One enduring myth.

[Mr Gray]

Amaral cannot prove maddie died in the apartment so he went on tv and told a lie

[Robittybob1]

it is not my fault that you are unaware of things that are simply common Knowledge

But it appears that common knowledge needs to be cited as well.  This will make it hard for the ants to make any claims.  I like it.

Amaral cannot prove maddie died in the apartment so he went on tv and told a lie

Where's your cite?  I suppose we can claim freedom of expression, which appears more important than a good name in Portuguese Law. Cite for this is the SC judgement.

[Mr Gray]

But it appears that common knowledge needs to be cited as well.  This will make it hard for the ants to make any claims.  I like it.
Where's your cite?

perhaps it isnt common knowledge...it seems some of those pontificating about the case simply are not aware of the true facts in this case. ....sil has deleted some  of her own posts which shows she was not aware of things amaral has said...sil thought amaral was proposing a thesis whereas he was stating things as facts

[Robittybob1]

perhaps it isnt common knowledge...it seems some of those pontificating about the case simply are not aware of the true facts in this case. ....sil has deleted some  of her own posts which shows she was not aware of things amaral has said...sil thought amaral was proposing a thesis whereas he was stating things as facts

Facts that were yet to be proved, so were they facts or was it a thesis?  It certainly made the book fly off the shelves.
He appears to be a marketing genius.  Did or got all the things done in the right order too.  Resigned not just reassigned. Got his friend Tavares to repeat his claims in a document within the file.  Then got the case archived and then got the files released (something that does not normally happen).
Once all those were in place he was able to release his book which had already been given promotional priority along with the Newspaper.

[Mr Gray]

Facts that yet to be proved, so were they facts or was it a thesis.  It certainly made the book fly off the shelves.

opinion presented as fact...in fact it was worse than that ...a misrepresentation of the facts....but the SC has allowed amaral to get away with it

[ShiningInLuz]

Gonçalo Amaral
Former Polícia Judiciária coordinator

00.33 - My name is Gonçalo Amaral. I’ve been an investigator with the Polícia Judiciária for 27 years. I coordinated the investigation into the disappearance of Madeleine McCann, on the 3rd of May 2007.

00.48 - During the following 50 minutes, I will prove that the child was not abducted, and that she died in the holiday apartment in Praia da Luz.

00.58 - Discover the whole truth about what happened that day – a death that many people want to cover up.

VC Filmes presents

Maddie The Truth of the Lie


http://www.gerrymccannsblogs.co.uk/AMARAL_DOC_13_04_09.htm#doc


Could you reinstate my posts

Finally, a cite.  I cannot hear the video clearly enough to verify the Portuguese, therefore I am assuming someone with better hearing has checked this.

As to your deleted posts, these have disappeared forever.  AFAIK, they cannot be re-instated by anyone.

Perhaps in future, when you are repeatedly asked for a cite, you will provide it, to avoid such deletions.

[Mr Gray]

Finally, a cite.  I cannot hear the video clearly enough to verify the Portuguese, therefore I am assuming someone with better hearing has checked this.

As to your deleted posts, these have disappeared forever.  AFAIK, they cannot be re-instated by anyone.

Perhaps in future, when you are repeatedly asked for a cite, you will provide it, to avoid such deletions.

what I have stated is common knowledge amongst those who have followed the case...why have you deleted your own posts which show you were simply not aware of the basic facts in this case

[Robittybob1]

opinion presented as fact...in fact it was worse than that ...a misrepresentation of the facts....but the SC has allowed amaral to get away with it

Because of Freedom of Speech. 

[Mr Gray]

Finally, a cite.  I cannot hear the video clearly enough to verify the Portuguese, therefore I am assuming someone with better hearing has checked this.

As to your deleted posts, these have disappeared forever.  AFAIK, they cannot be re-instated by anyone.

Perhaps in future, when you are repeatedly asked for a cite, you will provide it, to avoid such deletions.

yes just checked and it shows you have deleted several of your own posts....LOL

[Robittybob1]

what I have stated is common knowledge amongst those who have followed the case...why have you deleted your own posts which show you were simply not aware of the basic facts in this case

Maybe that is freedom of expression too.  Don't complain, as it means we too can delete comments after the event as well. 

[Mr Gray]

Because of Freedom of Speech.

playing the freedom of speech card...there is...and should not be...absolute freedom of speech

[ShiningInLuz]

So how could the mccanns counter this sort of campaign when amaral was able to claim he could prove maddie died in the apartment........amaral was talking tosh and able to get away with it

Sitting on a large donations fighting fund, armed with a supposedly top PR adviser, free from judicial secrecy, in possession of professionally-translated PJ Files, being an ultra hot topic in Portugal, and of course having first-hand access to inside information, allegedly believing that an on-going search in Portugal was critical?

Are you being serious?

Here's a thought.  Countering Amaral might well have brought in yet more cash for the Find Madeleine fund, both via appearance money and donations.

[Mr Gray]

Sitting on a large donations fighting fund, armed with a supposedly top PR adviser, free from judicial secrecy, in possession of professionally-translated PJ Files, being an ultra hot topic in Portugal, and of course having first-hand access to inside information, allegedly believing that an on-going search in Portugal was critical?

Are you being serious?

Here's a thought.  Countering Amaral might well have brought in yet more cash for the Find Madeleine fund, both via appearance money and donations.

amaral has told lies...we have established that
he is backed by portuguese TV
portugues press
Portuguese courts



amaral cannot be countered in portugal ...you are delusional if you think he can be

[ShiningInLuz]

perhaps it isnt common knowledge...it seems some of those pontificating about the case simply are not aware of the true facts in this case. ....sil has deleted some  of her own posts which shows she was not aware of things amaral has said...sil thought amaral was proposing a thesis whereas he was stating things as facts

I deleted several of my own posts since they contained material that could be deemed libellous in the absence of a cite from you.  Fácil.

[ShiningInLuz]

perhaps it isnt common knowledge...it seems some of those pontificating about the case simply are not aware of the true facts in this case. ....sil has deleted some  of her own posts which shows she was not aware of things amaral has said...sil thought amaral was proposing a thesis whereas he was stating things as facts

No doubt you will inform the Portuguese legal authorities of this, just in case Duarte hasn't.