Sharon Osbourne is way out of line to lay into Kate and Gerry McCann as ‘insane’ for leaving Madeleine
May 23, 2016 6:23pm
WENDY TUOHYHerald Sun
Subscriber Exclusive Icon
Sharon Osbourne has controversially criticised Madeleine McCann’s parents for leaving their daughter alone.
FEW if any parents are beyond criticism for every single thing done or not done in the course of raising their children. Madeleine McCann’s parents, Kate and Gerry, absolutely included.
Taking a swipe at another person’s parenting is always risky but having a go at a family still gripped by the loss of a child, as Sharon Osbourne has, is beyond insensitive. And I’m glad she’s being taken down on social media for it.
The reality TV star all but blamed the still-grieving McCanns for the disappearance of their toddler, Madeleine, who was abducted from the family’s holiday unit in Portugal nine years ago.
Speaking on a US chat show, Osbourne said it was “insane” for the McCanns to have left their children sleeping in the apartment while they were dining with friends 50 metres away.
She was commenting on a question a mother posed in a blog forum asking is it OK to leave her sleeping child at home to go to a store “50 yards” away.
In her answer, Osbourne chose to raise the abduction of Madeleine nine days before her fourth birthday.
Other Stories
“There was a husband and wife on holiday in Portugal. They left their baby in the room sleeping, sleeping while they went to dinner in the restaurant,” she said.
“While they were in the resort their baby was taken. And it’s like, ‘Oh but we can see everything that’s going on’ and it’s insane,” Osbourne said in a taping of the show The Talk.
Actually, it was a decision any parent could have made without factoring in a completely unforeseeable and freakish crime that would not cross the minds of all but the most paranoid.
The McCanns and their friends were taking it in turns to check on the sleeping children in the sleepy holiday destination.
A child could just as easily be taken from your home by someone who climbed in the front window while you were gardening in the back as from an apartment within your line of sight.
What happened to that family is tragic and as rare and random as a lightning strike. What possible use could it be for Osbourne to criticise these people whose search for their daughter has never paused?
Apart from it being callous and hurtful to lay something that could absolutely not have been predicted at the feet of Madeleine’s still-devastated parents, it breaks the basic rule of parent-on-parent comment; never take another parent down for something you could just as easily have done yourself.
Up until not too long ago parents left sleeping babies in their prams lined up outside supermarkets while they went in to do the shopping, and while no one would do that now it was never considered a life-threatening risk when it was common.
A relative of the McCanns has said that Osbourne’s comments were ignorant and ill-informed, but to my mind they were just heartless.
This family should not have their ongoing pain hashed up in talkshow content by a woman whose main game is self-promotion.
As with so many other innocent parenting choices that end up in disaster, were most parents to be honest the McCanns’ awful tale is a case of “there but for the grace of God go I”.