Author Topic: Sharon Osbourne blasted by missing Madeleine McCann's parents  (Read 93327 times)

0 Members and 4 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline faithlilly

Re: Sharon Osbourne blasted by missing Madeleine McCann's parents
« Reply #375 on: May 25, 2016, 03:22:39 PM »
How so, Faith? Did the McCanns go out & leave hair-straighteners on or food cooking on the stove?

I'm sure you know exactly what I mean misty.
Brietta posted on 10/04/2022 “But whether or not that is the reason behind the delay I am certain that Brueckner's trial is going to take place.”

Let’s count the months, shall we?

Alfie

  • Guest
Re: Sharon Osbourne blasted by missing Madeleine McCann's parents
« Reply #376 on: May 25, 2016, 04:06:53 PM »
I notice you avoided my points that you need to show a campaign to ''publicly shame' the McCanns actually exists, before you speculate about it's possible effect on them.

Sharon Osbourne referred to their actions as an example of how 'insane' it is to leave children home alone. Her opinion is shared by many and I don't see it as an 'attack' to talk about it.

The McCanns placed themselves, their families and their children in the public eye in order to promote their story. Why should others be barred from commenting and voicing any disagreement? People comment and disagree with stories in the media all the time.

On the other hand, someone commented anonymously on the internet, which is not illegal, and their comments broke no laws. Vigilantes took the law into their own hands and placed that person in the media spotlight. A very different situation imo.
You are avoiding again.  Why do I need to prove that a campaign to publicly shame the McCanns exists, when it is already blatantly self-evident?  What's the minimum proof would you accept?  Signed memorandums on headed paper?  What difference does it make if it's a co-ordinated campaign or an ad-hoc campaign anyway?  The public shaming of the McCanns has been going on one way or another for a very long time, much, much longer than any so-called "vigilante" action against a few McCann sceptics. 

As for your point that Brenda "broke no laws", well guess what?  Neither have the McCanns.  Nor was she completely anonymous as she actually she posted her views under her own name for a time, but it seems that what you actually are saying is that if you choose to raise your head above the parapet, even if it is done to highlight the fact that your child is missing and even if you have been found guilty of no crime, then you deserve to have it blasted off repeatedly.  In other words the McCanns deserve to be repeatedly criticised again and again, even nine years after their careless actions and are just getting their comeuppance, and you don't object one bit,  nor could you care less how it affects their mental and physical health.    Am I right or wrong? 

stephen25000

  • Guest
Re: Sharon Osbourne blasted by missing Madeleine McCann's parents
« Reply #377 on: May 25, 2016, 04:11:07 PM »
You are avoiding again.  Why do I need to prove that a campaign to publicly shame the McCanns exists, when it is already blatantly self-evident?  What's the minimum proof would you accept?  Signed memorandums on headed paper?  What difference does it make if it's a co-ordinated campaign or an ad-hoc campaign anyway?  The public shaming of the McCanns has been going on one way or another for a very long time, much, much longer than any so-called "vigilante" action against a few McCann sceptics. 

As for your point that Brenda "broke no laws", well guess what?  Neither have the McCanns.  Nor was she completely anonymous as she actually she posted her views under her own name for a time, but it seems that what you actually are saying is that if you choose to raise your head above the parapet, even if it is done to highlight the fact that your child is missing and even if you have been found guilty of no crime, then you deserve to have it blasted off repeatedly.  In other words the McCanns deserve to be repeatedly criticised again and again, even nine years after their careless actions and are just getting their comeuppance, and you don't object one bit,  nor could you care less how it affects their mental and physical health.    Am I right or wrong?

They got away with charges on abandonment charges In Portugal.

Have you forgotten?

Alfie

  • Guest
Re: Sharon Osbourne blasted by missing Madeleine McCann's parents
« Reply #378 on: May 25, 2016, 04:13:34 PM »
They got away with charges on abandonment charges In Portugal.

Have you forgotten?
What are you talking about?  They were not charged, they did not run away to escape charges of neglect, end of.

stephen25000

  • Guest
Re: Sharon Osbourne blasted by missing Madeleine McCann's parents
« Reply #379 on: May 25, 2016, 04:22:28 PM »
What are you talking about?  They were not charged, they did not run away to escape charges of neglect, end of.
Q
You haven't being attention, have you Alf.

They escaped charges of abandonment as the Portuguese thought it was a British habit of leaving children the way the mccanns did.

It was admitted Portuguese people doing the same would have been arrested and the equivalent of their social services would have been involved as well.

This has been on the forum and in the news.

Look it up.

Offline Benice

Re: Sharon Osbourne blasted by missing Madeleine McCann's parents
« Reply #380 on: May 25, 2016, 04:25:23 PM »
It's possible to promote a missing child without giving the media arranged photoshoots with and without your other two children. It's possible to promote a missing child without criticising the efforts of those trying to find her. It's possible to promote a missing child without asking family and friends to express their outrage in the media when you become arguidos. It gave the impression to some that it wasn't always about the missing child.

