Kate McCann: I believe kidnapper drugged my twins night Madeleine was taken.

[ferryman]

And lo!

My sin-bin points are promptly upped to 50%

I wonder why?

[Mr Gray]

Why would I do that?
I have the answer to my question.........in part. Which tells me what I wanted to know.

Didn't you spot the one error

[ShiningInLuz]

TO REPEAT Anyone using a post by a fellow member to publish or reveal personal details is going to get warning points.

[John]

TO REPEAT Anyone using a post by a fellow member to publish or reveal personal details is going to get warning points.

Members are well aware of the rules by now.  If a member wishes to remain anonymous then that is their right and any attempts to undermine this will attract sanctions as per forum rules.  That said however, I am greatly in favour of members posting in their own name since this adds to their credibility and shows willingness to stand over their comments come what may.

[Lace]

What details would that be ?

Let's have  a CITED source from SY, proving an abduction.

An opinion of course, doesn't count.

Good grief isn't it enough that Redwood said he believed Madeleine was taken by a stranger?

[jassi]

Good grief isn't it enough that Redwood said he believed Madeleine was taken by a stranger?

Just as long as it's not passed off as being the gospel truth.

[stephen25000]

Good grief isn't it enough that Redwood said he believed Madeleine was taken by a stranger?

........and what else did Redwood say as regards, this may not follow all our thinking on this case ?

Besides, when did Redwood's belief, become a fact ?

[Mr Gray]

Members are well aware of the rules by now.  If a member wishes to remain anonymous then that is their right and any attempts to undermine this will attract sanctions as per forum rules.  That said however, I am greatly in favour of members posting in their own name since this adds to their credibility and shows willingness to stand over their comments come what may.

I think to post in your own name could be quite dangerous and also result in even more personal abuse than currently experienced .
Guidelines for safety on line advise not to reveal true identities

[John]

Good grief isn't it enough that Redwood said he believed Madeleine was taken by a stranger?

I think Redwood should have added "if she was taken" to that assertion.

[faithlilly]

I think Redwood should have added "if she was taken" to that assertion.

I think if you listen to Redwood's comment in its proper context there was no need for him to.

[Alfie]

I think if you listen to Redwood's comment in its proper context there was no need for him to.

Every indication we ever had from Redwood was that the Met are treating the disappearance as stranger abduction and nothing whatsoever to suggest they are treating it as anything else.  I sincerely suggest you try and come to terms with this sometime soon as otherwise you face enormous disappointment which you may struggle to accept and which may cause you some distress.

[faithlilly]

Every indication we ever had from Redwood was that the Met are treating the disappearance as stranger abduction and nothing whatsoever to suggest they are treating it as anything else.  I sincerely suggest you try and come to terms with this sometime soon as otherwise you face enormous disappointment which you may struggle to accept and cause you some distress.

We shall see. 

[Alfie]

We shall see. 

We certainly shall

[Robittybob1]

Just as long as it's not passed off as being the gospel truth.

What is the truth?

[G-Unit]

Good grief isn't it enough that Redwood said he believed Madeleine was taken by a stranger?

If that is what he actually said, of course, which he didn't. He actually said 'Yes, I mean, you know, we have conducted a forensic analysis of the timeline, and there is clearly opportunity there - for Madeleine McCann to have been removed from that apartment alive - and it is our belief, as experienced investigators - on the evidence, that, um that you know, that that, that is as a criminal act - and that has been, you know, undertaken by by a stranger,
http://www.gerrymccannsblogs.co.uk/press/60april12/ITV1_27_04_2012.htm

He says there was opportunity within the timeline for Madeleine McCann to have been taken from the apartment alive. He doesn't say it happened, he says it could have happened.

He believes that if it did happen it was carried out as a criminal act by a stranger.