Author Topic: Empathy and Support  (Read 52650 times)

0 Members and 8 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline gilet

Empathy and Support
« on: June 22, 2014, 09:02:56 PM »
Kate and Gerry McCann have stated clearly on many occasions that they do understand that their little daughter, Madeleine, may in fact be dead. I agree with that.

However, unlike Amaral, who wrote a book to salvage his honour (and to make money off the back of the case which his team failed to solve), and the others who like to declare that Madeleine is dead I am not prepared to right the child off in such a disgusting way. And nor, of course, are her parents.

There is absolutely no evidence (reliable or otherwise) that proves that Madeleine is dead. Nothing. Yet this disgraceful man chooses to write a book and publish it based entirely on that premise. He even states that this could damage the case.

There are others who have, on various social media, declared the same. It has even been said on this forum on occasion.

Some of those making this claim attempt to justify their action by saying that it would be better for this little girl to be dead rather than suffering at the hands of tormentors. I find that to be a very insipid argument, almost nothing more than an excuse for them wanting to say she is dead.

I refute that attempt at a justification absolutely.

I hope Madeleine is alive and found soon. That is the Christian view.

I simply cannot understand how anyone can wish a little girl to be dead.

Do the people, including some on this forum, who have made this claim that she would be better off dead really believe that, simply because she may currently be suffering?

Do they wish everyone who is suffering in some way at present to be dead? Would it be right to say that all those suffering from cancer would be better off dead? (It would certainly save the nation an absolute fortune.) Should we simply give up on those who suffer horrendous pain daily because of illness or have an incurable disability which causes pain and suffering and say they would be better off dead?

I have a close relative suffering from very painful cancer at the moment and in exactly the same way I hope she may have her suffering relieved and be able in the future to live a fulfilling life for years to come I wish the same for Madeleine McCann. I do not wish my relative to be dead and I do not wish Madeleine to be dead.

Instead I wish the doctors to do whatever they can to find a pain-free way forward my relative and I wish the Police to do absolutely everything they can to find Madeleine.  I want both searches to be successful so that the suffering might end.

In Madeleine's case I fervently believe that there is hope of finding her alive and that should that happen, her being returned to a loving supportive family could well lead to her having a happy future. It will of course be difficult (in much the same way as recovering from cancer can be difficult). Life would never be the same as it was before. That is inevitable. But there have been occasions when captives have returned to their families and been able to live fulfilling lives again. That can also happen in the case of Madeleine.

I find it almost impossible to understand people who do not wish the same, who prefer to wish the child dead.

If anyone has a cancer sufferer in their family, I sincerely hope that you do not give up on that person, that you write on the Internet that you think they would be better off dead.

I would hope that you are able to support him or her in whatever way possible even if that help is simply to say a prayer for them. It is hard. It is horrendously hard but it is the decent human thing to do. It is never easy to empathise with those who are suffering or handicapped, to stand (even for a moment) in their place and feel their suffering, their difference, their difficulties, their pain. But we do it (those of us who try to be decent members of society) to the best of our ability.

And on occasion the suffering does abate, the cancer sufferer does find remission, the formerly abducted person does return to loved ones and lead a fulfilling life. Another relative of mine spent two years undergoing cancer treatment and was near death's door but that was some time ago and having witnessed her playing with her new-born grandchild in recent months I know that every day of life is a blessing to her.

For those reasons I shall never, ever (until there is no further hope) declare this little missing girl dead (as Amaral has done in order to profit from his theories (and recent fantasies) about her parents). And I shall always hope for her safe return to her family.







« Last Edit: July 02, 2014, 12:14:22 PM by John »

Martina

  • Guest
Re: Empathy and Support
« Reply #1 on: June 23, 2014, 02:02:39 AM »

I simply cannot understand how anyone can wish a little girl to be dead.

Do the people, including some on this forum, who have made this claim that she would be better off dead really believe that, simply because she may currently be suffering?

Which poster actually made such claim? I haven't noticed that. Most people here, I think, wish Maddie to be alive and unharmed. Me included, as I stated it before. So who made this claim?

