Has the other reason ever been covered in the papers? What was it in your opinion (IYO)?
No, i dont deal with the (news)papers
Possible different reasons for the window being open. I had a list of about 7 of them, which took me thought to assemble. but that was about 3 years ago. I will have a go
1) As a possible emergency escape route
2) To pass any drugs for sleeping thru the window
3) To give verbal encouragement to the nervous accompolis lifting Madeleine inside, who I thought likely to be a woman who Madeleine knew and trusted ... i.e. cleaner, nanny, icecream vendor etc.
4) To give the instant impression that Madeloeine had wanderd off on her own violition, so giving the abductor a start before the police were called
5) To take the polices' eye off the fact that an insider in OC was involved who got hold of a key.
6) I think it likely that someone was watching and directing operations from one of the upper balconies right opposite (in block 6). I think it quite possible that he was using a torch, or even a lighter, to signal to the person on the outside of Madeleines window when someone was coming. That person was then able to alert the lifter in the apartment, via the open window.
7) Also the watcher could alert someone outside as Gerry left, walking down the steps.
Quickly in with a key, drug Madeleine, lift her, pass her over from the lifter to the main abductor and off. Entrance and exit through the dark, hidden front door. The lifter off back to the ?staff quarters and the abductor probably to near 5A car park entrance, waiting to be picked up in a matter of seconds. With an unexpected delay he decided to walk to Jane Tanner corner
The watcher having alerted the abductors that Gerry had left, probably then immediately went thru block 6, out thru the back gate to the getaway vehicle adjacent, parked on the little car park opposite the Tapas reception.
As soon as he had alerted to go in to 5A after Gerry left, the Watcher /getaway driver was then supposed to pull out of the little parking lot, drive up Rua Francisco G.M ... drive round the corner and pick the abductor up with Madeleine ... The whole abduction, lifting to pick up by the getaway driver, could probably have been achieved in less than 3 minutes
However, as he pulled away he saw Gerry and Jez talking ... and then Jane witnessing the abductor carrying Madeleine.
He scarpered, leaving Tannerman in the lurch
Only my thoughts, but there are facts that support them
a) Fag ends were found on the balcony afterwards. Great views in most directions from that balcony and shadow to slink back into if anyone came.
b) When Jane saw Tannerman he was carrying Madeleine with her head on his left arm. Had he lifted Madeleine, her head would have been on his right arm. Seems someone had passed her to him
Also,
c) This would also explain why Gerry thought that he had crossed the road to chat with Jez
Maybe he did and they chatted in the middle of the road, but seeing a vehicle [unbeknown to them the getaway vehicle] beginning to come out of the little car park opposite the tapas reception, they moved back into the kerb [by the alleyway]. The driver dithered upon seeing them .... and then when Jane witnessed the abductor carrying madeleine he shot off in the opposite direction
d) And because of the the beam of the headlights of the getaway vehicle, Jane was able to pick up the colour of Madeleines PJ's.
Cant think of any more possible reasons at present. Maybe you can?
AIMHO a possibility. Everything fits