What evidence would confirm a cadaver dog alert?

[Mr Gray]

Was the dog in question Eddie?  Not all cadaver dogs equal?  SIL is finding his cadaver dog is finding all sorts of cadavers.

Sil doesn't have a cadaver dog

[Vertigo Swirl]

Was the dog in question Eddie?  Not all cadaver dogs equal?  SIL is finding his cadaver dog is finding all sorts of cadavers.

Eddie was an Enhanced VRD, the only one there has ever been.  He was the Top of the heap.  Best nose in the business.  Never wrong.  A Superdog.  All others pale into insignificance. 

[Wonderfulspam]

https://www.standard.co.uk/news/human-bone-at-centre-of-jersey-childrens-home-inquiry-is-actually-a-piece-of-wood-or-coconut-shell-6658362.html

Interesting, nothing in that article proves Eddie was alerting to the coconut shell.

[Mr Gray]

Interesting, nothing in that article proves Eddie was alerting to the coconut shell.

You are absolutely  right... And nothing proves Edie alerted to cadaver or keela alerted to blood in PDL... Have a coconut

[Robittybob1]

Sil doesn't have a cadaver dog

A dog that finds road kill is still a cadaver dog in my book.

[Vertigo Swirl]

Interesting, nothing in that article proves Eddie was alerting to the coconut shell.

Gosh.  You’re quite right.
Apart from this bit of course.
“The scientists, led by the lab's deputy director, Dr Tom Higham, were so concerned by Mr Harper's continued insistence that the fragment was human bone that they wrote to him formally on May 1.

They restated their findings and added that they had been endorsed by a second opinion from a leading bone expert, palaeontologist Dr Roger Jacobi.

"We concluded that the sample was not in fact bone but almost certainly a piece of wood," the letter said.

"Its curvature may have had something to do with it being misidentified. It appears to be more likely a seed casing or a small piece of coconut. Our conclusion is that this sample is a) not bone and b) not human."

[Vertigo Swirl]

A dog that finds road kill is still a cadaver dog in my book.

Do you actually know what a cadaver is?

[Mr Gray]

A dog that finds road kill is still a cadaver dog in my book.

But not in my book

[Wonderfulspam]

Gosh.  You’re quite right.
Apart from this bit of course.
“The scientists, led by the lab's deputy director, Dr Tom Higham, were so concerned by Mr Harper's continued insistence that the fragment was human bone that they wrote to him formally on May 1.

They restated their findings and added that they had been endorsed by a second opinion from a leading bone expert, palaeontologist Dr Roger Jacobi.

"We concluded that the sample was not in fact bone but almost certainly a piece of wood," the letter said.

"Its curvature may have had something to do with it being misidentified. It appears to be more likely a seed casing or a small piece of coconut. Our conclusion is that this sample is a) not bone and b) not human."

How does any of that prove what Eddie was alerting to?

[Mr Gray]

How does any of that prove what Eddie was alerting to?

No-one knows, what Eddie was alerting to... That's, the whole point

[Vertigo Swirl]

How does any of that prove what Eddie was alerting to?

The sample was “not in fact bone”.  So what was it?  It doesn’t really matter if it was a coconut or a coco pop.  It wasn’t human.  FACT.

[Wonderfulspam]

No-one knows, what Eddie was alerting to... That's, the whole point

I know.

So why do you & Eleanor claim he alerted to a coconut?

[Wonderfulspam]

The sample was “not in fact bone”.  So what was it?  It doesn’t really matter if it was a coconut or a coco pop.  It wasn’t human.  FACT.

Prove Eddie alerted to that item.

[Mr Gray]

I know.

So why do you & Eleanor claim he alerted to a coconut?

No you don't... And... To prove a point... Which I did

[Vertigo Swirl]

Prove Eddie alerted to that item.

It’s not for me to prove it, it’s for the scientists who proved that what he alerted to did not originate from a human.  Do you think those responsible for excavating the site missed all the human remains and only submitted the coconut shell for analysis?