Author Topic: Australian Ch7 documentary claims new lead in search for missing Madeleine McCann.  (Read 59406 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline John

No
He says he will prove in the next hour
In his documentary
He's quite clear
If the pj had proof Maddie died in the apartment then the McCanns would be arrested
Gross speculation with no basis in fact

As you have argued many times, evidence is not proof.
A malicious prosecution for a crime which never existed. An exposé of egregious malfeasance by public officials.
Indeed, the truth never changes with the passage of time.

Offline ShiningInLuz

Pleasing to note the (steadily more apparent) abandonment of discussion of (Amaral's) allegations of what they are (supposed!) to have done.

It's all about 'neglect', now, explicitly rejected by the Portuguese prosecutors, together with other, far more serious crimes, equally emphatically rejected by the Portuguese prosecutors.

And yet Amaral is accorded 'free speech' to make these baseless allegations.
The bit I have bolded is plain wrong.
What's up, old man?

Offline John

kate mcann was the last person to  check on the kids   not accusing but you can see why portugese police   found that suspicious

Amaral seems convinced that Kate was involved in something.  Wasn't that why she was offered a deal during the arguido interview?  Admit involvement to accidental death and we will go easy on you or words to that effect.

As most people know, it is a fact of life that the parents or family of any missing child should be investigated first and foremost when one disappears in suspicious circumstances.  It is a fine balance for investigators between upsetting already distraught parents and getting to the truth.  Some Portuguese police think Amaral delayed far too long in what he did and should have insisted on a reconstruction early on.
« Last Edit: April 24, 2017, 02:33:39 PM by John »
A malicious prosecution for a crime which never existed. An exposé of egregious malfeasance by public officials.
Indeed, the truth never changes with the passage of time.

Offline ShiningInLuz


Dear Stephen,  I don't have any great argument with you.  I understand perfectly, how The Supreme Court arrived at their decision, and how The Judge in The First Instance arrived at hers.

So, we have a Legal Difference of Opinion.  I think that this is the whole point.  Who won or lost is actually irrelevant.  And I have no doubt that The McCanns can see this as well.
If you actually believe the two sentences I have bolded, then we have a major difference of opinion.  I believe it could have a major impact re a future search for Madeleine, should OG shut down.  But I would rather wait and see what happens than argue the point now.
What's up, old man?

Offline misty

Amaral seems convinced that Kate was involved in something.  Wasn't that why she was offered a deal during the arguido interview?  Admit involvement to accidental death and we will go easy on you or words to that effect.

So why wasn't the same "misunderstanding" offered to Gerry?
Cue Martin Smith's phone call......

Offline John

So why wasn't the same "misunderstanding" offered to Gerry?
Cue Martin Smith's phone call......

That would have been an accomplice after the fact.
A malicious prosecution for a crime which never existed. An exposé of egregious malfeasance by public officials.
Indeed, the truth never changes with the passage of time.

Offline Eleanor

even if there was you would never accept it  you believe the  mcanns  as  gospel

This comment simply will not do.  There is no evidence of parental involvement, so it cannot be said what Ferryman would do if there was.

Please don't say this again.

Offline Eleanor

Ah, but what will OG say tomorrow or maybe the day after?  Will they be that bold or will they hedge their bets?

Will you believe what they say?

Offline Eleanor

It was probably a mistake by the translators. Can you prove that the translation is correct?

A Mistake by The Translators is always a good one.  If it suits you.

Offline Eleanor

kate mcann was the last person to  check on the kids   not accusing but you can see why portugese police   found that suspicious

No.  Not really.  Madeleine wasn't there.  Do you think Kate managed to dispose of Madeleine in barely ten minutes?

Offline The Singularity

Amaral seems convinced that Kate was involved in something.  Wasn't that why she was offered a deal during the arguido interview? 

I remember this being reported on the forums and thought it really quite forward of Snr Amaral, however I have since googled this and it was in fact another internet rumour and Snr Amaral says he did not offer Mrs McCann a deal strangely enough.

TPN: Did the police offer a plea bargain to Kate McCann?
GA: No.
TPN: But did you not suggest she consider a plea bargain?
GA: We only explained the nature of certain crimes. Her lawyer was there, you can ask him.

Link

Offline Eleanor

As you have argued many times, evidence is not proof.

"Prove",  John.

Offline Eleanor

Amaral seems convinced that Kate was involved in something.  Wasn't that why she was offered a deal during the arguido interview?  Admit involvement to accidental death and we will go easy on you or words to that effect.

As most people know, it is a fact of life that the parents or family of any missing child should be investigated first and foremost when one disappears in suspicious circumstances.  It is a fine balance for investigators between upsetting already distraught parents and getting to the truth.  Some Portuguese police think Amaral delayed far too long in what he did and should have insisted on a reconstruction early on.

But Amaral refused to do a Reconstruction early on.

Offline Mr Gray

If you actually believe the two sentences I have bolded, then we have a major difference of opinion.  I believe it could have a major impact re a future search for Madeleine, should OG shut down.  But I would rather wait and see what happens than argue the point now.

the SC made it clear taht they have made no judgement on the guilt or innocence of the mccanns...in fact they are not in a postion to....so the thought that their  judgeemnt can have a major impact on a future search seems more than a tad ridiculous

Offline Mr Gray

As you have argued many times, evidence is not proof.

I understand that...it seems amaral doesnt