Richard Hall's film 'When Madeleine Died?' uploaded to YouTube 19th Feb

[stephen25000]

LOL.  What took you so long?

Just keeping you in suspense alfred.

[xtina]

Anyone who can't see Madeleine's eye (complete with mark) on that iconic photograph urgently needs to go to Specsavers IMO.

IIRC Rachael Oldfield did not say she took the tennis photo of Madeleine.  She thought it was Jane Tanner who she saw taking photos of Ella and Madeleine and so assumed Jane had taken that particular photo.

Quote from Jayne Tanners Rog statement re the weather on Thursday when the last photo was taken:-

Quote
Reply    “No, not at all, no.  As I say, at this stage, this is when everybody was sat down and everybody was saying how well it had all worked.  This was the night when we were all saying that, so, no, there was nothing.  And we’d had a really, I think in some ways it had been the nicest day because the weather had been nicer, we’d all had the chance, you know, we’d taken the kids to the beach, we were all saying, you know, it was probably, it’s ironic, but it had been the best day of the holiday so far because, you know, we’d been able to do something with the kids and blah blah, so”.
End quote

You still haven't said whether you agree with R. Hall that Mrs Fenn colluded with the McCanns and fabricated some of her evidence??

look at what k mc said in her book

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yUPm35D-X3o

6;40 mins into it

what photo are you talkin about.......this is the one i mean......so many they could have used .......and they chose this one

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mFk1l_8lxq4



why give an out of date photo  '.......' to use in the 'search'!

THAT........, much 'shorter haired, 'girl' was never in PDL!

So it's no surprise  that nobody 'found' THAT 'girl'

nobody was 'looking' for 'the,' much 'longer haired', maddie, by the pool, 'photographed'...allegedly... just hours before her 'disappearance'.



as for what SY...tell you

http://www.expressandstar.com/news/uk-news/2016/02/06/met-chief-faces-quizzing-on-forces-handling-of-high-profile-child-abuse-claims/




 

[Carana]

look at what k mc said in her book

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yUPm35D-X3o

6;40 mins into it

what photo are you talkin about.......this is the one i mean......so many they could have used .......and they chose this one

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mFk1l_8lxq4



why give an out of date photo  '.......' to use in the 'search'!

THAT........, much 'shorter haired, 'girl' was never in PDL!

So it's no surprise  that nobody 'found' THAT 'girl'

nobody was 'looking' for 'the,' much 'longer haired', maddie, by the pool, 'photographed'...allegedly... just hours before her 'disappearance'.



as for what SY...tell you

http://www.expressandstar.com/news/uk-news/2016/02/06/met-chief-faces-quizzing-on-forces-handling-of-high-profile-child-abuse-claims/

Kate said she had taken that photo.

Rachel thought that Jane had taken it.

Wow. Oh my. Someone must definitely be lying. It's not as if several people could possibly be taking photos of their kids, is it?


I hope the Met have been duly informed.

[mercury]

Kate said she had taken that photo.

Rachel thought that Jane had taken it.

Wow. Oh my. Someone must definitely be lying. It's not as if several people could possibly be taking photos of their kids, is it?


I hope the Met have been duly informed.

just goes to prove the rotatory interviews can't be taken seriously, what with witnesses saying it was either Sunday Monday Tuesday or Wednesday

Fantastic witnesses....not

[pegasus]

just goes to prove the rotatory interviews can't be taken seriously, what with witnesses saying it was either Sunday Monday Tuesday or Wednesday

Fantastic witnesses....not

IMO all the T7 rogs are honest Mercury.

[xtina]

Kate said she had taken that photo.

Rachel thought that Jane had taken it.

Wow. Oh my. Someone must definitely be lying. It's not as if several people could possibly be taking photos of their kids, is it?


I hope the Met have been duly informed.

Wow. Oh my. Someone must definitely be lying.


exactly 

[ShiningInLuz]

Does anyone have more info on where Mr Hall got this Luz weather chart?

The video is rather vague on this.  It is attributed to an ex-RAF ex-pat living in Luz who kept a daily diary of the weather.

I have been trying to establish more by checking the usual suspects, so far without success.

