Author Topic: The Supreme Court in Portugal will shortly decide the McCann v Amaral damages case.  (Read 44684 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline G-Unit

I also think the Mccann's reputations had gone before the book was published.

Their unimpressive child care arrangements, their courting of the media, their grand tour of Europe, their apparent lack of emotion all went against them.

By September 2007 when they were made arguidos not many people were surprised in my opinion.

The Portuguese investigation did the most damage.

Amaral's book [by the disgraced, sacked, bumbling, drunken, shabby ex detective] had little effect compared to the official investigation.

However. If someone presents a well researched, well documented case showing a surge in detrimental comments and articles following the release of the book and documentary which proves me wrong I am prepared to change my opinion. Reiteration of opinions won't do it.
Read and abide by the forum rules.
Result = happy posting.
Ignore and break the rules
Result = edits, deletions and unhappiness
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?board=2.0

Alfie

  • Guest
I also think the Mccann's reputations had gone before the book was published.

Their unimpressive child care arrangements, their courting of the media, their grand tour of Europe, their apparent lack of emotion all went against them.

By September 2007 when they were made arguidos not many people were surprised in my opinion.

The Portuguese investigation did the most damage.

Amaral's book [by the disgraced, sacked, bumbling, drunken, shabby ex detective] had little effect compared to the official investigation.

However. If someone presents a well researched, well documented case showing a surge in detrimental comments and articles following the release of the book and documentary which proves me wrong I am prepared to change my opinion. Reiteration of opinions won't do it.
DO you seriously doubt that the book and video contributed to a surge in detrimental comments and articles?  I have already posted links to dozens of them, will they not do?

Offline Alice Purjorick

Not everyone is as good at detecting bullshit when one sees it as Misty and I, some people will believe any old crap they read, some people WANT to believe any old crap they read.  If only half the world believed it, that's still a lot of harm!
.
Indeed.
If only half the world believed it that would presuppose more than half the world were aware of it.
The world population is ca 7.5 billion........................ &%+((£
Mes dames et messieurs faites vos jeux.
"Navigating the difference between weird but normal grief and truly suspicious behaviour is the key for any detective worth his salt.". ….Sarah Bailey

Offline G-Unit

In case anyone had forgotten the publicity generated by Amaral's book - was it not published to coincide with the McCanns being cleared as arguidos and the case archived also?  So whilst the archiving report clearly stated a lack of evidence, at the same time the ex-cop is promoting a book which claims to be full of it.  But, of course, no harm done, eh?

http://www.mccannfiles.com/id131.html

http://www.mccannfiles.com/id164.html

http://www.mccannfiles.com/id164.html

http://www.mccannfiles.com/id241.html

http://www.mccannfiles.com/id180.html

I have read a selection of the links. A lot are from Portuguese newspapers. The reports from UK newspapers didn't report it favourably at all. British people were told that the 'sacked' police officer was writing a disgraceful book attacking poor distraught Kate and Gerry who were going to sue him immediately it was released.

Only those who already had doubts were likely to be interested in what he had to say therefore. Most people would either be disinterested or indignant on the McCann's behalf.
Read and abide by the forum rules.
Result = happy posting.
Ignore and break the rules
Result = edits, deletions and unhappiness
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?board=2.0

Offline ShiningInLuz


On occasion I too have trawled those Portuguese media reports which are still available and with the help of Google translate (although sometimes I am left scratching my head in bewilderment) have managed to get a flavour of the times.
In my opinion many of the outrages had to have their genesis in calculated leaks direct from source within the investigation.

You have said, "It is clear that the scandalous accusations were getting through to the McCanns, given the number of rebuttals stating they were entirely untrue."

That raises the question for me of why it was necessary for the McCanns to do this?  What was it about the Concept of Judicial Secrecy that allowed such wicked  misinformation to enter the public domain  without some effort on the part of the authorities to stem the flow?

As far as the publication of Amaral's book is concerned ... I find it exceedingly odd that the people who contributed to its best selling status were unconcerned with a verdade da questão as outlined by their own judiciary.
Inexplicedly preferring instead a penny dreadful authored by the man who, in the real world, really should have had a lot of questions to answer about aspects of his conduct of the inquiry into Madeleine's disappearance.
Misinformation entered the press in the UK as well as Portugal, and it didn't all come from the PJ.

Note, I am not trying to absolve the PJ, because there were too many allegations that show some understanding of the internal workings of the enquiry, even when the end result was manifestly wrong.

The PJ couldn't silence the media - the constitution does not prevent that.  They might have tried to find they source of the leaks and discipline them, but that does not appear to have happened.

Essentially, the battle lines were drawn very early on when directly or indirectly the T9 involved the media, having had clear instructions not to.  Then there was the misinformation about the jemmied shutter.  However that originated, it was not from the PJ.

I don't wish to indulge in a blow-by-blow account of this exchange.  Life is too short.  The point is the McCanns had been trashed before the Amaral book came out, and from what little I know the only Portuguese media they tried to sue was Tal e Qal (?), when there seemed to be multiple serial offenders.

