Casting aside prejudices; given the manpower, materiel, technology and access to world wide data bases the average national police force has one does really wonder just what the "armchair and notso armchair detective" believes they can bring to the party short of witnessing the event ?
In certain circumstances, yes, I find it possible.
You don't have to be a witness to the event to offer specialist knowledge, if you have any: e.g., engineers, builders, architects contacting the police to alert them to details of a particular construction / demolition in the area of interest, for example.
Or, if someone suddenly stumbles on something odd while clearing out a deceased great-uncle's attic that raises a suspicion (still not a direct witness to the events).
Or, any member of the public who notices something potentially relevant that the police may not have been aware of even if it turns out to be a dead-end.
However, this doesn't appear to be the case in this latest tabloid saga.