Have most people given up on finding Madeleine alive?

[stephen25000]

The very fact that the best dogs in the world found nothing to confirm Maddie's death supports the fact that she may still be alive.

FACT ???

So where is she exactly ?

Worldwide publicity has revealed nothing as to what happened.

As far as your statement /belief is concerned,  'the best dogs in the world found nothing to confirm Maddie's death' , it 'supports the fact'  she is living on Alpha Centuari II, 4.3 Light Years away.

[Mr Gray]

FACT ???

So where is she exactly ?

Worldwide publicity has revealed nothing as to what happened.

As far as your statement /belief is concerned,  'the best dogs in the world found nothing to confirm Maddie's death' , it 'supports the fact'  she is living on Alpha Centuari II, 4.3 Light Years away.

What proof is there that maddie is no longer alive...you do not seem to understand the basic facts

[stephen25000]

What proof is there that maddie is no longer alive...you do not seem to understand the basic facts

You are very common of use of the word 'cites'.

Now 'cite' some evidence to affirm your statement.

[Mr Gray]

You are very common of use of the word 'cites'.

Now 'cite' some evidence to affirm your statement.

there is no proof either way...therefore there can be no cite....

Maddie may be alive or sadly dead...that's  a fact. Do you have a cite to prove otherwise

[stephen25000]

there is no proof either way...therefore there can be no cite....

Maddie may be alive or sadly dead...that's  a fact. Do you have a cite to prove otherwise

Therefore your statement is meaningless

'The very fact that the best dogs in the world found nothing to confirm Maddie's death supports the fact that she may still be alive.'

IT IS NO FACT.

[Mr Gray]

Therefore your statement is meaningless

'The very fact that the best dogs in the world found nothing to confirm Maddie's death supports the fact that she may still be alive.'

IT IS NO FACT.

If there is no proof she is dead then it is a fact that she may still be alive...that is very simple to understand and is a statement based on fact

[stephen25000]

If there is no proof she is dead then it is a fact that she may still be alive...that is very simple to understand and is a statement based on fact

There is absolutely no proof she is alive.

THAT IS A FACT.

[Mr Gray]

There is absolutely no proof she is alive.

THAT IS A FACT.

can you not understand basic logic...

There is no proof she is alive
There is no proof she is dead

Therefore either may be true...is that simple enough for you

[stephen25000]

can you not understand basic logic...

There is no proof she is alive
There is no proof she is dead

Therefore either may be true...is that simple enough for you

Well here's simple logic.

Don't make statements that make no sense.

and merely because the forensics were inconclusive, it does NOT MEAN THE DOGS DIDN'T ALERT TO A BODY.

Do you comprehend that ???

[Mr Gray]

Well here's simple logic.

Don't make statements that make no sense.

and merely because the forensics were inconclusive, it does NOT MEAN THE DOGS DIDN'T ALERT TO A BODY.

Do you comprehend that ???

There is no proof the dogs alerted to a body
There is no proof the dogs did not alert to a body

Therefore either may be true

[stephen25000]

There is no proof the dogs alerted to a body
There is no proof the dogs did not alert to a body

Therefore either may be true

Now you maintain that Madeleine could be alive ?

So you must have reason to think so.

So where exactly could she be ?

1. In the hands of a paedophile(s) ?

or

2. With a loving Family who are completely unaware of  the worldwide publicity for nearly 8 years, as are the people around them?

[carlymichelle]

Now you maintain that Madeleine could be alive ?

So you must have reason to think so.

So where exactly could she be ?

1. In the hands of a paedophile(s) ?

or

2. With a loving Family who are completely unaware of  the worldwide publicity for nearly 8 years, as are the people around them?

sadly  realistically if maddie was alive   number 1 would be most  likley

[Mr Gray]

Now you maintain that Madeleine could be alive ?

So you must have reason to think so.

So where exactly could she be ?

1. In the hands of a paedophile(s) ?

or

2. With a loving Family who are completely unaware of  the worldwide publicity for nearly 8 years, as are the people around them?

so you accept Maddie may still be alive...that is a fact.. as for speculation of where she may be I have no idea

[stephen25000]

so you accept Maddie may still be alive...that is a fact.. as for speculation of where she may be I have no idea

No, I don't accept Madeleine is alive.

There is not one jot of evidence to support that she is.

See  my last post for why.

[Mr Gray]

No, I don't accept Madeleine is alive.

There is not one jot of evidence to support that she is.

See  my last post for why.

You really are slow...where have I said Maddie is alive...It is a complete waste of time discussing anything with you