Richard Hall's film 'When Madeleine Died?' uploaded to YouTube 19th Feb

[xtina]

The Police would have needed a full on face photo,  the playground one she has her face to the side

I doubt it the McCann's would have given a photo of Madeleine aged two,  would they have photo's two years old on their camera?

tho photo they gave ....was took eighteen months previous .

maddie looks a lot younger

the play are photo was of maddie as she was ....what the police would have wanted ....you can see her face .....

[G-Unit]

Upon questioning, she states that the last time she saw Madeleine was at approximately 16.30 on 3rd May 2007 when she was having dinner with the other children in their part of the restaurant, as she did each day of that week.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MARIA_JOSE.htm

At 17h00 the OCEAN CLUB nursery care workers conducted MADELEINE and the other children in creche on the 1st floor of the main reception to [the area] next to the TAPAS, under awnings, where they [the children] had dinner under the supervision of the employees and, at times, with their parents. The dinner ended at 17h30
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/GERRY-MCCANN-10MAY.htm

[G-Unit]

How is the arrivals schedule related to which children were present at the Tapas high-tea on 3 May?

All those children (girls) were in the 'Mini's' age group. They were split into two, Lobsters and another group. there were only 2 boys and Madeleine left in the Lobsters on 3rd May, but the other group would have had some children to bring to high tea. Berry. Patel and Naylor were in Madeleine's group so they weren't there. We have no sheets for the other group, but there were plenty of little girls of the right age in it.

[Lace]

tho photo they gave ....was took eighteen months previous .

maddie looks a lot younger

the play are photo was of maddie as she was ....what the police would have wanted ....you can see her face .....

Well so  you think you know better than the parents about how Madeleine looked?

[jassi]

tho photo they gave ....was took eighteen months previous .

maddie looks a lot younger

the play are photo was of maddie as she was ....what the police would have wanted ....you can see her face .....

Presumably the spotted pyjama pic is the one that Russell was desperately in search of a USB port in order to download via his card-reader, so it must have been on the camera card. Was that the only pic downloaded and offered to the police, I wonder?
It was fortuitous that he had such a reader, as its not the sort of thing that everyone carries around with them.

[Alfred R Jones]

It amazes me how credulous some of sceptics seem to be, even entertaining this nonense for even a nanno second.  Respect due at least to Pathfinder who has described this as  death before the 3rd idea as madness, which it clearly is.

[faithlilly]

It amazes me how credulous some of sceptics seem to be, even entertaining this nonense for even a nanno second.  Respect due at least to Pathfinder who has described this as  death before the 3rd idea as madness, which it clearly is.

Of course it is but no more potty than a certain theory doing the round last week.

[Carana]

It's easy to go off on all sorts of tangents.

However, I still haven't found anything to substantiate the weather question (which is supposed to be a major factor in the concept that the last photo issue couldn't have been taken on 3 May).

Any updates on that?

Blonk: Where was the weather chart from? And who supplied it?

[Alfred R Jones]

Of course it is but no more potty than a certain theory doing the round last week.

what was it, and how many people bought into it?

[jassi]

Its terrible having the memory-span of a gnat.  What was that theory again ? 

[Alfred R Jones]

Its terrible having the memory-span of a gnat.  What was that theory again ? 

is that aimed at me? 

[jassi]

is that aimed at me?

No.it wasn't actually, more at myself. Sorry if it appeared otherwise.

[ShiningInLuz]

One current, one not. I presume both were available.



http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/P1/01_VOLUME_Ia_Page_30.jpg

Not unless you are a whizz on camera photo editing software.

The second one has been cropped from an original showing both Madeleine, on the left, and Ella, on the right.

The issue seems to have been that they wanted a photo showing only Madeleine, not Madeleine and some other girl, which could be confusing.

[faithlilly]

what was it, and how many people bought into it?

How soon you forget Alfie. For ridiculous, convoluted theories you have to go pretty far to beat sadie's and as to who bought into it, you appeared to albeit in a rather selective, face saving way.

[jassi]

I guess they could have printed the picture and then cut the other girl off with a pair of scissors - you know, the old fashioned way we used before digital came along