Was there actual 'evidence' Madeleine might have died in apartment 5a?

[mercury]

it is not circumstantial evidence...it isn't any kind of evidence...according to harrison and grime. I agree it is possible the dog alerted to remnant scent...but possibly the dog didn't...no one knows..that is what makes the alerts useless

Neither Grime nor Harrison use the term distinct possibility....you are embroidering the facts to make them look better

It is circumstantial evidence
And distinct is the perfect word preceding possibility as a cadaver dog is trained on cadaver scent not any substance whatsoever

After all mr grime didnt "suggest" eddie could havebeen alerting to remnant bubble bath scent e.g.

[Mr Gray]

It is circumstantial evidence
And distinct is the perfect word preceding possibility as a cadaver dog is trained on cadaver scent not any substance whatsoever

After all mr grime didnt "suggest" eddie could havebeen alerting to remnant bubble bath scent e.g.

If you want to continue to contradict Grime and Harrison then you simply show the weakness of your position and support my opinion that many sceptics simply do not understand the evidence

[mercury]

Going back to square zero, is there any evidence that the child left the apartment Thu evening? No-one saw her leaving. So what exactly is the evidence for it?

Emma Loach, documentary maker for the Mccans narrated that Jane Tanner saw Madeleine being abducted

And talking of Tannerman, who carries a four year old across the body? Unless it is a body???

[Alfred R Jones]

Emma Loach, documentary maker for the Mccans narrated that Jane Tanner saw Madeleine being abducted

And talking of Tannerman, who carries a four year old across the body? Unless it is a body???

A child you've just picked up from a bed maybe?

This man does not appear to be carrying a body....
http://www.phototour.minneapolis.mn.us/5085

[mercury]

A child you've just picked up from a bed maybe?

This man does not appear to be carrying a body....
http://www.phototour.minneapolis.mn.us/5085

Tannerman/abductor hadnt "just" picked up from a bed..he was seen well away from the apartment....that photo proves nothing except that a child can be carried like that...you may be right....mYbecergin people prefer the harder option of carrying kids....but I would say its a cumbersome way to carry a child..anyway...the question i was answering from pegasus is important....emma loach stated something which wasnt true, ergo no evidence that it happened

[Alfred R Jones]

Tannerman/abductor hadnt "just" picked up from a bed..he was seen well away from the apartment....that photo proves nothing except that a child can be carried like that...you may be right....mYbecergin people prefer the harder option of carrying kids....but I would say its a cumbersome way to carry a child..anyway...the question i was answering from pegasus is important....emma loach stated something which wasnt true, ergo no evidence that it happened

If Tannerman had picked up Madeleine from her bed, just how many seconds between doing so and being spotted by Jane Tanner do you think would have elapsed? Not many in my estimation, ergo "just" is "just" about right, in my view. 
mYbecergin? You'll have to explain that one to me, I couldn't translate it...

[faithlilly]

Emma Loach, documentary maker for the Mccans narrated that Jane Tanner saw Madeleine being abducted

And talking of Tannerman, who carries a four year old across the body? Unless it is a body???

Anyone who thinks an adult would choose to carry a child as allegedly seen by Tanner obviously has not attempted to do it.

[mercury]

If Tannerman had picked up Madeleine from her bed, just how many seconds between doing so and being spotted by Jane Tanner do you think would have elapsed? Not many in my estimation, ergo "just" is "just" about right, in my view. 
mYbecergin? You'll have to explain that one to me, I couldn't translate it...

Why have an unnecessary weight?
Ps
My cat did run across my keyboard as i hit send!!! It was meant to say maybe certain people.....

[Alfred R Jones]

Anyone who thinks an adult would choose to carry a child as allegedly seen by Tanner obviously has not attempted to do it.

What nonsense.  I have even posted a link to a photo of a man carrying a child exactly as Jane Tanner described. 

[Alfred R Jones]

Why have an unnecessary weight?
Ps
My cat did run across my keyboard as i hit send!!! It was meant to say maybe certain people.....

A child weighs the same whichever way it is carried.  There is no rule which states that a child picked up from its bed and carried away in the manner described by JT has to continue to be carried in the same manner for the entire duration of the journey. 

[misty]

Anyone who thinks an adult would choose to carry a child as allegedly seen by Tanner obviously has not attempted to do it.

How does an adult carry an injured or unconscious child into A&E?

[Alfred R Jones]

A Syrian refugee carrying a child through a snow storm.  Someone tell him he's doing it all wrong, I'm sure he'd appreciate the advice.

[mercury]

A child weighs the same whichever way it is carried.  There is no rule which states that a child picked up from its bed and carried away in the manner described by JT has to continue to be carried in the same manner for the entire duration of the journey.

Obviously a child weighs the same but the manner of carrying can reduce the stress on the carrier

To get back to the point, Tanned saw a childs feet, and bottom of their pyjamax, she did NOT see Madeleine Mccann beng abducted, so perhaps you have an answer to why emma loach and the mccanns touted the idea as a fact...and in answer to pegasus...exactly no, no one saw her being abducted or carried...as a fact

[faithlilly]

How does an adult carry an injured or unconscious child into A&E?

That is usually from a car and over a very short distance.

[mercury]

A Syrian refugee carrying a child through a snow storm.  Someone tell him he's doing it all wrong, I'm sure he'd appreciate the advice.

Hes carryng like that for a reason, no reason for your sarky snide remarks is there?