What some people call 'lies and myths' others call facts. The 'abduction' has been promoted as a fact since May 2007, but it isn't a fact. Is it a lie or a myth?

All parents make mistakes but there's a difference between a mistake and a reckless disregard for the safety, security and happiness of your children. What some see as a mistake is seen as a deliberate decision by others, taken despite the obvious (to most intelligent people) dangers and the distress suggested by the crying incidents. Sharon Osbourne's description of it as an 'insane' decision is correct.


So the McCanns didn't do what you would have done to promote a missing child.  So what?   That is just your opinion and doesn't make what they did wrong. 

It's possible for the police to investigate a case without conducting a massive smear campaign against the people they are investigating in order to turn the public against them  - whilst at the same time informing those people that if they retaliate they face a 2 year prison sentence.    No wonder their friends and family tried to redress that disgraceful state of affairs.    Although IIRC -  as your own reaction to being the victim of horrendous lies in the press would be to have a good giggle about it with your friends and family, I wouldn't expect you to understand their point of view.

Since their arguido status was lifted - there is not a scrap of evidence that the PT police or SY are investigating the McCanns or have any intention to do so.    Quite the opposite in fact.   Therefore that only leaves the removal of Madeleine from 5a by a stranger.        Anyone who thinks this means that some kind of whitewash is being conducted by those 2 police forces is allowing their wishful thinking to get the better of them IMO.

I agree that there are people who for instance regard claims like -  'the blood splattered wall' and the 'bloody footprint' in 5a  - and  'the dogs proved someone had died in 5A  etc etc -  to be true facts and who repeat them -  along with countless other similar lies and myths.      But how anyone can even attempt to justify the spread of such downright lies and disinformation as even remotely acceptable is inexplicable to me.

The McCanns did no different to what hundreds of thousands of other people have done on holiday for decades.    That's an awful lot of parents who apparently have deliberately displayed a reckless disregard for their children's safety whilst on holiday.   AFAIK  none of them have ever been arrested for neglect or approached by Social Services.   Every year there are parents whose children also go missing or who drown in swimming pools whilst on holiday  because they were not adequately supervised.    I don't see any attempts being made to hound them for a single day - let alone 9 years. 

The notion that innocence prevails over guilt – when there is no evidence to the contrary – is what separates civilization from barbarism.    Unfortunately, there are remains of barbarism among us.    Until very recently, it headed the PJ in Portimão. I hope he was the last one.
                                               Henrique Monteiro, chief editor, Expresso, Portugal

stephen25000

  • Guest
Re: Sharon Osbourne blasted by missing Madeleine McCann's parents
« Reply #381 on: May 25, 2016, 04:34:36 PM »

So the McCanns didn't do what you would have done to promote a missing child.  So what?   That is just your opinion and doesn't make what they did wrong. 

It's possible for the police to investigate a case without conducting a massive smear campaign against the people they are investigating in order to turn the public against them  - whilst at the same time informing those people that if they retaliate they face a 2 year prison sentence.    No wonder their friends and family tried to redress that disgraceful state of affairs.    Although IIRC -  as your own reaction to being the victim of horrendous lies in the press would be to have a good giggle about it with your friends and family, I wouldn't expect you to understand their point of view.

Since their arguido status was lifted - there is not a scrap of evidence that the PT police or SY are investigating the McCanns or have any intention to do so.    Quite the opposite in fact.   Therefore that only leaves the removal of Madeleine from 5a by a stranger.        Anyone who thinks this means that some kind of whitewash is being conducted by those 2 police forces is allowing their wishful thinking to get the better of them IMO.

I agree that there are people who for instance regard claims like -  'the blood splattered wall' and the 'bloody footprint' in 5a  - and  'the dogs proved someone had died in 5A  etc etc -  to be true facts and who repeat them -  along with countless other similar lies and myths.      But how anyone can even attempt to justify the spread of such downright lies and disinformation as even remotely acceptable is inexplicable to me.

The McCanns did no different to what hundreds of thousands of other people have done on holiday for decades.    That's an awful lot of parents who apparently have deliberately displayed a reckless disregard for their children's safety whilst on holiday.   AFAIK  none of them have ever been arrested for neglect or approached by Social Services.   Every year there are parents whose children also go missing or who drown in swimming pools whilst on holiday  because they were not adequately supervised.    I don't see any attempts being made to hound them for a single day - let alone 9 years.

Spot the cliches again.

'....what hundreds of thousands...'

Well  try citing that.

Then explain why most people do have common sense, use common sense and logic. Don'the leave very young children by themselves whilst out eating and boozing.

