Was Madeleine McCann run over by accident and then carried off?

[jassi]

With so much apparent choice, its strange that they haven't found one yet. Perhaps they are looking in the wrong direction.

[Mr Gray]

With so much apparent choice, its strange that they haven't found one yet. Perhaps they are looking in the wrong direction.

amaral and the PJ found nothing

[jassi]

Neither have SY. Strange that considering their reputation.

[Miss Taken Identity]

Neither have SY. Strange that considering their reputation.

AND the parents 'searches' found nothing either....even more strange. but wait.. what about a 'sighting'. nah not to bother with that one.

[Brietta]

... "strange" would appear to be the 'in' word.

Would someone care to enlighten me ... is it only "strange" when applied to Madeleine McCann??

Or is "strange" applicable in ALL cases of missing children?

[Miss Taken Identity]

... "strange" would appear to be the 'in' word.

Would someone care to enlighten me ... is it only "strange" when applied to Madeleine McCann??

Or is "strange" applicable in ALL cases of missing children?

This thread is about Madeleine McCann as far as I see.  Why do you need to be enlightened? do you not understand the Davel post or the replies?

Or is it the case Davel and your 'crew' should not be challenged?

[Brietta]

This thread is about Madeleine McCann as far as I see.  Why do you need to be enlightened? do you not understand the Davel post or the replies?

Or is it the case Davel and your 'crew' should not be challenged?

Well spotted.

This thread is indeed a discussion on the possibility of Madeleine falling victim to a hit and run driver after exiting the apartment.

I do not see quite where your statement "AND the parents 'searches' found nothing either....even more strange." comes into that discussion.

Please refrain from posting suppositions about me ... you know absolutely nothing about me or what "crew" if any I may belong to.

[Angelo222]

This is the only explanation for Maddie's disappearance which works for me.   She was used to opening the front door and going out every morning, it is recorded that she would run ahead along the path bordering the apartments.   It is also known that she woke up when her parents were at the tapas.  Putting two and two together it is very easy to see what happened.

Was it Maddie who pulled up the shutter and opened the window in a vain attempt to attract her parents attention?

[Alfred R Jones]

This is the only explanation for Maddie's disappearance which works for me.   She was used to opening the front door and going out every morning, it is recorded that she would run ahead along the path bordering the apartments.   It is also known that she woke up when her parents were at the tapas.  Putting two and two together it is very easy to see what happened.

In order for this to be the case it means that Kate McCann staged an abduction almost immediately she discovered her child missing, that she put more thought into covering her own arse* than in looking for her daughter, who as far as she knew could have been wandering around moments from the Apartment.  This means that in your scenario Kate McCann is a most evil woman, and that Gerry is either evil too for supporting her in the lie, or has been duped by his wife for the last nearly 8 years.  Is this what you believe Angelo?

*  (though quite how that would work I'm not entirely sure as whether Madeleine was taken or left by her own design it happened when the McCanns were not there)

[Angelo222]

In order for this to be the case it means that Kate McCann staged an abduction almost immediately she discovered her child missing, that she put more thought into covering her own arse* than in looking for her daughter, who as far as she knew could have been wandering around moments from the Apartment.  This means that in your scenario Kate McCann is a most evil woman, and that Gerry is either evil too for supporting her in the lie, or has been duped by his wife for the last nearly 8 years.  Is this what you believe Angelo?

*  (though quite how that would work I'm not entirely sure as whether Madeleine was taken or left by her own design it happened when the McCanns were not there)

I don't see it that way at all.  Any parent given the circumstances would jump to the same conclusion that someone had abducted her.  Unfortunately or fortunately, depending on your point of view, the evidence does NOT support an abduction.

In fact, contrary to what you posted, there was no need for any lie.  Mistaken would be a more appropriate qualification.

In the final analysis, it was the guilt of having left her unattended and the possible legal consequences of having done so which concerned the tapas group more than anything else.  Thus we have the ass covering exercise in perfect parenting!

[Alfred R Jones]

I don't see it that way at all.  Any parent given the circumstances would jump to the same conclusion that someone had abducted her.  Unfortunately or fortunately, depending on your point of view, the evidence does NOT support an abduction.

When Kate McCann entered the bedroom of the children the window was open and the shutter pushed up. Are you of the opinion then that Madeleine did this?

[Alice Purjorick]

This is the only explanation for Maddie's disappearance which works for me.   She was used to opening the front door and going out every morning, it is recorded that she would run ahead along the path bordering the apartments.   It is also known that she woke up when her parents were at the tapas.  Putting two and two together it is very easy to see what happened.

Was it Maddie who pulled up the shutter and opened the window in a vain attempt to attract her parents attention?

Well it is better than the abduction theory 
Now as I recall, all The Met ever said about the abduction theory was: "There was a window of opportunity when and abduction could have taken place. If it were abduction by stranger it would be a criminal offence" or some such. I am sure a diligent Googler could find the actual quotation. It'll be on one the YouTube videos I bet.
Shame about The Met greasing Tannerman The Abductor ( I have put that in as a test)

[Angelo222]

Well it is better than the abduction theory 
Now as I recall, all The Met ever said about the abduction theory was: "There was a window of opportunity when and abduction could have taken place. If it were abduction by stranger it would be a criminal offence" or some such. I am sure a diligent Googler could find the actual quotation. It'll be on one the YouTube videos I bet.
Shame about The Met greasing Tannerman The Abductor ( I have put that in as a test)

If you recall, the group of retired senior detectives who visited Praia da Luz early on came to the same conclusion ie she got out and wandered off.  Even Amaral considered this a serious possibility.

[Alfred R Jones]

I don't see it that way at all.  Any parent given the circumstances would jump to the same conclusion that someone had abducted her.  Unfortunately or fortunately, depending on your point of view, the evidence does NOT support an abduction.

In fact, contrary to what you posted, there was no need for any lie.  Mistaken would be a more appropriate qualification.

In the final analysis, it was the guilt of having left her unattended and the possible legal consequences of having done so which concerned the tapas group more than anything else.  Thus we have the ass covering exercise in perfect parenting!

You've contradicted yourself above.  Firstly you say you don't see it the way I described it, that Kate was mistaken not lying (and hence not evil), then you say that there actions subsequently were those of ass covering, implying that they have been lying (hence evil) after all - so which is it?

[carlymichelle]

If you recall, the group of retired senior detectives who visited Praia da Luz early on came to the same conclusion ie she got out and wandered off.

i struggle to understand why  mcann supporters only support   the abduction theory?? do they know what pedos do to children?? they are basically  wishing  maddie  harm by saying she is alive  with   a pedo  the denial by them is amazing