A Thread To Discuss Alfred's Theory in detail.

[Gadfly2.1]

Well, just waded through 24 pages of that.

Three points:

1) It contained not a shred of detail and well, a good theory, needs... a bit of detail. 
2) Considering his theory, I'm amazed Alfred isn't much more interested and excited about Smithman.
3) The funniest bit for me was when Albert claimed SY agreed with him! :)  I'll take a punt in the dark: he doesn't know a single SY detective!

[sadie]

Well, just waded through 24 pages of that.

Three points:

1) It contained not a shred of detail and well, a good theory, needs... a bit of detail. 
2) Considering his theory, I'm amazed Alfred isn't much more interested and excited about Smithman.
3) The funniest bit for me was when Albert claimed SY agreed with him! :)  I'll take a punt in the dark: he doesn't know a single SY detective!

Just having a little stir, are you Gadfly?

A little sneer and a little stir

Why dont you produce something constructive?



To remind everyone:
This thread wasn't started by Alfred, but just by certain people with the express purpose of having a little sneer.  Nice.

[Gadfly2.1]

You seem a bit riled Sadie.

This is a website to discuss what happened to poor Madeleine.  Alfred takes a thick black marker pen to certain theories, so I actually gave him the benefit of reading through all of these pages dedicated to his theory. 

Like I said, I think if he believes Madeleine was abducted, he should be really interested in Smithman, shouldn't he?

And if you want constructive.  Have a quick look at the thread on Kate's silence, and as I showed, her sister-in-law and mother were incorrectly asserting she'd answered/was answering the questions put to her.  Both of them had been recently in touch with the family in Portugal. :)

P.S. Thanks for your list on this thread, it was a good read. :)

[sadie]

You seem a bit riled Sadie.

This is a website to discuss what happened to poor Madeleine.  Alfred takes a thick black marker pen to certain theories, so I actually gave him the benefit of reading through all of these pages dedicated to his theory. 

Like I said, I think if he believes Madeleine was abducted, he should be really interested in Smithman, shouldn't he?

And if you want constructive.  Have a quick look at the thread on Kate's silence, and as I showed, her sister-in-law and mother were incorrectly asserting she'd answered/was answering the questions put to her.  Both of them had been recently in touch with the family in Portugal. :)

P.S. Thanks for your list on this thread, it was a good read. :)

I just dont like sneery snide people.

The purpose of this thread was to attack Alfred and deliberately undermine him.... and you are trying to re-open it.   

To remind you, he didn't start it. 



BTW, third party statements are notorious for being wrong. 

They call it Chinese Whispers.

[Gadfly2.1]

What do you believe to be a third party statement Sadie?

[Eleanor]

Alfred's Theory.  If you please.

[Gadfly2.1]

OK, to give Alfred his due, police are duty bound to investigate this theory.  Indeed, Scotland Yard are looking at this as one of a number of scenarios.  DCI Andy Redwood has pinpointed the importance of Smithman and has conclusively ruled out -- on national TV even - Tannerman.  So, does Alfred think Smithman was carrying Madeleine on that night?

[faithlilly]

What do you believe to be a third party statement Sadie?

Anything that doesn't come directly from the couple McCann I believe.

Gerry and Kate must certainly have got all the brains in their families. What other reason could there be for ALL their relatives having such appalling levels of comprehension ?

[Eleanor]

Anything that doesn't come directly from the couple McCann I believe.

Gerry and Kate must certainly have got all the brains in their families. What other reason could there be for ALL their relatives having such appalling levels of comprehension ?

Topic, Sweetie.  How often do I have to ask?

[Alfred R Jones]

OK, to give Alfred his due, police are duty bound to investigate this theory.  Indeed, Scotland Yard are looking at this as one of a number of scenarios.  DCI Andy Redwood has pinpointed the importance of Smithman and has conclusively ruled out -- on national TV even - Tannerman.  So, does Alfred think Smithman was carrying Madeleine on that night?

As you've read the whole of this thread (allegedly) you should already know the answer I believe. :-)

[Alfred R Jones]

Well, just waded through 24 pages of that.

Three points:

1) It contained not a shred of detail and well, a good theory, needs... a bit of detail. 
2) Considering his theory, I'm amazed Alfred isn't much more interested and excited about Smithman.
3) The funniest bit for me was when Albert claimed SY agreed with him! :)  I'll take a punt in the dark: he doesn't know a single SY detective!

Who is Albert...? &%+((£

[Alice Purjorick]

Who is Albert...? &%+((£

A little lad who had a stick wi' a 'orses 'ead 'andle as I recall.

[Alfred R Jones]

A little lad who had a stick wi' a 'orses 'ead 'andle as I recall.