Journalist Sonia Poulton promises "The untold story of Madeleine McCann".

[ferryman]

You don`t consider Gamble hypocritical then?

Indeed not.

[Lyall]

So who is worse, brunt and Sky, plus the dossier girly boys, or Poulton ?

As to Gamble , judging by his twitter behaviour, he is on a par with Poulton.

You've got to have a bit of class and dignity about it. Brunt/Gamble/Summers/others are ultimately backed by the PM, because he shares their view. If you're going up against that lobby you need to be doing more than cheap stunts imo.

[ferryman]

You've got to have a bit of class and dignity about it. Brunt/Gamble/Summers/others are ultimately backed by the PM, because he shares their view. If you're going up against that lobby you need to be doing more than cheap stunts imo.

When views are backed by solid fact (in respect of all those you name, they are; Kate and Gerry are blameless for the disappearance of their daughter) where's the problem?

[Lyall]

When views are backed by solid fact (in respect of all those you name, they are; Kate and Gerry are blameless for the disappearance of their daughter) where's the problem?

The day police statements become solid fact is the day we've become a police state

As far as we the public are concerned little evidence has been seen to change the equations in the case since Week 1.

[stephen25000]

Poulton is worse, for her blatant hypocrisy IMO.

Of course you would say that.

Who started the whole ball game rolling ?

The cowards who produced the dossier and who tried to hide their identities and set off the chain of events resulting in Leyland's death.

[Alice Purjorick]

Wouldn't you if you had Pointy Poulton harassing you for an interview?

  I was thinking more in terms his mardy remains a hang over from dear old Kitten Heels chewing nails and spitting rust at him.
I could be wrong of course  &%+((£

[Alfred R Jones]

By the same token, Poulton said of Gamble

"This is a practice you have publicly applauded when it applied to a single, older woman expressing an opinion e.g. Brenda Leyland also from Leicester. And yet, apparently, it is not to your taste when it comes to those who are at the heart of a story of enormous public investment. "

So is it your stance that someone else"s perceived hypocrisy excuses Sonia's hypocrisy?

[ferryman]

The day police statements become solid fact is the day we've become a police state

As far as we the public are concerned little evidence has been seen to change the equations in the case since Week 1.

Depends which police statements you have in mind.

[Carana]

At least she is giving the matter a public airing for all on twitter to see.

What "matter"?

[Carew]

So is it your stance that someone else"s perceived hypocrisy excuses Sonia's hypocrisy?

...........and yours that someone else`s perceived hypocrisy excuses Gamble`s, the dossier warriors and Uncle Tom Mythpeoples and all`s hypocrisy?


No more from me.........

[Alfred R Jones]

...........and yours that someone else`s perceived hypocrisy excuses Gamble`s, the dossier warriors and Uncle Tom Mythpeoples and all`s hypocrisy?

My stance is very clear.  Someone who shrieks blue murder when Brenda Leyland was doorstepped by the media and then claims that doorstepping is perfectly legitimate is being hypocritical.  Surely there can be no debate on that matter?  If you have a problem with Jim Gamble being a hypocrite too then that's fine but it doesn't change the fact of Sonia's shameless hypocrisy.  i have never once expressed any view on Jim Gamble,  start a thread and perhaps we can debate them there.

[faithlilly]

And know we know things must be bad !!

Welcome back gilet 

[Alfred R Jones]

I liked Jim's withering response to ol' Sonia's twitter letter 

[Carana]

I liked Jim's withering response to ol' Sonia's twitter letter 

What did he say?

[Alfred R Jones]

What did he say?

"Thank you for your note.  It confirms you do irony well. I will let my reputation speak for me and yours for you".  Beautiful!