Witnesses claimed to have seen Robert Murat the night Maddie disappeared.

[mercury]

Proving that accusations against an innocent man are false is not boring.
1. The man SB saw that night was not RM  - because it's proven photographically that RM does not have light brown hair. 2. The man [Name removed] saw that night was not RM - she confused him with another man - proven photographically.  3. For the same reason, the man RB saw that night was not RM.  4. DP who spoke briefly with the man that night was not even sure if it was RM and therefore did not attend the confrontation.
Four down, four to go, and next is CP.  But first a sidenote - when she went to enter the apartment she was told "No, no, she's not here, she's not here"

I
Trying to implicate an innocent man is boring that's all I said

[misty]

@Misty. BW's statement that RM was wearing a yellow shirt and light coloured trousers on morning 4th is IMO incorrect  (he does say he's not sure). RM was certainly wearing those clothes on a later date, but not on the 4th. He was wearing blue tshirt and jeans from first thing in morning 4th until just after visiting RB balcony evening 4th. BW is getting the 4th and a later date mixed up IMO.

I can't find a photo of him in a yellow T-shirt, do you have one, please? He does seem to be more of a formal shirt man, judging by most of the photos.

Is it not bordering on the ridiculous to think that so many people made mistakes about one man?

[mercury]

I can't find a photo of him in a yellow T-shirt, do you have one, please? He does seem to be more of a formal shirt man, judging by most of the photos.

Is it not bordering on the ridiculous to think that so many people made mistakes about one man?

There WERE not SO MANY PEOPLE ,not even one , not a single one.

[misty]

There WERE not SO MANY PEOPLE ,not even one , not a single one

And you KNOW that because?

[mercury]

And you KNOW that because?

No dear, YOU are the one insisting that several people said Murat was there, to date you haven't proved a single one was right....leave you to it lol

[misty]

No dear, YOU are the one insisting that several people said Murat was there, to date you haven't proved a single one was right....leave you to it lol

I don't have to prove it, that's SY/PJ's job. But it only takes one piece of hard evidence to add to all the circumstantial evidence..... you'd have a hard job convincing a jury all those people were wrong.

[mercury]

I don't have to prove it, that's SY/PJ's job. But it only takes one piece of hard evidence to add to all the circumstantial evidence..... you'd have a hard job convincing a jury all those people were wrong.

Hard evidence for what?!

And what bloody circumstantial evidence. ....??

[misty]

Hard evidence for what?!

And what bloody circumstantial evidence. ....??

Night, Mercury.

[pegasus]

I can't find a photo of him in a yellow T-shirt, do you have one, please? He does seem to be more of a formal shirt man, judging by most of the photos.

Is it not bordering on the ridiculous to think that so many people made mistakes about one man?

There's a yellow shirt photo somewhere but I don't have link, and its a later date than the 4th.

All the people who claimed to have seen him there that night were victims of the same irrational brain processes. They did not know RM, not even by sight. See the McClusky statements for an example of the same psychological phenomenon - the mind retrospectively adapts memories to try to form connections where there are none

[mercury]

Night, Mercury.

You posted last night you don't suspect him and now you're sending a different message, confused, but yes night out of here

You still owe an answer to my questiin  post 261 though  maybe after breakfast????
Hmmmm important questions unanswered

[misty]

There's a yellow shirt photo somewhere but I don't have link, and its a later date than the 4th.

All the people who claimed to have seen him there that night were victims of the same irrational brain processes. They did not know RM, not even by sight. See the McClusky statements for an example of the same psychological phenomenon - the mind retrospectively adapts memories to try to form connections where there are none

 It seems far too important to certain people that anything which implicates RM in any way whatsoever needs to be discredited by phrases such  as victims of irrational brain processes. Do cadaver dogs suffer the same affliction?

[pegasus]

I don't have to prove it, that's SY/PJ's job. But it only takes one piece of hard evidence to add to all the circumstantial evidence..... you'd have a hard job convincing a jury all those people were wrong.

It would be easy as cake Misty. For example I would simply call as witnesses GM KM DP FP DW MO and JT because they were all standing right next to RM first thing on morning 4th and they will all confirm he was wearing blue tshirt and jeans exactly as he stated - and so the "changed clothes then denied it" allegation would be laughed out of court. 

[misty]

It would be easy as cake Misty. For example I would simply call as witnesses GM KM DP FP DW MO and JT because they were all standing right next to RM first thing on morning 4th and they will all confirm he was wearing blue tshirt and jeans exactly as he stated - and so the "changed clothes then denied it" allegation would be laughed out of court.

What he was wearing at 9.30 is not in dispute as there is photographic evidence of that & no-one has denied he was on the scene on 4/5.
Where is the evidence of what he was wearing later in the day, apart from a blue T-shirt in the evening which may or may not have been the same one he had on in the morning.
Do you think that, by the way he was dressed first thing, he would have been mistaken as being with the PJ?

[pegasus]

It seems far too important to certain people that anything which implicates RM in any way whatsoever needs to be discredited by phrases such  as victims of irrational brain processes. Do cadaver dogs suffer the same affliction?

It is a fact that RM was wearing a blue t-shirt when he first arrived outside the apartment on morning 4th. Photos prove it. Photos of GM and KM and several of the T7 standing right next to him in a blue tshirt. Yet still some people will still claim the "changed clothes" story is true. It's puzzling how someone could publish that story when the proof it is wrong was so easily accessible. 

[misty]

@Pegasus
Sorry if I came over as rather rude. I do respect your opinion, even if I don't always agree with it.
Night.