Offline Angelo222

Re: Sharon Osbourne blasted by missing Madeleine McCann's parents
« Reply #382 on: May 25, 2016, 04:44:31 PM »
Q
You haven't being attention, have you Alf.

They escaped charges of abandonment as the Portuguese thought it was a British habit of leaving children the way the mccanns did.

It was admitted Portuguese people doing the same would have been arrested and the equivalent of their social services would have been involved as well.

This has been on the forum and in the news.

Look it up.

It was the element of intent which came into play.  The AG stated that as they didn't set out to harm her then they couldn't be prosecuted for neglect.
De troothe has the annoying habit of coming to the surface just when you least expect it!!

Je ne regrette rien!!

Offline Brietta

Re: Sharon Osbourne blasted by missing Madeleine McCann's parents
« Reply #383 on: May 25, 2016, 04:45:10 PM »

So the McCanns didn't do what you would have done to promote a missing child.  So what?   That is just your opinion and doesn't make what they did wrong. 

It's possible for the police to investigate a case without conducting a massive smear campaign against the people they are investigating in order to turn the public against them  - whilst at the same time informing those people that if they retaliate they face a 2 year prison sentence.    No wonder their friends and family tried to redress that disgraceful state of affairs.    Although IIRC -  as your own reaction to being the victim of horrendous lies in the press would be to have a good giggle about it with your friends and family, I wouldn't expect you to understand their point of view.

Since their arguido status was lifted - there is not a scrap of evidence that the PT police or SY are investigating the McCanns or have any intention to do so.    Quite the opposite in fact.   Therefore that only leaves the removal of Madeleine from 5a by a stranger.        Anyone who thinks this means that some kind of whitewash is being conducted by those 2 police forces is allowing their wishful thinking to get the better of them IMO.

I agree that there are people who for instance regard claims like -  'the blood splattered wall' and the 'bloody footprint' in 5a  - and  'the dogs proved someone had died in 5A  etc etc -  to be true facts and who repeat them -  along with countless other similar lies and myths.      But how anyone can even attempt to justify the spread of such downright lies and disinformation as even remotely acceptable is inexplicable to me.

The McCanns did no different to what hundreds of thousands of other people have done on holiday for decades.    That's an awful lot of parents who apparently have deliberately displayed a reckless disregard for their children's safety whilst on holiday.   AFAIK  none of them have ever been arrested for neglect or approached by Social Services.   Every year there are parents whose children also go missing or who drown in swimming pools whilst on holiday  because they were not adequately supervised.    I don't see any attempts being made to hound them for a single day - let alone 9 years.


At Butlin's parents and children could do their own thing without worry. This was one of the great attractions of a Butlin's style holiday. At night the Redcoats patrolled the chalets to listen for children waking up - so parents could go out in the evening and not worry about the kids.
http://www.seasidehistory.co.uk/camps.html
"All I'm going to say is that we've conducted a very serious investigation and there's no indication that Madeleine McCann's parents are connected to her disappearance. On the other hand, we have a lot of evidence pointing out that Christian killed her," Wolter told the "Friday at 9"....

Offline Benice

Re: Sharon Osbourne blasted by missing Madeleine McCann's parents
« Reply #384 on: May 25, 2016, 04:50:13 PM »
Spot the cliches again.

'....what hundreds of thousands...'

Well  try citing that.

Then explain why most people do have common sense, use common sense and logic. Don'the leave very young children by themselves whilst out eating and boozing.

Stephen,  -  companies do not offer a service to their clients unless there  is a demand for it.  The Listening Service which the McCanns mirrored has been on offer for decades.  In fact 'hundreds of thousands' is probably a conservative estimate.   The true number could well be in the millions by now - especially if you add in those parents who take baby alarms with them when they leave their children asleep and go to dinner.

As I have already explained this is not something most people would do at home, but illogical as it is  - it is something which those same people do on holiday.

The notion that innocence prevails over guilt – when there is no evidence to the contrary – is what separates civilization from barbarism.    Unfortunately, there are remains of barbarism among us.    Until very recently, it headed the PJ in Portimão. I hope he was the last one.
                                               Henrique Monteiro, chief editor, Expresso, Portugal

stephen25000

  • Guest
Re: Sharon Osbourne blasted by missing Madeleine McCann's parents
« Reply #385 on: May 25, 2016, 04:53:52 PM »
Stephen,  -  companies do not offer a service to their clients unless there  is a demand for it.  The Listening Service which the McCanns mirrored has been on offer for decades.  In fact 'hundreds of thousands' is probably a conservative estimate.   The true number could well be in the millions by now - especially if you add in those parents who take baby alarms with them when they leave their children asleep and go to dinner.

As I have already explained this is not something most people would do at home, but illogical as it is  - it is something which those same people do on holiday.

What are you on about ?

You and your fellows are forever trying to give excuses.

