If Maddie may still be alive...what did the dog's alert to.

[stephen25000]

Abduction, abduction and abduction.

Yet not one iota of evidence, forensic or otherwise to support it.

[slartibartfast]

Davel, if you believe you have valid alternative sources for the alert, why would you not want or share them?

[Mr Gray]

Davel, if you believe you have valid alternative sources for the alert, why would you not want or share them?

I already have done and sceptics do not accept them...I'm interested if sceptics have an explanation but obvioulsly they don't....the idea of thread is not to argue about explanations...but to see if posters such as you have one...and you don't

[ferryman]

The beckon-call of their handler (answer to the opening post).

[stephen25000]

I already have done and sceptics do not accept them...I'm interested if sceptics have an explanation but obvioulsly they don't....the idea of thread is not to argue about explanations...but to see if posters such as you have one...and you don't

No dave.

This whole thread is about casting doubt on the dogs indications.

Despite the fact they did not indicate to any other peoples belongings, other than the mccanns.

Likewise, the dogs did what they were trained to do.

Indicate.

[stephen25000]

The beckon-call of their handler (answer to the opening post).

They did what they were trained to do.

[Lace]

Abduction, abduction and abduction.

Yet not one iota of evidence, forensic or otherwise to support it.

Yet SY are following that route Stephen,    they say they may find Madeleine alive,  so they have ditched the dogs findings.

[stephen25000]

Yet SY are following that route Stephen,    they say they may find Madeleine alive,  so they have ditched the dogs findings.

Well you can believe in fantasies.

As to the dogs findings, if they are of no matter why the concern, and never forget, the lack of confirmatory evidence, does not mean it won't be found.

SY have found nothing, they are no further than the original investigation.

Meanwhile the clock is ticking down for the mccanns and the Supreme Court.

[Lace]

No blood alert on the clothes so what do you think Eddie alerted to.......Persil?

Alerted to?   he played with them,   funny they were all together like that too isn't it?

[stephen25000]

Alerted to?   he played with them,   funny they were all together like that too isn't it?

You never had a dog ?

Have you never watched dogs in action when they search ?

[Lace]

Well you can believe in fantasies.

As to the dogs findings, if they are of no matter why the concern, and never forget, the lack of confirmatory evidence, does not mean it won't be found.

SY have found nothing, they are no further than the original investigation.

Meanwhile the clock is ticking down for the mccanns and the Supreme Court.

Aren't you happy that SY said they may find Madeleine alive?   Why are you so worried they may be on to something,   you keep saying they've found nothing,  is that your hope to just prove you are right saying Madeleine is dead?

[stephen25000]

Aren't you happy that SY said they may find Madeleine alive?   Why are you so worried they may be on to something,   you keep saying they've found nothing,  is that your hope to just prove you are right saying Madeleine is dead?

The so called investigation is winding down, shortly to be shelved.

Do keep up.

[Angelo222]

we have an alert......we have a statement that maddie may still be alive from the police...so what caused the alert
In that instance youn have to accept that the alert was not caused by maddie...so it would have to be caused by something else...do you have any suggestions

First of all you have to accept that SY is correct but given they have been unable to provide any proof that she is still alive I doubt the validity never mind the veracity of their claim.

[Lace]

The so called investigation is winding down, shortly to be shelved.

Do keep up.

Why so pleased the investigation is winding down Stephen?  because they are not investigating the McCann's is it?  It may be winding down but it will remain open if they don't find Madeleine and any new information and they will investigate again.   As they do with all cases of missing children.

[Mr Gray]

First of all you have to accept that SY is correct but given they have been unable to provide any proof that she is still alive I doubt the validity never mind the veracity of their claim.

the important FACT is that SY are prepared to accept she is alive ...despite the alerts...SY MUST therefore believe there is an alternative explanation for the alerts