Please note, the chart was referenced by Mr Hall wrt 'the Last Photo' and when 'the Last Photo' was taken.  That is not my interest, though I have now waded through umpteen 'Last Photo' threads in the hope the weather chart might be in it.  The nearest I have got is detailed weather charts for Faro, which I consider to be of limited value re the weather in Luz, given the distance between the two.

I have also waded through threads compiling and comparing statements made about the weather, and again, that is not what I am looking for.

I am looking for further information about this chart, the person behind it, and how the chart was built up.  Does anyone know?

[mercury]

IMO all the T7 rogs are honest Mercury.

You often post about x y z being honest witnesses, is there any you have come cross that you consider dishonest?

[pegasus]

You often post about x y z being honest witnesses, is there any you have come cross that you consider dishonest?

IMO the vast majority of statements are completely honest Mercury, and if there's any that are only almost completely honest just by leaving a few things out it's a very small number.

[ShiningInLuz]

I have added a small amount of information about "The Last Photo" on my blog, following a personal foray to check out some details.

From what I have seen so far, Mr Hall does not argue re the particular point I have covered, albeit I have an hour and a half of his 4 hour marathon to go.

However, this seems the most relevant thread for additional information on "The Last Photo".

[Carana]

Does anyone have more info on where Mr Hall got this Luz weather chart?

The video is rather vague on this.  It is attributed to an ex-RAF ex-pat living in Luz who kept a daily diary of the weather.

I have been trying to establish more by checking the usual suspects, so far without success.

Please note, the chart was referenced by Mr Hall wrt 'the Last Photo' and when 'the Last Photo' was taken.  That is not my interest, though I have now waded through umpteen 'Last Photo' threads in the hope the weather chart might be in it.  The nearest I have got is detailed weather charts for Faro, which I consider to be of limited value re the weather in Luz, given the distance between the two.

I have also waded through threads compiling and comparing statements made about the weather, and again, that is not what I am looking for.

I am looking for further information about this chart, the person behind it, and how the chart was built up.  Does anyone know?

No idea, SIL.

[Mr Gray]

anyone know why he intended to sell the video...on preorder for 20p...then decided to give it away....what happened to all those who had paid 20p already

[Miss Taken Identity]

anyone know why he intended to sell the video...on preorder for 20p...then decided to give it away....what happened to all those who had paid 20p already

I gave him 2 bob and told him to keep the change!.

lol He wanted to sell it.  I don't think his work is accurate- some of it is interesting and some of it worth discussing, I only watched the first 10 mins... oops sorry.

[blonk]

anyone know why he intended to sell the video...on preorder for 20p...then decided to give it away....what happened to all those who had paid 20p already

All this is made plain on his website, and also on the McCann-doubter forums.

People buy his videos to have, to watch again, to share with friends etc. etc. - and many comments add as a further reason for buying the Madeleine films: "So we still have copies in circulation in case the McCanns try to ban them".

Also @ ShiningInLuz    Hall publishes responses to his films and offers to correct any proven inaccuracies. He has a contact address on his website. Why not ask him your question about the weather charts direct? - he will probably answer you after his current tour ends. I have looked at available weather reports that week on the Algarve myself - and without question they all show that Saturday and Sunday (28th, 29th April 2007) were very sunny and warm, followed during Monday by a cold front which brought cooler, cloudier, windier weather - and some rain - for the rest of the week   

[Mr Gray]

All this is made plain on his website, and also on the McCann-doubter forums.

People buy his videos to have, to watch again, to share with friends etc. etc. - and many comments add as a further reason for buying the Madeleine films: "So we still have copies in circulation in case the McCanns try to ban them".

Also @ ShiningInLuz    Hall publishes responses to his films and offers to correct any proven inaccuracies. He has a contact address on his website. Why not ask him your question about the weather charts direct? - he will probably answer you after his current tour ends. I have looked at available weather reports that week on the Algarve myself - and without question they all show that Saturday and Sunday (28th, 29th April 2007) were very sunny and warm, followed during Monday by a cold front which brought cooler, cloudier, windier weather - and some rain - for the rest of the week   

The introduction....

WHEN MADELEINE DIED?
The past presence of a human corpse was detected in the McCanns’ apartment and in many other places associated with the McCanns by highly trained police sniffer dogs.



who decided the alert was to the past presence of  a human corpse.../that is a lie...perhaps he could correct that