Documentaries & Articles for Discussion

[Mr Gray]

Redwood's thoughts are now irrelevant.

they were the thoughts of the SY team

[Brietta]

He might have believed that, but he certainly hasn't been able to prove it.

Although now retired, neither DCI Redwood nor his successor require to "prove" anything ... nor am I quite sure that is actually their remit.  I would imagine it is probably more appropriate for the courts to deal with the matter of guilt, innocence and provenance.

I believe the role of policing is to find the evidence trail and to follow it either to where it peters out or to conclusion for handing over to the prosecuting authorities.

I rather get the impression you and others have been somewhat beguiled into thinking that any second rate detective who could be considered a better author and documentary maker than he ever was at the day job only has to invent a thesis ... and job done ... case solved.

The real world does not work like that outwith the pages of Christie, Conan Doyle and Amaral.

[G-Unit]

so was amarals.....it's now up to Hall...she doesn't have to...she will certainly do her best

Who's this Hall then? You've lost me there....

[ferryman]

Although now retired, neither DCI Redwood nor his successor require to "prove" anything ... nor am I quite sure that is actually their remit.  I would imagine it is probably more appropriate for the courts to deal with the matter of guilt, innocence and provenance.

I believe the role of policing is to find the evidence trail and to follow it either to where it peters out or to conclusion for handing over to the prosecuting authorities.

I rather get the impression you and others have been somewhat beguiled into thinking that any second rate detective who could be considered a better author and documentary maker than he ever was at the day job only has to invent a thesis ... and job done ... case solved.

The real world does not work like that outwith the pages of Christie, Conan Doyle and Amaral.

I rather think Christie and Conan-Doyle are not flattered by that comparison ....

[slartibartfast]

I rather think Christie and Conan-Doyle are not flattered by that comparison ....

I rather think they are beyond caring.

[mercury]

I rather think Christie and Conan-Doyle are not flattered by that comparison ....

Talking with the dead now to bash Amaral?

 

[Brietta]

Talking with the dead now to bash Amaral?

 

                          Nope ... just giving a mention to another two authors of fiction.

[mercury]

                          Nope ... just giving a mention to another two authors of fiction.

Droll. The Portuguese judicial authorities do not share your biased views, and they have the upper hand, so that is just, well, that...their views matter, yours do not



....

[Mr Gray]

Droll. The Portuguese judicial authorities do not share your biased views, and they have the upper hand, so that is just, well, that...their views matter, yours do not



....

and neither do yours of course...and it looks like they do not see the mccanns as suspects either

[stephen25000]

                          Nope ... just giving a mention to another two authors of fiction.

Not forgetting kate mccanns of course. *&*%£

[Brietta]

I rather think Christie and Conan-Doyle are not flattered by that comparison ....

LOL should probably gone for Victorian 'Penny Dreadful' authors ... some of them claimed what they penned to be based on 'true stories' the more lurid the better.
Don't know if any of them ever came up with body fluids sloshing around in a carriage one though or wasn't there something about the pet crematorium with remains secreted inside a Labrador?  Or is that too ridiculous for words? ... oh wait a minute, seems not ...

**Snip
Pet cremator is asked: Did you burn Madeleine McCann's body
**
He said he was asked if a body could have been hidden in one of the dead animal carcasses, but said he told police that he checked everything that was burned.
**
"They asked if I had spoken with the parents of Madeleine McCann," he said. "They claimed they knew I had spoken to the parents, but it's not true.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/1563735/Pet-cremator-is-asked-Did-you-burn-Madeleine-McCanns-body.html

Lots of time spent investigating her parents apparently and their supposed involvement in secreting her remains.  What a shame while that was going on ... no-one was giving Madeleine the benefit of the doubt and going to the trouble of looking for her with the exception of her parents..

[mercury]

and neither do yours of course...and it looks like they do not see the mccanns as suspects either

Presumng to know what someone else is referring to, when one does not actually know or even ask, and does not  even attempt to engage braincells is not a sign of superior intelligence...but of arrogance and laziness..you must brush up on....several things..lol

[mercury]

Not forgetting kate mccanns of course. *&*%£

Of course! Forgot about that little litany.

[stephen25000]

Of course! Forgot about that little litany.

Definitely on a par with the great works of self adoration of our times.

[mercury]

LOL should probably gone for Victorian 'Penny Dreadful' authors ... some of them claimed what they penned to be based on 'true stories' the more lurid the better.
Don't know if any of them ever came up with body fluids sloshing around in a carriage one though or wasn't there something about the pet crematorium with remains secreted inside a Labrador?  Or is that too ridiculous for words? ... oh wait a minute, seems not ...

**Snip
Pet cremator is asked: Did you burn Madeleine McCann's body
**
He said he was asked if a body could have been hidden in one of the dead animal carcasses, but said he told police that he checked everything that was burned.
**
"They asked if I had spoken with the parents of Madeleine McCann," he said. "They claimed they knew I had spoken to the parents, but it's not true.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/1563735/Pet-cremator-is-asked-Did-you-burn-Madeleine-McCanns-body.html

Lots of time spent investigating her parents apparently and their supposed involvement in secreting her remains.  What a shame while that was going on ... no-one was giving Madeleine the benefit of the doubt and going to the trouble of looking for her with the exception of her parents..

How utterly ridiculous to state no one gave MADELEINE the benefit of the doubt, that does not even make sense, Im sure that was an unconscious SLIP of yours whch exposes one of your tactics, disgraceful....and dear, you do not KNOW what happened, therefore this FACT does not give you any right whatsoever to post yur BELIEFS as FACTS, ths breaks forum rules at the very least...now go away and thnk about this