I don't need to have read all the files to work that one out Alice. Use your noodle.
"My side" as you called it earlier is hardly a cohesive unit with one overarching homogeneous opinion.
JT says she saw a man carrying a child.
Early doors the GNR believed her to be an unreliable witness.
I would take it on face value she saw a man as I have no basis for another opinion.
Which way the man was traveling or what he was carrying and what he looked like are up for debate as that was the point where the GNR started to wonder about witness reliability; 6/6 vision on some items and acute myopia on others.
There is nothing to suggest the Portuguese did not follow up the lead. I thought I had read somewhere the guy had contacted the Leicestershire police on his return......... dunno. It begs the question how SY located the guy and why he retained six year old clothing belonging to his child......dunno that either.
According the archiving report the Portuguese police considered:
1.abduction, for sexual exploration(sic) or other (e.g, later adoption, child trafficking, organ trafficking), without homicide;
2. abduction, followed by homicide with (or without) hiding of the corpse;
3. accidental death, with later hiding of the corpse;
4 as a remote hypothesis, the possibility of the minor leaving the apartment by her own means was explored – that would be highly unlikely physically – and after, because of an accident or by a third person intervention, she would have disappeared.
Whatever; one by incompetence and one by supersleuthing, if you will, two different police forces arrived at the same conclusion with respect to "Tannerman".
Back on yer 'eads!