I haven't voted, mainly because of the word "believe".
Obviously, the remote possibility that she might be is the best outcome that most people would wish for, whatever one's views. Except perhaps the few who might desperately hope that that will never turn out to be the case for reasons best known to themselves and their psychiatrists.
There HAVE been cases of children being abducted, dumped, and/or subject to fake adoptions and brought up by loving families, including in the US. However, at least amongst those eventually found or who discovered their own pasts, they are often children with little to no press coverage at the time. Rare, no doubt, but there may also be others who have simply chosen not to say anything for a variety of reasons.
So, while I don't totally discount the possibility, I can't say that I believe that this is the case concerning Madeleine.
Could she be alive, but not with a loving family? Back in my innocent days, I'd have thought that anyone claiming that kids could be held captive in dungeons must have been reading too many Stephen King novels... yet such cases exist.
Could she have died the night she disappeared? Yes, of course, that's a possibility.