The mccanns were offered services by MW.

They declined.

They could have had a babysitter from one of the crèche employees.

They didn't.

Offline Angelo222

Re: Sharon Osbourne blasted by missing Madeleine McCann's parents
« Reply #386 on: May 25, 2016, 05:01:21 PM »
Topic please!!
De troothe has the annoying habit of coming to the surface just when you least expect it!!

Je ne regrette rien!!

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: Sharon Osbourne blasted by missing Madeleine McCann's parents
« Reply #387 on: May 25, 2016, 06:05:06 PM »
It was the element of intent which came into play.  The AG stated that as they didn't set out to harm her then they couldn't be prosecuted for neglect.

Intent (as a vital element of any crime) is a common strand running through both the adversarial and inquisitorial penal codes.

Offline G-Unit

Re: Sharon Osbourne blasted by missing Madeleine McCann's parents
« Reply #388 on: May 25, 2016, 06:39:32 PM »
You are avoiding again.  Why do I need to prove that a campaign to publicly shame the McCanns exists, when it is already blatantly self-evident?  What's the minimum proof would you accept?  Signed memorandums on headed paper?  What difference does it make if it's a co-ordinated campaign or an ad-hoc campaign anyway?  The public shaming of the McCanns has been going on one way or another for a very long time, much, much longer than any so-called "vigilante" action against a few McCann sceptics. 

As for your point that Brenda "broke no laws", well guess what?  Neither have the McCanns.  Nor was she completely anonymous as she actually she posted her views under her own name for a time, but it seems that what you actually are saying is that if you choose to raise your head above the parapet, even if it is done to highlight the fact that your child is missing and even if you have been found guilty of no crime, then you deserve to have it blasted off repeatedly.  In other words the McCanns deserve to be repeatedly criticised again and again, even nine years after their careless actions and are just getting their comeuppance, and you don't object one bit,  nor could you care less how it affects their mental and physical health.    Am I right or wrong?

If you make assertions it's up to you to provide verification. Saying something is 'blatantly self-evident' makes it simply your opinion, as is your rant about what I think. I've stated my position and have no intention of spending time denying your unfounded accusations. Have you forgotten completely the title of the thread, by the way?

Sharon Osbourne gave her opinion which wasn't an unusual one. The fury of the McCanns and their supporters is remarkable; Kate McCann admitted it was a mistake (sort of);

I'm sure people will learn from our mistake, if you want to call it that.
http://www.mccannfiles.com/id16.html

A mistake is forgetting to turn pan handles away from small hands, or to shut a stairgate, so I don't class their actions as a mistake. Leaving children alone in an unsecured apartment isn't a mistake. For it to be a mistake they would have had to forget to lock the window, the front door and the patio doors. They would have had to have failed to notice how dangerous the balcony was (even though there was a warning on the patio doors about unsupervised children) and that unsupervised children could get out there through an unlocked door. That's not even mentioning knives, hot water, falls; all the things parents guard their children against all the time. It wasn't one mistake it was many. Too many to comprehend in my opinion.

Read and abide by the forum rules.
Result = happy posting.
Ignore and break the rules
Result = edits, deletions and unhappiness
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?board=2.0

Alfie

  • Guest
Re: Sharon Osbourne blasted by missing Madeleine McCann's parents
« Reply #389 on: May 25, 2016, 07:04:17 PM »
If you make assertions it's up to you to provide verification. Saying something is 'blatantly self-evident' makes it simply your opinion, as is your rant about what I think. I've stated my position and have no intention of spending time denying your unfounded accusations. Have you forgotten completely the title of the thread, by the way?

Sharon Osbourne gave her opinion which wasn't an unusual one. The fury of the McCanns and their supporters is remarkable; Kate McCann admitted it was a mistake (sort of);

I'm sure people will learn from our mistake, if you want to call it that.
http://www.mccannfiles.com/id16.html

A mistake is forgetting to turn pan handles away from small hands, or to shut a stairgate, so I don't class their actions as a mistake. Leaving children alone in an unsecured apartment isn't a mistake. For it to be a mistake they would have had to forget to lock the window, the front door and the patio doors. They would have had to have failed to notice how dangerous the balcony was (even though there was a warning on the patio doors about unsupervised children) and that unsupervised children could get out there through an unlocked door. That's not even mentioning knives, hot water, falls; all the things parents guard their children against all the time. It wasn't one mistake it was many. Too many to comprehend in my opinion.
Thanks for the lecture, I'm sure we all needed to read those sentiments for the umpteen millionth time.  How many more times though?  That is my point.  Will it ever end or do those "committed sceptics" who make it their business to campaign against the McCanns (either as an organised group or on an ad-hoc basis, with or without celebrity endorsement) intend to repeat these well-worn mantras to the very end of time or until they have brow-beaten the McCanns into submission?   Just askin' like...