Where is the alert on Cuddle Cat happening and is it on video?

[slartibartfast]

Eddie alerted TWICE in the dining area whilst on camera, the result of which was the production of CC from a distant cupboard.

So are you saying there was no alert to CC contrary to Grime’s statement?

[Mr Gray]

It would have been better had he used a term of certainty e.g 80% certain or even 99.9% if he was really certain.

One has to wonder why he didn't... But I have my ideas

[misty]

So are you saying there was no alert to CC contrary to Grime’s statement?

Unless there is an alert we can't see, then yes. If there was another alert not filmed, then why is there no mention in Grime's report of the 2 we can hear in the video to something in the dining area?

[slartibartfast]

Unless there is an alert we can't see, then yes. If there was another alert not filmed, then why is there no mention in Grime's report of the 2 we can hear in the video to something in the dining area?

Maybe it’s because you’re not the dog handler and can’t identify when the dog alerts?

[Robittybob1]

So are you saying there was no alert to CC contrary to Grime’s statement?

What is an alert and where did it happen?

[Vertigo Swirl]

Maybe it’s because you’re not the dog handler and can’t identify when the dog alerts?

I thought the dog barked when it alerted?  It doesn’t take a dog handler to know when a dog has barked.

[Mr Gray]

So Eddie was brought... At great expense... With a world class record in cadaver detection. I bet the PJ couldn't wait to have this incredible tool at their disposal... They waited with baited breath... Incredibly rddie alerted to CC... But they didn't bother to do any forensic tests... What's going on

[Robittybob1]

So Eddie was brought... At great expense... With a world class record in cadaver detection. I bet the PJ couldn't wait to have this incredible tool at their disposal... They waited with baited breath... Incredibly rddie alerted to CC... But they didn't bother to do any forensic tests... What's going on

Have you just clicked onto this joke?

[misty]

Maybe it’s because you’re not the dog handler and can’t identify when the dog alerts?

Perhaps you would explain, for the benefit of this ignoramus, the difference between Eddie's alert beside the wardrobe in 5A & the one beside the chair in the villa?

[slartibartfast]

Perhaps you would explain, for the benefit of this ignoramus, the difference between Eddie's alert beside the wardrobe in 5A & the one beside the chair in the villa?

I’m not a dog handler either, would you like to go and check the FSS got their forensics right?

[Mr Gray]

I’m not a dog handler either, would you like to go and check the FSS got their forensics right?

Are you suggesting they didnt

[slartibartfast]

Are you suggesting they didnt

I’m suggesting that our opinions on the FSS are as relevant as our opinions on Grime.

[misty]

I’m not a dog handler either, would you like to go and check the FSS got their forensics right?

Forensic science does not rely on the interpretation of a vocal alert made by a dog trained primarily on pig; it's a little more complicated than that. I can, however, see no distinction, visual or aural, between the 2 alerts I mentioned in my previous post.

[Mr Gray]

I’m suggesting that our opinions on the FSS are as relevant as our opinions on Grime.

Absolutely  not IMO.... DNA has tons of science supporting it... Grime has no real scientific  evidence to support his alerts

[Vertigo Swirl]

I’m suggesting that our opinions on the FSS are as relevant as our opinions on Grime.

Are you suggesting that as far as Gime and his dogs are concerned we should just accept everything he says or his dogs suggest without question?