Goncalo Amaral interviewed after the Appeal Court decision.

[stephen25000]

He was wrong with his understanding of the dog alerts and the forensic evidence
SY have said the McCanns are not suspects so therefore consider him wrong in thinking the parents are guilty

Redwood also said, Madeleine could have died in the apartment.

[ferryman]

So you think it's fortunate that GA was prevented from proving M died in the apartment?

That, of course, is a post of outright libel.

Which I am guilty of repeating, making me, also, guilty of libel.

[Robittybob1]

So you think it's fortunate that GA was prevented from proving M died in the apartment?

I don't think the proof would have stood scrutiny.  They had the chance to take samples etc from the apartment before he was demoted.

[Robittybob1]

You are happy that no matter whether he was right or wrong and with the possibility that he may have been able to find out what happened to Madeleine, he wasn't allowed to progress the case.

We have to accept that his bosses felt the same way.

[Robittybob1]

You mean fantasies, such as abduction Brietta ?

What is the forensic test for abduction?

[Mr Gray]

Redwood also said, Madeleine could have died in the apartment.

as we have discussed a million times before....parents not suspects...maddie could have died in the aprtment
of course she could but as the parents are not suspects not at the hands of her parents

[Mr Gray]

if amaral can prove maddie died in the aparatment he should presnt his evidence to the pj....if not simply post it on the net


he cannot....a lot of peopele have been fooled by amaral

[stephen25000]

as we have discussed a million times before....parents not suspects...maddie could have died in the aprtment
of course she could but as the parents are not suspects not at the hands of her parents

Indeed, accidental death.

That has not been disproved.

By the way, who said her parents as regards that ?

[Robittybob1]

Indeed, accidental death.

That has bot been disproved.

By the way, who said her parents as regards that ?

I knew you would be excited about Davel's post.

[stephen25000]

if amaral can prove maddie died in the aparatment he should presnt his evidence to the pj....if not simply post it on the net


he cannot....a lot of peopele have been fooled by amaral

Again dave.

People did not need Amaral to consider accidental death as a scenario.

Try remembering that, it would help.

[Mr Gray]

Indeed, accidental death.

That has bot been disproved.

By the way, who said her parents as regards that ?

if redwood suspected an accidental death the the parents would be suspects so no


as we have discussed...no one has been able to come up with an accident scenario that fits the time frame
and expalin why the mccanns would cover it up
and exaplin why they havee kept the case open for ten years...absolutely barmy

[stephen25000]

I knew you would be excited about Davel's post.

That is not the description I would use.

[Mr Gray]

Again dave.

People did not need Amaral to consider accidental death as a scenario.

Try remembering that, it would help.

I have never said that
... you are imagining things...oh dear

[stephen25000]

if redwood suspected an accidental death the the parents would be suspects so no


as we have discussed...no one has been able to come up with an accident scenario that fits the time frame
and expalin why the mccanns would cover it up
and exaplin why they havee kept the case open for ten years...absolutely barmy

Agreeing with yourself dave, is not discussion.

[Mr Gray]

Agreeing with yourself dave, is not discussion.

you are imagining things again...oh dear