One enduring myth.

[Erngath]

It's every tiny aspect of their lives which is criticized, not only their behaviour during the week of Madeleine's abduction, but every aspect of their behaviour and family life both before and after that week.
Every decision, every choice, every element dissected and judged.

Must be wonderful to be so perfect.

[Mr Gray]

Ha ha ha! 

I didn't quote p29.

The quote was from p30.

Copyright infringement?  After paraphrasing?  After a request from a supporter to cite given said supporter does not appear to have a copy of the book?

It would appear some of the supporters are in total disarray.  Not all.  Some have chosen to keep their black powder dry.  An entirely wise choice.

I didnt mention a page.....you made a direct quote from the book ...that is a breach of copyright...supporters in disarray?....you might be under the misapprehension that supporters are part of some sort  of organised team...a rather silly notion.....We are all independent individuals...that must come as something of a shock to you

[ShiningInLuz]

mccann bashing from someone who claimed to be " impartial and on the fence"

Bashing the McCanns is perfectly in order when they deserve to be bashed.

Bashing Amaral is perfectly in order when he deserves to be bashed.

Bashing (please fit your own victim here) is perfectly in order when he/she/it/they deserve to be bashed.

If 2 doctors with a newborn with colic found it tough, guess what they deserve.

[Alfie]

Ha ha ha! 

I didn't quote p29.

The quote was from p30.

Copyright infringement?  After paraphrasing?  After a request from a supporter to cite given said supporter does not appear to have a copy of the book?

It would appear some of the supporters are in total disarray.  Not all.  Some have chosen to keep their black powder dry.  An entirely wise choice.

goading.  Are we all to speak with one voice?  In that case I suggest you nominate a spokesperson and get the rest of us to shut up.  Would that suit you better?

[Robittybob1]

I didnt mention a page.....you made a direct quote from the book ...that is a breach of copyright...supporters in disarray?....you might be under the misapprehension that supporters are part of some sort  of organised team...a rather silly notion.....We are all independent individuals...that must come as something of a shock to you

There is no clause in the copyright section that forbids quoting sections of her book.

[Mr Gray]

Bashing the McCanns is perfectly in order when they deserve to be bashed.

Bashing Amaral is perfectly in order when he deserves to be bashed.

Bashing (please fit your own victim here) is perfectly in order when he/she/it/they deserve to be bashed.

If 2 doctors with a newborn with colic found it tough, guess what they deserve.

so the mccanns deserve to be bashed because they found it difficult to cope with a baby suffering from severe colic....and no doubt you think Maddie deserves to be referred to as a possible pain in the a**e....and the McCanns were very wise to give you a very wide berth when you attempted to contact them to offer your "help"

perhaps your rejection has fuelled your ill feeling

[Mr Gray]

There is no clause in the copyright section that forbids quoting sections of her book.

which copyright section

[Alice Purjorick]

A lead injection will cure it.

Chuck us an M16 with two clips taped together...... 

[Alfie]

Having re-read the first few pages of the chapter that SIL is desperately using as evidence of god knows what I am struck by just how much love and tenderness there is in Kate's words, it's kind of heartbreaking actually.

[ShiningInLuz]

I didnt mention a page.....you made a direct quote from the book ...that is a breach of copyright...supporters in disarray?....you might be under the misapprehension that supporters are part of some sort  of organised team...a rather silly notion.....We are all independent individuals...that must come as something of a shock to you

Nope, you had a quote with a page number in it, to which you replied breach of copyright.

"Still failing to see the relevance of page 29 to this thread, apart from being yet another excuse for McCann bashing."

Reply

"it is of no relevance at all and purely an excuse for mccann bashing.....and of course a breach of copyright"

Page 29.  Alleged breach of copyright.  After all the other Internet gubbins about the serious conditions the McCanns seemingly overlooked.

[Mr Gray]

Nope, you had a quote with a page number in it, to which you replied breach of copyright.

"Still failing to see the relevance of page 29 to this thread, apart from being yet another excuse for McCann bashing."

Reply

"it is of no relevance at all and purely an excuse for mccann bashing.....and of course a breach of copyright"

Page 29.  Alleged breach of copyright.  After all the other Internet gubbins about the serious conditions the McCanns seemingly overlooked.

your quote of page 30 is a breach of copyright...you are obviously not aware that John has been warned re breach of copyright of the book....keep up the good work

[ShiningInLuz]

goading.  Are we all to speak with one voice?  In that case I suggest you nominate a spokesperson and get the rest of us to shut up.  Would that suit you better?

Report the post.

I do not moderate any post that is by me and has been reported.

There are other moderators for that.

[Robittybob1]

Chuck us an M16 with two clips taped together...... 

That might be the Portuguese way of dealing with a problem, but it seems slightly like overkill.

[ShiningInLuz]

so the mccanns deserve to be bashed because they found it difficult to cope with a baby suffering from severe colic....and no doubt you think Maddie deserves to be referred to as a possible pain in the a**e....and the McCanns were very wise to give you a very wide berth when you attempted to contact them to offer your "help"

perhaps your rejection has fuelled your ill feeling

The McCanns did not get cleared.  Portuguese Supreme Court.

I did not get rejected.  SIL.

I suppose the SC pronouncement is a tad more important than mine.  Such is life.

[Erngath]

Having re-read the first few pages of the chapter that SIL is desperately using as evidence of god knows what I am struck by just how much love and tenderness there is in Kate's words, it's kind of heartbreaking actually.

I am re-reading as well and yes there are so many tender memories there.