It's interesting that the McCann counterstrike was against UK media in UK courts, ditto Murat et al.  I don't know what press Murat got in Portugal.  I cannot imagine it was pleasant.

The bottom line that the McCanns were persona non grata in Portugal well before Amaral's book, as the appeal judge made clear.
What's up, old man?

Alfie

  • Guest
I have read a selection of the links. A lot are from Portuguese newspapers. The reports from UK newspapers didn't report it favourably at all. British people were told that the 'sacked' police officer was writing a disgraceful book attacking poor distraught Kate and Gerry who were going to sue him immediately it was released.

Only those who already had doubts were likely to be interested in what he had to say therefore. Most people would either be disinterested or indignant on the McCann's behalf.
Oh really?  And there was me being given to believe by some "sceptics" that "most" people didn't believe a word the McCanns say and proof of this can be found in the comments pages under each article.  Guess it depends on your point of view and what point you are trying to win at the time. 

Alfie

  • Guest
Question:  is it reputation-enhancing or reputation ruining to have an article published on the front page of a paper, all about a book written by an ex-cop claiming that you have hidden your child's body?  What if the article mentions the fact that the author was sacked and disgraced, does that completely wipe out any damage caused by the lurid headlines and article in the first place? 

"True Lies" of Maddie's Parents - Sun Headline.

Offline G-Unit

Oh really?  And there was me being given to believe by some "sceptics" that "most" people didn't believe a word the McCanns say and proof of this can be found in the comments pages under each article.  Guess it depends on your point of view and what point you are trying to win at the time.

I'm not responsible for what others say. I don't think huge numbers of people care or ever did after a few weeks. 

I do know that comments weren't allowed for a certain period of time by most UK newspapers, but now they are and those I have read are mostly not supportive of the McCanns.
Read and abide by the forum rules.
Result = happy posting.
Ignore and break the rules
Result = edits, deletions and unhappiness
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?board=2.0

Offline ShiningInLuz

Question:  is it reputation-enhancing or reputation ruining to have an article published on the front page of a paper, all about a book written by an ex-cop claiming that you have hidden your child's body?  What if the article mentions the fact that the author was sacked and disgraced, does that completely wipe out any damage caused by the lurid headlines and article in the first place? 

"True Lies" of Maddie's Parents - Sun Headline.
If you have the article in full, or a link to it, please post it and I'll be happy to answer your question.

The manner in which you have posted immediately raises some queries.  'True Lies'?  Could the Sun not translate 'A Verdade da Mentira'?

The author was sacked?  When he had resigned? 

Disgraced?  I'd need to see the article to know what The Sun is rabbiting on about there.
What's up, old man?

Offline misty

The appeal will have absolutely no effect on the ongoing enquiry, just like the preceding rulings and do you really think anything printed in a British tabloid could have any effect on an appeal that will be judged on a point of Portuguese law?

As far as Portuguese law is concerned, it doesn't seem to know which side of the fence is the correct side to be. There are, however, a few ways in which British tabloid reports could hypothetically influence the appeal.

Alfie

  • Guest
If you have the article in full, or a link to it, please post it and I'll be happy to answer your question.

The manner in which you have posted immediately raises some queries.  'True Lies'?  Could the Sun not translate 'A Verdade da Mentira'?

The author was sacked?  When he had resigned? 

Disgraced?  I'd need to see the article to know what The Sun is rabbiting on about there.
My question was hypothetical (yes I know, you don't like those).  The headline was real, available on one of the links I posted earlier.  The question I posed however doesn't really need much in depth study to answer, I don't think.

Offline G-Unit

As far as Portuguese law is concerned, it doesn't seem to know which side of the fence is the correct side to be. There are, however, a few ways in which British tabloid reports could hypothetically influence the appeal.

You think the Supreme Court judges would be influenced by advice from the UK media on how to interpret Portuguese law? I think you are utterly and completely mistaken.
Read and abide by the forum rules.
Result = happy posting.
Ignore and break the rules
Result = edits, deletions and unhappiness
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?board=2.0

Offline misty

You think the Supreme Court judges would be influenced by advice from the UK media on how to interpret Portuguese law? I think you are utterly and completely mistaken.

No, I don't. But, hypothetically, I do think they'd be influenced if stories were published saying judges in the lower/appeal court had been leaned on.

Offline G-Unit

No, I don't. But, hypothetically, I do think they'd be influenced if stories were published saying judges in the lower/appeal court had been leaned on.

Are you accusing someone of something? Unless you can back it up I think you should stop now.

All I have seen is a report that the McCann's lawyer objected to one of the judges [unsuccessfully].
http://portugalresident.com/appeal-court-judges-reject-mccanns-%E2%80%98libel-win%E2%80%99
Read and abide by the forum rules.
Result = happy posting.
Ignore and break the rules
Result = edits, deletions and unhappiness
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?board=2.0

Offline mercury

There was a pr company that got an award for turning around the negative uk media stories on the mccanns in sept 07

Proof that the uk had negative media stories a year before the book tht required the services and payment of this co
Cant find the link now but its around