRACE.

That probably explains why you fail to understand just how disgrace -ed the cop who was thrown off the McCann case really is.

But back on topic. I am sorry that you are incapable of reading a thoughtful post about empathy and suffering.

Offline gilet

Re: Empathy and Support
« Reply #35 on: June 23, 2014, 04:54:26 PM »
what a  consending post  i live with chronic pain  from severe scoliosis and  do 4  injecions a  day   of insulin  for type one diabetes i also have  severe anxiety and depression and cerebal palsy from  being  born without a heartbeat at birth   where i   almost  died  i  was    a   footlong breech and my twin and my  cords  wrapped around my  neck  most likley aspergers    due to cortex  damage from my  birth   and yet the mcann supporters call me chucky mispell etc and  all kinds of other stuff   all because dont believe the mcanns   i  never  was and never have been stupid like mcann supporters have said i am           i dont  expect anyone to feel sorry for me but  gilets post  pissed me off so much that i could not   stay silent anymore

everybody in my life  love that i have my own opinion becaus ei couldnt talk clearly until i was 10 years old im also going to be   honest  i have been  in therapy  for  16  months    to deal with the severe  pain and anxiety i live with everyday  that the strong pain medications   i take   dont   cure   so all the     stuff  written about me   needs to  stop   i have no  issues from being alone   when i was 11   but  i do have  a   issue with the mcanns not being accountable for their actions in regards to their children  because i cannot have children and yet they  can  and did and abandoned them   do you     people  who  pick on  me for having a  opinion understand that pain?? no its all about kate mcanns pain   of her own making  and maddie paid the price for gerry and kates actions

 no doubt i will  be abused and made  fun of because of this post too but i dont care   i will never    apologize about how i feel about the  mcanns because if i had been   able to have     a   child like maddie i would never have left her to  fend for herself

In precisely what way was my post condescending (sic)?

There was nothing in my post which referred directly to you.

This thread is not about your specific problems. It is about the way in which people are unable to feel empathy. I am truly sorry that you suffer in the way you do.

I would have thought that you, of all people, would have been able to appreciate that the very idea of claiming that people who are suffering would be better off dead than alive is completely barbaric.

It is up to everyone around those who are suffering to help them cope in any way they can, to pray that the suffering be relieved, and to offer support, whether that suffering is as a cause of illness or caused by others treating a person badly as is possible in the case of Madeleine McCann if she is still alive.

Why you should believe that the opening post of this thread will be a reason to mock you personally, I simply do not understand.

Offline gilet

Re: Empathy and Support
« Reply #36 on: June 23, 2014, 04:56:27 PM »
This isn't about you, Carly. 

You chose to insert yourself into this case some seven years ago, making endless derogatory and vitriolic comments about the McCanns and then playing the "but I'm disabled" card whenever challenged. 

One may have thought that maybe your disabilities would allow you to feel some empathy for others challenges, but it seems not.

I agree. When Carlymichelle chooses of her own adult free will to make vile comments about a missing little girl or her parents then it is the freedom of speech of those who read those comments to challenge her over them.


Offline gilet

Re: Empathy and Support
« Reply #37 on: June 23, 2014, 05:00:05 PM »
me being disabled has no baring on what i think of the mcanns i have the ability to think for myself and i do  so i have alot of compassion for many  walks of life including little maddie but i cant for gerry and  kate      did  you  read where i cannot have   children  how do you think people who cannot have children feel  when they read that the mcanns left their  children alone  and  one  vanished and people like you mcann supporters justify it    you  will never understand  me   so  you   have no right to comment

Well, if your being disabled has no bearing, why have you referred to it so often in so many of your posts over the last seven years? It is you dragging the subject of your disability into your posts not me.

I am really surprised that as someone with such disability as you described in the earlier post in this thread for example, that you cannot understand the point I am making that judging someone on their disability or suffering alone is so wrong. Those who state that they believe Madeleine would be better off dead are concentrating only on the suffering that they believe she may have been subjected to and ignoring all other positive aspects of her future life.

Offline Eleanor

Re: Empathy and Support
« Reply #38 on: June 23, 2014, 05:04:38 PM »
CarlyMichelle doesn't seem to see the irony of her own position when it comes to the pain and suffering of others.  She expects sympathy, but won't afford it to other people.  When in fact she should be the one to understand the most.

Offline gilet

Re: Empathy and Support
« Reply #39 on: June 23, 2014, 05:15:13 PM »
im a  athest so christian  values have no meaning to  me 8((()*/

Actually, empathy and the idea of caring for others is not a Christian (or religious) dogma at all. It is simply humanity at its finest.

We are discussing human values not specifically Christian values.

Just because, as well as empathising I suggested some might pray for those who are suffering does not mean that the two are inseparable.

Offline gilet

Re: Empathy and Support
« Reply #40 on: June 23, 2014, 05:16:29 PM »
As an objective point of semantics, it is only truly possible to have empathy with someone in whose shoes you have travelled.

I do not have empathy with the McCanns because I have never experienced anything like what they have experienced.

But I do have plenty of sympathy, which is quite different ...

I fear that you have a very narrow view of empathy. There are many definitions of the word. I think of it as a wider action than you.

Offline gilet

Re: Empathy and Support
« Reply #41 on: June 23, 2014, 05:20:08 PM »
How can you have sympathy for something they are responsible for in the first place ?

That post is the very essence of your attitude.

This thread is about the suffering of the little child, Madeleine McCann but you simply cannot get beyond that ridiculous and immature fixation of yours that the only matter of importance is the fact that the McCanns made a bad judgement call, a fact that they cannot change.


Offline gilet

Re: Empathy and Support
« Reply #42 on: June 23, 2014, 05:23:04 PM »
it gives me great pleasure that regardless of the ridiculous theories and hate shown on this forum towards the maccanns that they are now regarded as not suspects by SY and it is their opinon that counts...not some posters on the net who do not understand the evidence

And it gives me hope that, having been let down by the PJ who did not investigate all possibilities, Madeleine is now being given the benefit of a thorough Police investigation. If, by any chance, Madeleine is being held and is suffering then such a search is the best hope of some day relieving that suffering.

Offline carlymichelle

Re: Empathy and Support
« Reply #43 on: June 23, 2014, 05:23:57 PM »
If the thread really is supposed to be about empathy in a global sense and the finer characteristics of man kind why has it been necessary to make less than complimentary remarks about Dr Amaral in para 2 and the last para?
Surely a thread on empathy if genuine would stand in its own right without resort to those remarks?

didnt you know   only the mccans deserve empathy   according to mcann supporters??

Offline gilet

Re: Empathy and Support
« Reply #44 on: June 23, 2014, 05:24:48 PM »
I think there are two types of people in this world - when it comes to people's reactions to something going badly wrong because of human error.

I.E.

1.  People whose first instinct is to concentrate on solving the problem caused - regardless of who made a mistake. 

2. People whose first instinct is to allocate blame - and who just want to punish the person for making a mistake.

The McCanns made a human error.  IMO they are allowed to -  because they are human.  It's as simple as that.       It is their family who are the ones who have suffered terribly as a result of it - not those who spend their time gleefully reminding them that they are to blame and so deserve no sympathy.

Anyone who has a TV will have seen the terrible cruelty and abuse being inflicted daily on little girls as we speak.   IMO what the McCanns did - i.e. they left their happy, well cared for, beloved liittle girl fast asleep - while they sat 50 metres away - pales into insignificance in comparison.

In the meantime the monster who took advantage of that human error and ruined the lives of a whole family - the person who does deserve blame and punishment - is still free to do it again.

Excellent points.