Witnesses claimed to have seen Robert Murat the night Maddie disappeared.

[pegasus]

The man seen by SB that night, she does not not say he was translating, she just says he was keen to help search, this was simply one of the tourists from another building helping search very soon after the disappearance.

A different man was seen by CP and [Name removed] and RB that night, none of them say he was translating, just that he was standing there, this is a different man to the man seen by SB

Milling around the apartment at various times during the panic were about 100 people, obviously this would include quite a few males with short hair and glasses.

[jassi]

Has it ever been explained why this character was singled out from the crowd as being sufficiently unusual to be even noticed.?

[pegasus]

Has it ever been explained why this character was singled out from the crowd as being sufficiently unusual to be even noticed.?

It was only after RM was incorrectly suspected, and truthfully said he wasn't there that night.

[misty]

It was only after RM was incorrectly suspected, and truthfully said he wasn't there that night.

So FP was untruthful when she said she met him while KM was still inside 5a?

[jassi]

I believe mistaken is the word 

[pegasus]

So FP was untruthful when she said she met him while KM was still inside 5a?

FP did see a man. He came up to her and introduced himself. The fact is that FP does NOT remember what name he gave. That is how poor the recollection is. And she does not remember even a single item of clothing he was wearing. It was not RM. He was not there. It was a different man.

[misty]

FP did see a man. He came up to her and introduced himself. The fact is that FP does NOT remember what name he gave. That is how poor the recollection is. And she does not remember even a single item of clothing he was wearing. It was not RM. He was not there. It was a different man.

How many people have to be mistaken for the word of a person, who made at least 17 alterations (not counting lies)
to his own statement, to be the truth? Please bear in mind RM's first recollection of the evening of the 3rd was that he was with his girlfriend.

[stephen25000]

How many people have to be mistaken for the word of a person, who made at least 17 alterations (not counting lies)
to his own statement, to be the truth? Please bear in mind RM's first recollection of the evening of the 3rd was that he was with his girlfriend.

Would you care to substantiate  your post ?

[misty]

Would you care to substantiate  your post ?

Which part in particular?

[stephen25000]

Which part in particular?

All of it.

As it stands, you are more than implying that Murat was involved in Madeleine's disappearance.

[Mr Gray]

All of it.

As it stands, you are more than implying that Murat was involved in Madeleine's disappearance.

Has it been proved that he wasn't

[Alice Purjorick]

All of it.

As it stands, you are more than implying that Murat was involved in Madeleine's disappearance.

He just had poor recall of memory and changed his statement to compensate for it  &%+((£
Nothing suspicious about that ma'am it happens to everyone all the time.

[Mr Gray]

He just had poor recall of memory and changed his statement to compensate for it  &%+((£
Nothing suspicious about that ma'am it happens to everyone all the time.

why haven't SY stated he is not involved and given us all the evidence to prove it...sounds fishier than a pair of kippers to me

[stephen25000]

He just had poor recall of memory and changed his statement to compensate for it  &%+((£
Nothing suspicious about that ma'am it happens to everyone all the time.

I wonder who you mean Alice ? &%+((£

[Alice Purjorick]

why haven't SY stated he is not involved and given us all the evidence to prove it...sounds fishier than a pair of kippers to me

Because it is nowt to do with them?