What evidence would confirm a cadaver dog alert?

[Mr Gray]

Well how do you explain the catch 22 situation in http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=9966.msg536179#msg536179?

I don't  see it as ambiguous... Grime says the alers were not corroborated... Even though DNA, was found... So that's clear.
Then as the alert is not corroborated an alert to cadaver odour is only a, possibility

[Angelo222]

Well how do you explain the catch 22 situation in http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=9966.msg536179#msg536179?

Well tell us, how does Grime define corroboration?

You can link to the actual post by clicking on its header bar before copying and pasting.

[Angelo222]

I don't  see it as ambiguous... Grime says the alers were not corroborated... Even though DNA, was found... So that's clear.
Then as the alert is not corroborated an alert to cadaver odour is only a, possibility

I think it's more than that. IMO, Eddie did alert to substances for which he was trained but it has no relevance to Maddie's disappearance.

To be honest, every time I think about Cuddle Cat and the claims about him I have to laugh.  That farce wasn't Grime's finest hour imo.

[Mr Gray]

I think it's more than that. IMO, Eddie did alert to substances for which he was trained but it has no relevance to Maddie's disappearance.

To be honest, every time I think about Cuddle Cat and the claims about him I have to laugh.  That farce wasn't Grime's finest hour imo.

not grimes finest hour at all

[Robittybob1]

You can link to the actual post by clicking on its header bar before copying and pasting.

OK I'll try it! So can you explain the sequence please. 

[pathfinder73]

I think it's more than that. IMO, Eddie did alert to substances for which he was trained but it has no relevance to Maddie's disappearance.

To be honest, every time I think about Cuddle Cat and the claims about him I have to laugh.  That farce wasn't Grime's finest hour imo.

I think it is most revealing that Eddie only picked out the toy seen on the missing child's bed at the crime scene. Did he pick out another toy in the villa? No he did not and there's a good reason why!

[Robittybob1]

I think it is most revealing that Eddie only picked out the toy seen on the missing child's bed at the crime scene. Did he pick out another toy in the villa? No he did not and there's a good reason why!

OK so what is the reason?

[Brietta]

I think it is most revealing that Eddie only picked out the toy seen on the missing child's bed at the crime scene. Did he pick out another toy in the villa? No he did not and there's a good reason why!

The investigating officers were singularly unimpressed by Eddie and Cuddle cat and said as much in their final report.

[pathfinder73]

OK so what is the reason?

It's obvious with all the other alerts. SY were looking for a body in Luz - that's where most of their millions went.

[Mr Gray]

The investigating officers were singularly unimpressed by Eddie and Cuddle cat and said as much in their final report.

as I remember the pj questioned the way the alerts occurred

[Robittybob1]

It's obvious with all the other alerts. SY were looking for a body in Luz - that's where most of their millions went.

I have completely lost my patience with you, and from now on all your posts will be deleted unless they are fully explanatory.

[Robittybob1]

as I remember the pj questioned the way the alerts occurred

Can you provide the actual cite please?

[Brietta]

The dog still alerted to the toy that the missing child's mother had recently washed when it was hidden in the cupboard.

If anyone believes it was washed because it was filthy with suntan lotion, that's their preoperative. But washing her missing daughter's favorite soft toy wasn't Kate McCann's finest hour IMO.

Did it ?
Can you show me where the confirmation for that is in the forensic reports?

[The General]

The dog still alerted to the toy that the missing child's mother had recently washed when it was hidden in the cupboard.

If anyone believes it was washed because it was filthy with suntan lotion, that's their preoperative. But washing her missing daughter's favorite soft toy wasn't Kate McCann's finest hour IMO.

This further illustrates my somewhat contentious point / opinion re: moral adjustment.
I doubt you will find a single female, mother, supporter here who will support the notion that, if this toy was as precious as has been purported (Gerry's favourite word), then no mother would want to wash away the scent of their missing child. Moreover, I suggest that's more to do with a stoical support than their actual opinion, morally incongruent or not.

[Erngath]

This further illustrates my somewhat contentious point / opinion re: moral adjustment.
I doubt you will find a single female, mother, supporter here who will support the notion that, if this toy was as precious as has been purported (Gerry's favourite word), then no mother would want to wash away the scent of their missing child. Moreover, I suggest that's more to do with a stoical support than their actual opinion, morally incongruent or not.

Do children have a scent?
Can you explain?

When I had a class of children, some smelled of the shampoo used in their hair, some smelled of the washing powder and fabric conditioner used to wash their clothes, sometimes some smelled of a an ointment put on for grazes, some children sadly smelled of unclean bodies and unclean clothes.

What makes up the smell of an individual child?

Is a child born with a scent particular to itself?