thank you Sadie, So it is crecheman.................Why so many names to these men. I don't believe it was crecheman/bundleman, so don't know where WS got that, but I do believe there is a possibility that JT saw someone else. Does that make sense? I will call him Mysteryman. Why has my post explaining things to Anna, a newish person to the case details, been taken down? Leaving incorrect information up? She is a member and needs to know the facts. Reading Annas post without this post merely obfuscates and encourages the reader to falsely believe that Crechman is Tannerman. That is not likely to be true. Jane Tanner saw Tannerman at 9.20'ish going in a different direction to Crechman and also to a different place. Three things different. Jane Tanner is no fool. ...............................................................Responding to Anna. No Anna, not Crechman Crechman is the man that SY have been informed left the Crech on Rua Direita at about 10pm IIRC . He was walking in the wrong place and direction to be Tanner man and also at the wrong time. Three things wrong. I wonder if SY have fallen for yet another Red Herring tbh. cos none of us heard any of this at the time nor until just very recently. I only wonder. Tannerman was the man that Jane Tanner saw after she passed Gerry and Jez chatting at about 9.20-9.25pm. He walked from west to est across the top of Rua Francisco Gentil Martins Smithman is the man that The Smith family saw walking doen Rua d'Escola from North to South. This was about 10pm This video shows Jane Tanners recollections. She is a very sincere woman, also intelligent, and I personally do not doubt either her integrity or her memory Cutting Edge Viseo Youtube, http://youtu.be/atfDV7imHHY VIDEO
Starting at 9.25
Especially at 11.54, then crying at 12.27. Finishes at 12.40
Jane Tanner is lucid and honest. Totally distraught at the memory and the knowledge that she might have stopped Madeleine being taken, had the penny only dropped..
So either there were two men in that immediate area, Tannerman and Crechman .... or someone has pulled a fast one on SY.
I prefer to believe the former, two men.... but I am open minded[/size]
PLease leave this post up