Looking at the dismissing of witnesses by certain sections of this forum it would seem that this case, above any other, has had more merely mistaken or downright dishonest witnesses than in any other missing persons case in history. Just off the top of my head there's Pamela Fenn, Yvonne Martin, Martin Smith and his wife, the cleaner who saw the cot in the McCann's bedroom and of course the Gaspars, although I'm sure members can come up with many more.
Is it really believable that so many witnesses got things so wrong or is there another, more rational reason why these witnesses statements don't corrsspond with the official version ?
You are allowing your imagination to run rampant.
From the fact that Martin Smith agreed (after initial refusal) to produce an e-fit, we can reasonably infer that he has long since recanted of the view that the Smiths all saw Gerry that evening (a view, incidentally, never shared by any of his children).
Yvonne Martin was dismissed by PJ Inspector Ferraria
Mr Gaspar's statement runs much truer than his wife's.
And Gerry was verified by independent witnesses as at the Tapas Restaurant at the time of the Smith sighting.