What Happened To Madeleine McCann? - by Ian Horrocks.

[Alfie]

It is fascinating to observe those who  support Horrocks, knowing full well his incompetency in the Jill Dando case, as regards Barry George.

Also, he nailed his colours to the McCann supporting Sun, which tells us everything we need to know about Horrocks.

He has merely provided his jaundiced view of the case, even though he doesn't know what crime occurred.

Enough said.

Yes, he's provided his view to which he is entitled - do you think he's been paid to have this view and isn't sincere or something?  Attack the substance of what he says, not the man himself if you can.  What in his theory is implausible or illogical?

[stephen25000]

Yes, he's provided his view to which he is entitled - do you think he's been paid to have this view and isn't sincere or something?  Attack the substance of what he says, not the man himself if you can.  What in his theory is implausible or illogical?

It's all hypothetical.

Has he had access to all the PJ files on the case ?

Has he interviewed the parties concerned ?

[faithlilly]

Yes, he's provided his view to which he is entitled - do you think he's been paid to have this view and isn't sincere or something?  Attack the substance of what he says, not the man himself if you can.  What in his theory is implausible or illogical?

Horrocks was paid for his opinion, agreed? In this country Horrocks would not have been able to postulate a theory in the media with the McCanns as perpetrators, agreed? QED if he wanted paid this theory, or similar, was his only choice.

It really isn't rocket science.

[stephen25000]

Horrocks was paid for his opinion, agreed? In this country Horrocks would not have been able to postulate a theory in the media with the McCanns as perpetrators, agreed? QED if he wanted paid this theory, or similar, was his only choice.

It really isn't rocket science.

That Faithlilly precisely summarizes the situation.

[Alfie]

Horrocks was paid for his opinion, agreed? In this country Horrocks would not have been able to postulate a theory in the media with the McCanns as perpetrators, agreed? QED if he wanted paid this theory, or similar, was his only choice.

It really isn't rocket science.

Even if he was paid a million pounds for it it's a pretty decent theory that is plausible and logical and hangs well on the known facts of the case, unlike theory of parental involvement that I have read in ten years (including yours).

[stephen25000]

Even if he was paid a million pounds for it it's a pretty decent theory that is plausible and logical and hangs well on the known facts of the case, unlike theory of parental involvement that I have read in ten years (including yours).

Nope, it's a view you like, because it doesn't involve the McCann's.

He has b....r all facts, let alone evidence to deal with.

He hasn't interviewed the McCann's, or watch them under interview as regards being questioned about the events.

I trust the police on the ground in 2007, who saw what the McCann's did at the time, and the way they responded and behaved.

To top that, no evidence to support abduction was found.

P.S. What trail has been uncovered as regards kidnappers, burglars or paedophiles ?

[faithlilly]

Firstly I don't think it's necessary for a policeman to have direct contact with an individual to assess their character. Whether that assessment would be accurate is doubtful.

As to character flaws, is wanting to protect one's family from criminal charges potentially leading to financial ruin and the splitting up of that family really a character flaw?

[faithlilly]

Even if he was paid a million pounds for it it's a pretty decent theory that is plausible and logical and hangs well on the known facts of the case, unlike theory of parental involvement that I have read in ten years (including yours).

It's speculative at best, as is mine.

[stephen25000]

Here's an easy and open question for all McCann's supporters to answer.

If there was no 'abduction', where does it leave the McCann's ?

[Mr Gray]

The fact is that it's not just Horrocks saying abduction is the most likely
It's just about every informed report
Amaral and his coffin however are completely on their own

[Mr Gray]

Here's an easy and open question for all McCann's supporters to answer.

If there was no 'abduction', where does it leave the McCann's ?

You tell us where you think it leaves them

[stephen25000]

P.S. I'm just watching some sniffer dogs being deployed, and would you believe it, they play as they search.

[Robittybob1]

Here's an easy and open question for all McCann's supporters to answer.

If there was no 'abduction', where does it leave the McCann's ?

They would still have their nuclear family of 5 instead of 4.

[stephen25000]

They would still have their nuclear family of 5 instead of 4.

Let's try again Rob.

Madeleine disappeared, FACT.

Where does it leave the McCann's if she wasn't abducted  when she disappeared?

I await cogent replies.

[Mr Gray]

P.S. I'm just watching some sniffer dogs being deployed, and would you believe it, they play as they search.

Really
And does the handler keep bringing them back to spots they have previously ignored