Or is it maybe another subtle attempt to paint the people who do not think it is very probable Maddie is alive and well (but do not wish her dead) as baaaad, bad, empathy lacking inhuman monsters?
« Last Edit: June 23, 2014, 02:06:32 AM by Martina »

Offline slartibartfast

Re: Empathy and Support
« Reply #2 on: June 23, 2014, 04:27:36 AM »
Personally I think anyone who won't even consider that someone living in permanent terrible pain, or mental impairment with no hope of reprieve may prefer an alternative is totally lacking in empathy.
« Last Edit: June 23, 2014, 06:26:01 AM by Slartibartfast »
“Reasoning will never make a Man correct an ill Opinion, which by Reasoning he never acquired”.

Offline colombosstogey

Re: Empathy and Support
« Reply #3 on: June 23, 2014, 04:46:30 AM »
Just another post to support the McCanns.

You lost me Gilet at the word DISGRACE.


Offline carlymichelle

Re: Empathy and Support
« Reply #4 on: June 23, 2014, 06:10:14 AM »
 what a  consending post  i live with chronic pain  from severe scoliosis and  do 4  injecions a  day   of insulin  for type one diabetes i also have  severe anxiety and depression and cerebal palsy from  being  born without a heartbeat at birth   where i   almost  died  i  was    a   footlong breech and my twin and my  cords  wrapped around my  neck  most likley aspergers    due to cortex  damage from my  birth   and yet the mcann supporters call me chucky mispell etc and  all kinds of other stuff   all because dont believe the mcanns   i  never  was and never have been stupid like mcann supporters have said i am           i dont  expect anyone to feel sorry for me but  gilets post  pissed me off so much that i could not   stay silent anymore

everybody in my life  love that i have my own opinion becaus ei couldnt talk clearly until i was 10 years old im also going to be   honest  i have been  in therapy  for  16  months    to deal with the severe  pain and anxiety i live with everyday  that the strong pain medications   i take   dont   cure   so all the     stuff  written about me   needs to  stop   i have no  issues from being alone   when i was 11   but  i do have  a   issue with the mcanns not being accountable for their actions in regards to their children  because i cannot have children and yet they  can  and did and abandoned them   do you     people  who  pick on  me for having a  opinion understand that pain?? no its all about kate mcanns pain   of her own making  and maddie paid the price for gerry and kates actions

 no doubt i will  be abused and made  fun of because of this post too but i dont care   i will never    apologize about how i feel about the  mcanns because if i had been   able to have     a   child like maddie i would never have left her to  fend for herself
« Last Edit: June 23, 2014, 06:24:23 AM by carlymichelle »

Offline Jean-Pierre

Re: Empathy and Support
« Reply #5 on: June 23, 2014, 06:29:56 AM »
This isn't about you, Carly. 

You chose to insert yourself into this case some seven years ago, making endless derogatory and vitriolic comments about the McCanns and then playing the "but I'm disabled" card whenever challenged. 

One may have thought that maybe your disabilities would allow you to feel some empathy for others challenges, but it seems not.

Offline carlymichelle

Re: Empathy and Support
« Reply #6 on: June 23, 2014, 06:34:56 AM »
This isn't about you, Carly. 

You chose to insert yourself into this case some seven years ago, making endless derogatory and vitriolic comments about the McCanns and then playing the "but I'm disabled" card whenever challenged. 

One may have thought that maybe your disabilities would allow you to feel some empathy for others challenges, but it seems not.

me being disabled has no baring on what i think of the mcanns i have the ability to think for myself and i do  so i have alot of compassion for many  walks of life including little maddie but i cant for gerry and  kate      did  you  read where i cannot have   children  how do you think people who cannot have children feel  when they read that the mcanns left their  children alone  and  one  vanished and people like you mcann supporters justify it    you  will never understand  me   so  you   have no right to comment
« Last Edit: June 23, 2014, 06:37:30 AM by carlymichelle »

Offline Jean-Pierre

Re: Empathy and Support
« Reply #7 on: June 23, 2014, 06:54:35 AM »
me being disabled has no baring on what i think of the mcanns i have the ability to think for myself and i do  so i have alot of compassion for many  walks of life including little maddie but i cant for gerry and  kate      did  you  read where i cannot have   children  how do you think people who cannot have children feel  when they read that the mcanns left their  children alone  and  one  vanished and people like you mcann supporters justify it    you  will never understand  me   so  you   have no right to comment

Are you trying to say that I have no right to comment on the McCann case, Carly?

