Richard Hall's film 'When Madeleine Died?' uploaded to YouTube 19th Feb

[Carana]

Well done, you.

The previous weekend does indeed to have been lovely weather, which got worse during the course of the week UNTIL Thursday.

Taking Faro (further east) as evidence of weather the previous day further to the west doesn't appear to be the best estimation of local conditions and therefore the allegation that the "last photo" couldn't have been taken in PdL on the date cited due to weather appears to be yet another "misunderstanding".

[Carana]

Possibly neither McCann was big on photography?

Perhaps the "researchers" weren't too big on research?

[pathfinder73]

Well done, you.

Researchers made errors in this documentary and RH will be taking the flack. Thursday was sunny in the afternoon when Russ and Matt went sailing. They believe the Boyd family are in on it and god knows who else. Madeleine was at the Tapas area for high tea and the documentary thinks different. They wrongly assumed Madeleine was still at the creche above the reception and therefore couldn't be seen by tapas staff. If they release PE background pic of Madeleine taking on the 3 May 2007 this theory would be finished.

[Carana]

Researchers made errors in this documentary and RH will be taking the flack. Thursday was sunny in the afternoon when Russ and Matt went sailing. They believe the Boyd family are in on it and god knows who else. Madeleine was at the Tapas area for high tea and the documentary thinks different. They wrongly assumed Madeleine was still at the creche above the reception and therefore couldn't be seen by tapas staff. If they release PE background pic of Madeleine taking on the 3 May 2007 this theory would be finished.

I see no reason why PE should release holiday photos to the media to satisfy the curiosity of armchair detectives.

[pathfinder73]

I see no reason why PE should release holiday photos to the media to satisfy the curiosity of armchair detectives.

SY will have them and can release them not PE. They can cover the other faces in the photo.

[Eleanor]

Researchers made errors in this documentary and RH will be taking the flack. Thursday was sunny in the afternoon when Russ and Matt went sailing. They believe the Boyd family are in on it and god knows who else. Madeleine was at the Tapas area for high tea and the documentary thinks different. They wrongly assumed Madeleine was still at the creche above the reception and therefore couldn't be seen by tapas staff. If they release PE background pic of Madeleine taking on the 3 May 2007 this theory would be finished.

There were errors in Richard Hall's last film,  so not surprising really.  It's up to him to check if his researchers can't be trusted, which they obviously can't.

[Carana]

Researchers made errors in this documentary and RH will be taking the flack. Thursday was sunny in the afternoon when Russ and Matt went sailing. They believe the Boyd family are in on it and god knows who else. Madeleine was at the Tapas area for high tea and the documentary thinks different. They wrongly assumed Madeleine was still at the creche above the reception and therefore couldn't be seen by tapas staff. If they release PE background pic of Madeleine taking on the 3 May 2007 this theory would be finished.

He may well take the flak.

However, if he was relying on so-called researchers without checking for himself, then, erm, perhaps he should have done?

[Carana]

SY will have them and can release them not PE. They can cover the other faces in the photo.

No doubt. But unless there is some suspicious person in the background whom they'd like to identify, why would the Met release any such photos?

[pathfinder73]

No doubt. But unless there is some suspicious person in the background whom they'd like to identify, why would the Met release any such photos?

They probably won't release it. I think we know who is behind RH research but he's not allowed to reveal his name from past history with the McCanns. He is a liability to this investigation with his crazy outlandish theories.

[xtina]

why would maddie say that was the best day of her life [last day] ....strange thing to say ....especially when her friend Elle ...was taken out the creche to spend it on the beach

there is nothing credible...... about the abduction certainly no proof

R H shows ....there are so so many inconsistencies .....and whats more is no one has challenged him ...that what he shows is not true ...

not like the mccs is it ......

it is remarkable also .....no DNA in that apartment of maddie ....is that because the apartment had been sterilised

it shows you .......there is no proof maddie was there after the Sunday .....

[Carana]

why would maddie say that was the best day of her life [last day] ....strange thing to say ....especially when her friend Elle ...was taken out the creche to spend it on the beach

there is nothing credible...... about the abduction certainly no proof

R H shows ....there are so so many inconsistencies .....and whats more is no one has challenged him ...that what he shows is not true ...

not like the mccs is it ......

it is remarkable also .....no DNA in that apartment of maddie ....is that because the apartment had been sterilised

it shows you .......there is no proof maddie was there after the Sunday .....

First things first.

Have you noticed that there is a problem with where the children were collected from in the afternoon?

Have you noticed a problem with the weather charts?

[xtina]

Possibly neither McCann was big on photography?

well maybe not ......but k mcc ...did run back to the apartment to get her camera ,,,, to take the tennis photo

[xtina]

First things first.

Have you noticed that there is a problem with where the children were collected from in the afternoon?

Have you noticed a problem with the weather charts?

which one ...the max temp...that seems very low


what i have noticed ....there is a problem ...with everything the mccs say ....

[slartibartfast]

Possibly neither McCann was big on photography?

Perhaps there wasn't a lot of opportunity what with crèches etc.

[Carana]

which one ...the max temp...that seems very low


what i have noticed ....there is a problem ...with everything the mccs say ....

Have you checked the other graphs yet?