My thoughts too, Eleanor. However at what time was the sighting of Tannerman is what I am now thinking.
If it was 9.40 it could still be Smithman.
On the other hand, (like you) I believed in the possibility of a bungled plan where the vehicle driver took fright and left the culprit where he was seen by JT.
He might even had got into a vehicle parked nearby. Where does that leave Crecheman(walking in the wrong direction) and Smithman sighted 40 minutes after JT sighting?
If the child was to be taken off by sea then a time for pick up had to be arranged, since none of them at the time of abduction could have been sure that it would have been done.
The abductor then had to let the recipient know that it had been accomplished. And the abductor would not have wanted to be hanging around on the beach waiting for a small boat to arrive from a larger boat. Possibly something like 20 minutes to half an hour.
Hence Smithman seeming to be in a bit of a hurry as he headed towards the beach.
This was a planned abduction, and almost certainly not by a Paedophile. Paedophiles don't go to these lengths. But someone who wanted a well nurtured child would.
This has been my opinion for at least the last seven years.
I don't think that Crecheman ever figured in this, and I don't think that Andy Redwood ever said definitively that he did.
I am now pretty sure that Scotland Yard know what happened. But they were never going to tell the likes of us.