Or that I have no right to respond to any of your posts?

Offline carlymichelle

Re: Empathy and Support
« Reply #8 on: June 23, 2014, 06:54:59 AM »

They use it as a pretext to attack you.

Now what did gilet say about Christian values ???

OR ARE THEY RESERVED  EXCLUSIVELY RESERVED FOR THE MCCANNS ?

Who 'found ' religion when it suited them. 8)-)))

im a  athest so christian  values have no meaning to  me 8((()*/

Offline carlymichelle

Re: Empathy and Support
« Reply #9 on: June 23, 2014, 06:57:43 AM »
Are you trying to say that I have no right to comment on the McCann case, Carly?

Or that I have no right to respond to any of your posts?

you have  every  right to post   but you  do not have the right      to bring up  someones  disabilities and say  they have no empathy   i  have plenty but not for  gerry and kate and that is my  right

Offline carlymichelle

Re: Empathy and Support
« Reply #10 on: June 23, 2014, 06:59:04 AM »

They use it as a pretext to attack you.

Now what did gilet say about Christian values ???

OR ARE THEY RESERVED  EXCLUSIVELY RESERVED FOR THE MCCANNS ?

Who 'found ' religion when it suited them. 8)-)))


As personified by, and by so many other statements...


he deserves to be miserable and feel FEAR'


VERY CHRISTIAN INDEED.

 christians are like that though very hypocritcal  thou  shall not judge is  written in the bible but christians  judge everybody including  who can marry who and have  kids

Offline Jean-Pierre

Re: Empathy and Support
« Reply #11 on: June 23, 2014, 07:12:49 AM »
you have  every  right to post   but you  do not have the right      to bring up  someones  disabilities and say  they have no empathy   i  have plenty but not for  gerry and kate and that is my  right

It was you who brought up your disabilities.  (post #4). 

And it is something you do every time you are challenged on this or other fora.

I suspect you are perfectly able to hold your own in an argument, and this would mean engaging in the usual rough and tumble of forum posting on an equal footing.  By constantly playing the "disabled" card you are demanding that you be treated as special and that the usual rules of debate on a forum somehow do not apply to you.

 

Offline carlymichelle

Re: Empathy and Support
« Reply #12 on: June 23, 2014, 07:16:58 AM »
It was you who brought up your disabilities.  (post #4). 

And it is something you do every time you are challenged on this or other fora.

I suspect you are perfectly able to hold your own in an argument, and this would mean engaging in the usual rough and tumble of forum posting on an equal footing.  By constantly playing the "disabled" card you are demanding that you be treated as special and that the usual rules of debate on a forum somehow do not apply to you.

my  disabilities are nithing to do with what i  think i just   have my own opion and refuse to be told what to think by people like you and gilet  you and  other try and control what people   think and it will never happen it is a form of bullying  cyber bullying  actully

and you supporting the mcanns and what they did  leaving the children etc makes you and other mcann supporters have no empthay for maddie you dont care about her distress
« Last Edit: June 24, 2014, 07:24:02 PM by John »

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: Empathy and Support
« Reply #13 on: June 23, 2014, 07:21:30 AM »
As an objective point of semantics, it is only truly possible to have empathy with someone in whose shoes you have travelled.

I do not have empathy with the McCanns because I have never experienced anything like what they have experienced.

But I do have plenty of sympathy, which is quite different ...

stephen25000

  • Guest
Re: Empathy and Support
« Reply #14 on: June 23, 2014, 07:30:23 AM »
As an objective point of semantics, it is only truly possible to have empathy with someone in whose shoes you have travelled.

I do not have empathy with the McCanns because I have never experienced anything like what they have experienced.

But I do have plenty of sympathy, which is quite different ...

How can you have sympathy for something they are responsible for in the first place ?