If Brueckner is Never Charged.

[barrier]

I agree, Davel. The prosecutor’s reply that they have no body or any parts of the body gave me the impression that he chose his words very carefully. To me, this statement may well be a ‘clue’ as to what they have as evidence.

A family member would have to confirm it was Madeleine if it exist's, there is no evidence to suggest this has been done.

[Mr Gray]

I beleive Sadie claims she has evidence in the form of a video which show's Madeleine alive in 2012,also she claims she passed it on to OG, ,OG still class it has a missing persons case,how does that fit in with the claims of the Germans.

the Germans havent shared the evidence as Ive explained

[Mr Gray]

A family member would have to confirm it was Madeleine if it exist's, there is no evidence to suggest this has been done.

That would explain why the Germans refer to it as concrete evidence rather than proof

[barrier]

the Germans havent shared the evidence as Ive explained

Which is a strange turn of events if true with simultaneous statements back in early June.

[barrier]

That would explain why the Germans refer to it as concrete evidence rather than proof

Where is the original German statement.

[John]

I would say the prosecutors office have strong evidence maddie is dead...thats what theyve said. The mcCanns have been left to the lynch mob for the past 13 years led by the PJ

If that was the case, it is protocol to have shared such with the parents. Since that hasn't happened...

[John]

If ,as seems more and more likely, the German police never have enough concrete evidence to charge Brueckner with a part in Madeleine’s disappearance would those who think he is guilty accept the termination of Operation Grange ?

Operation Grange appear to be doing their own thing regardless.

[Mr Gray]

If that was the case, it is protocol to have shared such with the parents. Since that hasn't happened...

The Germans will have their reasons...protocol is not hard and fast rules. Breukner may or may not be involved....i think based on everything its highly possible he is. This upsets sceptics who resort to trying to undermine the professionalism of the German police. I know Germany....the police are far from unproffesional

[Mr Gray]

Operation Grange appear to be doing their own thing regardless.

I dont think they are...i recall is was co operation re the phone traffic that highlighted Breukner. SY may be a little peeved taht the Germans are not sharing the evidence....and thats why they insist on calling it  amissing person case. Until SY have that evidence they have no choice but to refer to it as a missing person case

[Holly Goodhead]

The Germans will have their reasons...protocol is not hard and fast rules. Breukner may or may not be involved....i think based on everything its highly possible he is. This upsets sceptics who resort to trying to undermine the professionalism of the German police. I know Germany....the police are far from unproffesional

I'm not a 'sceptic' and even Germany's deputy director general of the judicial system division, federal ministry of justice has criticed the prosecutor's office.

Why do you believe the prosecutor's office in Germany has intelligence about MM unknown to MET/PJ? 

[jassi]

A family member would have to confirm it was Madeleine if it exist's, there is no evidence to suggest this has been done.

Not if it was just a few bones.  DNA test would be required.

[Mr Gray]

its quite noticable how some posters have become awre of trial by media.....and the necessity to sue the media...when they have been blind to both of these for the past 13 years.

[Carana]

If that was the case, it is protocol to have shared such with the parents. Since that hasn't happened...

I'll wait for more facts to emerge.

Either the German prosecutor is on a fishing expedition (which I find unlikely for the moment as this case involves a British subject who disappeared in Portugal) or he has valid reasons to limit what could be leaked via all those fluttering fans in tabloid media newsrooms...

[Venturi Swirl]

I beleive Sadie claims she has evidence in the form of a video which show's Madeleine alive in 2012,also she claims she passed it on to OG, ,OG still class it has a missing persons case,how does that fit in with the claims of the Germans.

It doesn't.  Do you believe Madeleine is still alive then? 

[Mr Gray]

I'm not a 'sceptic' and even Germany's deputy director general of the judicial system division, federal ministry of justice has criticed the prosecutor's office.

Why do you believe the prosecutor's office in Germany has intelligence about MM unknown to MET/PJ?

Its  a fact...they have the memory sticks....that may well be the evidence.