There was a proposition put forward on here that the Portuguese Court of Appeal had taken leave of its senses by allowing "too much freedom of speech" with respect to Sr Amaral.
The case of this journalist would suggest that the Portuguese are quite happy to be heavy handed over freedom of speech when it suits them.
This particular case and the case of Steel & Morris v UK demonstrates that the ECHR places much importance on freedom of speech which in the McCann case would favour the state of Portugal rather than the McCanns were it to go that far. The question,were it to go that far, is would the ECHR rule that a loosely interpreted Article 8 trumps Article 10 in this case? Who knows? I am sure someone will have a blinding flash of inspiration and tell us though.
Ah, OK.
Yes Portugal and the ECHR seem to go in favour of freedom of speech.
That's great in countries in which there is none and in which there are bloggers with horrific sentences imposed for criticism against the government.
On the other hand.... here is a couple of doctors with a missing child and it appears normal that a temporary SIO is free to forever insist on any TV show that will have him that the child died (when there is no concrete evidence) and that the parents are therefore guilty of criminal activity related to it.
I don't find that normal, particularly when he STILL doesn't even understand the forensics. And goes on with gibberings about MI5 and his pals appear on TV to point to non-missing pink blankets and whatever else.
It's just not credible, IMO. But, if that's what the PT public get fed, then all but a few will assume that the case is done and dusted.
I don't find that fair... but it seems to be the way PT justice goes.